I made a box joint jig and wanted to try it out. I had a couple of pieces of black walnut that were too thin to be useful but too pretty to throw away. I used them to practice on. This is the result. Sides are Austrailian beefwood.
Got to modify a few things on the next one. Think I might use Macasser Ebony for the top and Zebra or Bolivian Rosewood for the sides and bottom.
Beautiful box but may I suggest that such good work needs a better than stamped brass latch. Lots of others are available - if you do not want to add a key. Away from the catalogs you might want to look to science instrument or surveying wood boxes as examples.
That is a spectacular box. I have two or three suggestions. I have made about a dozen boxes and observed a few things along the way.
The beefwood is beautiful, I have never seen it in person, but I think its a bit too thick. Maybe a 1/16 or even and 1/8" thinner?
The walnut is fabulous, Way too good for the bottom of the box, save it to use on the top of another box, and use something tough and plain like 1/8" plywood.
Don't recess the walnut quite so far down into the box, maybe half that far.
Probably does not matter with beefwood, but learn the trick of making the grain match all the way around the box for something like zebra wood.
Boxes are fun. endless possibilities. Hand made hardware, wooden hinges, on and on.
About the grain matching. I did not mean top to bottom, you did a great job on that. I was talking about wrapping the grain all the way around the box. You can do three corners by using a single board long enoguh to make all four sides and then cross cut it into four pieces and keep them in order with the same face out. "Fold" them around carefully in order and maintaining the orientation they were in in the board and the grain will continue around three of the corners, but not the fourth.
If you use a piece of stock half as long but twice as thick and resaw it, you can make all four corners match. (I wish I could draw this for you) Easy enough to do, hard to explain. Also, it may matter more with mitered corners and wood that has wild stripey grain.
In your case, the box joint corners might make my method less important, or at least less obvious.
I couldn't tell. I thought your box was a beauty. I was just trying to offer encouragement. If this was a practice piece, let us see what you do when you really get wound up
Yeah. I got off into turning for quite a while and haven't done much flatwork except frames for the pictures my Dad painted for family. I could get carried away.
Good for you! If we didn't have personal preferences, and standards of quality, we might as well be buying all our furniture and accessories at IKEA or WalMart.
Your cracks are on the bottom of the box, so they may or may not be important to you. Filling with pigmented epoxy is just one way to salvage a piece of otherwise beautifully figured wood, and can help if you discover a hidden defect late in the game, after building a piece around some limited amount of highly figured stock. Of course, it's always up to the designer whether to accentuate the natural variability, or try to obscure it, or start over with new stock for the panel.
I guess my perspective is: 1. I like the way the top and bottom are sort of bookmatched when it's open, 2. The deep sawmarks on the bottom are something I'll probably never look at so they don't bother me, 3. There is also a small flaw in the top that I missed but isn't very noticible (wabi sabi) and 4. I saved two very beautiful pieces of wood while learning that I can trust the jig I made and also some important things about the processes of doing this specific type box.
Since it was a practice piece that I'm going to be using as a piggy bank I didn't expect it to be more than what I ended up with. Actually, I ended up with more than I expected. The beefwood is nasty stuff and I used it, more or less, to "get rid of" some of it. I found that I really love the way it looks once finished. I'll be using the rest of what I have for real projects. I may wear gloves when working with it though.
Oh, I almost forgot, 5. I got a lot of interesting & useful comments. Thanks.
If you use a piece of stock half as long but twice as thick and resaw it, you can make all four corners match. (I wish I could draw this for you) Easy enough to do, hard to explain.
This poked around in my subconcious till last night before bed. All of a sudden it popped out and I saw how to do it. Thanks. Never would have thought about it otherwise.
It's similar in concept and geometry to bookmatching. The lengths rotate through 180° (so they are verticle with the cut surface out rather than in) instead of 90° (giving a horizontal plane). You could use them the way they are re-sawed, but the match would be close but not perfect. By rotating them you get a virtually exact match.
You're absolutely right. It's extremely easy to do, and show - to describe, not so much.
I'll probably use the trick on all my boxes regardless of figure/grain of the side wood. No reason not to and for a lot of wood it will make a difference. Once again thanks.
After you resaw and cut the corners, figure where you are going to slice it to cut the top off, use a saw blade that cuts a flat bottom groove (rip blade?) and cut a rabbet on the inside that is slightly over half the depth of the thickness of the sides. Make the rabbet slightly wider than the thickness of the blade. Then assemble the box, remembering where the rabbet is. And and clean up the exterior and rip the lid off, With the outer cut just off set from the inner one and slightly over half the thickness. (Again, easy to draw, not explain.)
