Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

Posts

Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#1

Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The next step in what seems an endless process to finish the drawers involves installing the bottoms. Some of these drawers are less than 2" tall so I did not what to loose any more of the internal space than I could get by with. The plan was to install 3/32" walnut veneer plywood into a rabbet cut into the bottom of the drawer.

I like to shellac the interior of drawers. Given the number I decided to prefinish the insides before fitting the bottom, an approach easier than finishing, sanding and final coating after the bottoms are in. That led to a future problem of how to glue the finished bottoms into the rabbet, as typical woodworking glue will not stick to a prefinished drawer bottom. I didn't come up with an entirely satisfactory solution. Any suggestions?


There was another problem to be solved. I cut the rabbets before gluing up the drawer. As a result there is a hole that shows on the outside of each drawer where the rabbets for the front and back drawer parts exit. See Picture 1


I solved this issue by making a stick of walnut with a cross section the size of the hole. I then glued the stick into the hole and sawed it off with a fine tooth flush saw as seen in Picture 2. In this case I left the filler long so that it would show up better in the photo.


When the glue set I pared the end flush with a chisel. The filler piece disappears into the end grain of the dovetail pin.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts

Ellis Walentine

I would have made the bottoms thicker than 3/32", probably about 3/16" (thin, tinny drawer bottoms are a pet peeve of mine), with a rabbet on the front and two sides to form tongues on those three edges, leaving the back edge square. Instead of rabbeting the drawer sides, I would have grooved the sides and front to receive the tongue and cut the back narrower so I could slide the bottom in from the back. This isn't necessary with a plywood bottom, but it does save you from having to plug umpteen gaps and pare them flush.

Ellis

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#3

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

Lars Parrington

You could rout the rebate for the bottom, after gluing and finishing the rest of the drawer. I'm thinking you'd do it on a router table, with a bit that has a bearing. This would solve the glue problem, and you wouldn't have to plug any holes.

You would have to do the extra step of chiseling the rebates square at the corners or rounding the corners of the bototm panels.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#4

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That's exactly how I make my drawers. Couple of headed brads up into the drawer-back and the bottoms are tight and strong.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#5

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

Paul in NJ

Hi Bill,

You could pre-fit the bottoms and mark the inside boundary on them. It will then be simple to tape them off to preserve the glue area. The drawer rabbets will be trickier. You can tape them or spot glue filler strips. Both sound like a lot of work. Have you considered not finishing? Traditionally I think this was rarely or never done.

I know this is hind-sight. Next time let the tails go all the way to the bottom, it will cover the rabbet in the drawer front. I think you might call it a half tail. On the back I normally leave the rabbet or groove off and just lap the bottom over it.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#6

Think tiny drawers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You may not understand how tiny these drawers are. The sides are barely more than 3/16" thick and some drawers are just a bit over 3" wide. Any thicker sides than I used would look clunky in such a tiny drawer. Visit the Jewelry Box contest winners to illustrate what a thick drawer looks like in a small cabinet. Well, tastes differ I guess for the winner had clunky drawers.

The 3/ 32" bottoms are more than stiff enough to hold even gold rings. If scaled to a 30" wide drawer the equivalent bottom would be nearly an inch thick.

While on the subject of drawer bottoms I think people use excessively thick bottoms on drawers leading to a heavy drawer. The English drawers I see that have survived for 200 years have bottoms about 3/8" thick and sides barely thicker. It makes for a light drawer, but one plenty strong enough to hold socks or even sweaters. I put a 35 pound lead brick in the middle of one of mine to demonstrate its adequacy. I have taken to making drawer bottoms 3/8 and making them out of some light weight wood like basswood, poplar or pine.

I hope Richard weighs in on this topic.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#7

Re: Think tiny drawers

Sgian Dubh

I guess you're asking me to comment Bill. I recall when judging the jewellery box contest making a somewhat negative comment about the chunkiness of the drawer sides in the winning piece. I agree with you therefore that slim sides are aesthetically more attractive.