Then you end up with a rabbeted joint that allows the top to telescope down over the rabbeted edge of the bottom. Keeps the lid nicely centered on the box. You can still hinge the lid if you like. And, You can play with the width of the rabbets and have a slight gap between the top and box on the exterior. Celebrate the joint. Sounds horrible until you see it. If you rip the lid off in a single pass and put hinges on it and it sits a few thousands wampass (highly scientific term) it looks like hell. I have had them sit with one corner raised less than the thickness of a sheet of paper and it sticks out like a sore thumb. If you put a 1/10" gap around the box, a tiny error does not show.
I had a kinda neat insight a few years ago that I have not tried yet, but feel confident would work.
If you are wanting to drill down the length of the whole lid, but know how slim the odds are of keeping the drill centered in the knuckles, here is my approach.
Find a metal hinge of the same proportions that you want to use. Then cut the spacing the same as it. The clamp the two together, to use the metal one as a drill guide. It should keep the drill centered down the length of the first inch, then enter the next metal knuckle, which would guide it into the next.
I would think that by using a aircraft drill, then moving the hinge along a few spaces, always making sure to always keep the bit in at least one metal finger, you could probably stay center all the way down the whole 12" of the drill.
Most metal hinges aren't very thick. That would make for thin wood walls. Unless you are talking about large passage door butt hinges, and then those have really big pins. Just not sure the proportions will work well in wood.
I made mine like box joints for corners, but rounded the knuckles so they could swing. Drilling them was a bit tricky. Found a numbered bit (No.60 IIRC) that was "just right" for the 1/8" brass rod. Keeping it centered was a problem and I lost a few because of it. OTOH, mine were never more than two inches wide.
I like your idea, but like Dick says, the geometry may be too small. Might be able to modify a metal hinge or have a machinist make something.
I saw one that was several feet long and am still ciphering on how they did that.
I have a few other things I would try. Yet, you know a box lid really doesn't have to do much, unless someone opens it hard beyond it's limit of movement.
I haven't made any boxes in a long time, but one idea I thought I might try to strengthen the wood, would be after drilling, to then really soak the wood with CPES, although I need to do some test with it. I know it will make a soft wood a lot harder, but I don't know if it really adds a lot to the tensile strength.
As for choosing a hinge to use for a jig, obviously a piano hinge would be too small, and a door hinge would would need too large a pin, so something in about the 2.5" range would be better. However, the offset on a larger, say 4.5" hinge would get the center over more, and I was thinking about making bushings to reduce down to about 1/8", then using a bronze brazing rod for the pin.
Although I picked up a pack of bamboo skewers from the grocery store a while back, thinking they would come in handy for whenever I need a small dowel with good strength. They are a lot stronger than the dowels I see being sold around here, and they are cheap.
Sounds wonderful. I'm going to have to let this percolate in my subconcious for a while and hope it pops out. If not I'll take a pencil, paper, and some pieces of wood and try to work out what you are describing.
(Update: didn't need to percolate long - I got it. Very neat trick!)
I wonder if the overlap along the top and bottom sides would throw out the match of the grain (or if I'm not visualizing it properly). (Update: I cut the box tops off using a re-saw blade on the bandsaw to get as thin a kerf as possible. This trick wouldn't work doing the cut that way. I'll have to see how much it disrupts the grain of something strong figured.) Maybe a contrasting inlay from the same wood as the top & bottom. Lot's to think about. I can feel my self getting hooked on boxes for a while. My lathe might get lonely. It's so much easier to finish sand flat stuff. LOL
As far as a flat bottom cut - once blade from a dado set should work to give an 1/8th channel. Don't know that I'd trust the 1/16th chipper from a set but it might work if the feed was slow. It wouldn't be cutting very deep. Might be worth a try. A shaper head only has 3 cutting blades and it's making a heck of a lot more contact with the wood.
I worried about disrupting the grain too, but as I recall it wasn't much of a problem.
As far as cutting the grooves goes, just use a rip blade or any blade that cuts a clean flat bottom groove and run the wood through twice, offsetting the cut slightly.
Set this up so that the groove on the exterior is about an 1/8" or maybe 3/64". It makes it look like the missing wood was in the groove. (???) Your eye compensates and fills in the details, much better than if you just slice the lid off and its obvious there is some missing. You can also paint the groove black for a stronger effect.
I made a pair of book-matched boxes for couple that were friends of mine. The boxes were fantastic. No matter which saw you turned them they were book matched. Tops and sides. Then the couple split up and each one took a box. Sigh!
In reply to hardware. So many. Look to Lee Valley Hardware Catalog who feature several alternatives. Londonderry. Whitechapel, Period Brass. Jamar. Van Dyke Restorers. Paxton. All have styles that might serve your purposes. Basically look and choose.