Your comments on drawer part proportions ring pretty true with me, particularly those drawers made in the UK over the last couple of centuries. Typically, sides are about 3/8" or perhaps 1/2" thick, but bottoms, in my experience tend to be a thinner even that the 3/8" you mention, sometimes only 1/4" or so thick, even for large full width drawers as you might see in a fairly typical chest of drawers. The usual means to reduce the likelihood of sagging was to include a muntin or two, not always successfully I have to say.

In your case, my preference would have been to maintain the thickness of the various parts that you used, because I agree with your reasons for selecting those sizes: but I would have fitted the bottom much as Ellis suggested, i.e., run a groove in the sides and the rear face of the front, raise the drawer back above the groove, and slide the bottom in after the drawer was assembled. a 3/16" thick side is not too thin to run a 1/16" or 5/64" deep groove in my opinion, set up from the bottom edge by perhaps an 1/8" or 3/16". This configuration lets you hide the groove in the drawer front behind a drawer side dovetail.

You could even glue on a slip or wear strip under the drawer bottom to increase the wearing surface. True, you'd have lost a little storage space, but these drawers are so small that there's very little wood movement to concern yourself with, especially if you use something known for small or fairly small movement, e.g., mahogany, walnut, maple, etc, and the dimensions of the parts you've used are surely more than robust enough for the intended load. Slainte.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#8

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

Larry Barrett

I have a Secretary, made in Delaware Valley around 1775. Some of the drawers are made just as Bill describes. Sides and back are poplar, about 3/16", rabbet on the bottom all around. The small gap on the bottom tail on the back, which Bill fills in, are not filled in on these drawers. The bottom is pine, about 3/32" thick, and glued into the rabbet. Insides are not finished, so no glueing problem.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#9

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These would be the small drawers in the gallery?

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#10

Re: Question

Larry Barrett

Yes, small drawers in the gallery. There are six, three on each side. All are shallow - only 1 3/8" high (outside). But fairly side and deep. On each side there is one drawer close to 13" side and 10" deep. Above that are two drawers each 6 1/2" wide and 10" deep. Thin pine on the bottom of each.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#11

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like ...

Ellis Walentine

... there is some precedence for thin bottoms and rabbeted sides, but those are things I would modify in a piece that I was making. Glue alone shouldn't be made to hold a bottom up into a rabbet; some mechanical help makes engineering sense, e.g., the t&g joint. As for the thin bottom, to me it's a matter of preference. It's not that it won't hold your spices, but it doesn't feel and sound solid.

Inescapable, though, is that plugging holes in all those drawers is more work than you should have to do. At the very least, the dovetails should cover them.

Ellis

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#12

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

don stephan

If the drawer parts all are made and finished, could you make a small scraper to remove enough of the shellac finish? No doubt you would do some testing first to be sure. Some fine finish brads in predrilled holes would help hold the bottom.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#13

Picture

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be nice to see a picture of this desk. It must be nice to own something that has been around this long, but a responsibility to preserve it.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#14

Not possible

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Inescapable, though, is that plugging holes in all those drawers is more work than you should have to do. At the very least, the dovetails should cover them. "

The only way to hide the rabbet would be to end the drawer side with a tail, which would leave this relatively wide expanse unsupported at the edge. Looking at the side of a drawer the top and bottom edge should be a half pin to securely capture the wider tail. With half a pin there is no way to avoid the drawer rabbet exposure.

For future reference I explored capturing the bottom in a groove as in a conventional drawer. I had not considered this possibility in these tiny drawers. Indeed it would be practical even in these thin sides, at the cost of loosing 8% of the functional drawer height. I could have lived with the height loss.

The hour it took to plug the holes was but a brief moment among the multitude of other steps in getting these drawers done. I am discovering that a tiny drawer takes just about the same time as a large one.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#15

Re: Picture

Larry Barrett

Bill - here are some pictures. The secretary is walnut, unknown maker, but estimated to be late 18th century. It has been in my family for a long time, at least since before civil war. Brasses have been replaced at some point.



The bookcase on top is a separate piece (I think this was the normal thing).



Here is a pic of the small drawer I mentioned.



Same drawer, but now upside down so you are seeing the pine bottom and the rabbet hole.



Can you make out one of the secret compartments?


Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#16

Re: Picture

Sgian Dubh

Larry, it's interesting to me to note that the grain of the drawer bottom seems to run front to back, and that the construction also seems to show the bottom face of the drawer bottom is flush with the bottom edge of the drawer side. I say this because I don't think there's a slip or wear strip showing in the picture of the upside down drawer (fourth image down).

This form of drawer construction was quite common up until perhaps the late 1600s or early 1700s here in the UK. At about this time it started to become the norm for the grain direction of the bottom to run left to right, and for it to be held in a groove which raised it leaving the drawer to run on the bottom edge of the drawer sides. Alternative construction methods involved rebating the bottom edge of the side something like 3/4" wide, install a ~1/4" bottom followed by rub jointing roughly 1/2" slips or wear strips to the rest of the rebate. Sometimes these strips were wide enough in the horizontal direction, perhaps 3/4" or so and, by the time you added this width to the existing width of the rebated drawer side, you ended up with a bearing surface of perhaps 1", or thereabouts per side.

In theory, the preference for later workers to run the drawer bottom grain left to right could have allowed better for expansion and contraction of the wood, but this was often offset by the fact that the drawer bottoms were often glued in. I can't recall just how many split drawer bottoms I've had to fix because of this. Slainte.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#17

Re: Picture

Larry Barrett

Your observation about the drawer construction is correct. In the small drawers (the one shown and the other three) the bottom was installed with the grain running front to back and was flush with the bottm edge of the drawer side. In the wider drawer below the two smaller drawers on each side the bottom is the same construction but the grain runs side to side. No slips or other wear strips on any of them. The thin pine bottoms are quite smooth on the inside of the drawer, but clearly planed with a jack on the bottom side of the drawer.

The drawer dividers are solid - that is they run the full depth of the gallery (about 10 inches). They are quite thin (about 1/8"), walnut for the first 2 inches and then poplar for the remaining depth. The drawers are so shallow that there is never much weight in them, so virtually no wear after 240 years.

There are similar drawers in the bottom of the bookcase. You might be able to make them out in the second picture. Same construction, but these are 2 1/2" high and do hold some weight. Nevertheless, no sigificant wear on them either. So perhaps not used much.

If more pictures of any part of this would be helpful or interesting I will be glad to provide.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#18

drawers date

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This drawer construction is characteristic of early 1700's (American Furniture of the 18th Century, by J. Greene) . Are you sure of the date on this piece?

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#19

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My drawer construction has been vindicated, especially so if this piece turns out to be nearly 300 years old. However, without a good solution to gluing a finished drawer bottom in I need to finish after assembly next time. It is just the intermediate sanding step that is more difficult with the drawer assembled with all its inside corners to sand.

You need to load it up and take it to a nearby Antiques Road Show :D I am amazed at the size and fragility of things that get hauled to these shows.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#20

Re: drawers date

Larry Barrett

No, not certain. Late 1700's is date passed down in the family. In addition to the drawer construction, the panels on the bookcase doors may give a clue. They are beveled, but the flat side of the panel is out, beveled side inside the doors.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#21

date

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a Windsor chair by family legend to be mid 1800's. Apparently that relative didn't buy it new for it was recently dated at late 1700's.

The style of the piece will most certainly date it and I am not knowledgeable of those details. Maybe there is an antiques forum where you could post the picture. Poking around antique books you may see some similarly styled piece and date it. For example, I have a book on Connecticut Valley furniture and if it was made there the examples in the book would date it. If it is indeed late 1700's the maker was way behind on drawer technology.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#22

Ellis Walentine

Quite possible

Ellis Walentine

Yes, you would have to put the groove high enough up that it would clear the half-blind pin at the drawer front, but, if you run the bottom out under the back, you have no rabbet hole there either.

Ellis

Re: Spice Box Jewelry Box- Drawer bottoms

#23

Possible but not practical

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I measured a typical small drawer in this cabinet. A Period Correct drawer from the late 18th century, as you describe, would have cost me 25% of the drawer height taken up by the bottom and space under it. The situation would be slightly less costly with a smaller half pin but the risk of splitting these tiny pins was to great to shrink the half pin any more than I did.

In contrast, building a Period Correct (except for the finish) drawer from the early 18th century only cost 7% of the drawer height. No doubt conserving drawer height in tiny drawers is why this construction persisted for items with small drawers like Secretaries.