Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

Posts

Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#1

Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have an old (and cheap) HP Deskjet printer/scanner. It's a real ink hog and no longer scans. In the woodworking biz it really helps to be able to scan sketches and the like to send to clients etc.

Time for a new machine. Maybe Epson or Brother are better choices than HP? I don't need high production printing. I need a reliable printer and scanner that won't drain ink cartridges in a heartbeat.

Anyone have a recommendation?

Thanks!

T.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#2

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Bill Howatt

The all-in-one type units are unbelievably cheap these days but my preference is a separate scanner and printer but that may be a bit historical

I have a color printer but it only gets used infrequently when I need some color. I use a B&W laser, right now a Brother HL-2270, for printing which does almost everything I need to do but it is black and white.

I have a now older Epson scanner which was bought for scanning purposes when all-in-one scanners were limited in features such as changing the resolution.

I think as long as you are in the inkjet mode, the cost of ink is something you just have to deal with. I always used the manufacturer's ink but if you ask around you should be able to find a reputable source of "remanufactured" cartridges for a lot less money. Years ago I tried filling but decided that wasn't the route for me.

I'm sure you'll get lots of advice here.

Bill

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#3

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

My Xerox Documate 252 has been a very reliable scanner for a number of years for both B&W and color.

Ain't a printer however.

While multi-function machines save space, I have always shied away from them on the jack-of-all-trades principal. If one function goes out on a multi, you can be left with a brick.

We have a color printer (Canon 100 Pro) for photographs and such, but the bulk of our printing is done on a laser, faster more reliable.

cheers

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#4

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

paul in AZ

Second the Brother laser.

I have a copier/printer that has been reliable for several years and is very frugal with toner. Cheap as well. I recall getting it on sale for just under $100.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#5

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

John McGaw

I just replaced my ancient Dell color laser (at 80+ pounds) with a new Brother color laser. I could have fixed the Dell for the price of a new drum unit but discovered that I could buy the Brother HL-3170CDW color laser for virtually the same cost and the new one features duplexing and wireless networking, Ethernet, and USB connectivity. I hardly hesitated at $180 from Amazon.

As for scanners, I have a simple Visioneer as well as the scanner included in an older Epson inkjet which is used mostly for photo work (no color laser I've seen is acceptable for photos). I definitely prefer to keep the two functions separate -- simpler is almost always better.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#6

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Nat Robison

I've had an Epson Artisan 730 for 3 or 4 years now. We don't do a ton of printing or photos but I believe it's highly rated for photos. Cost was around $100-120 and I think I just bought a second full set of ink cartridges ($80).

Per usual, the unit costs next to nothing and they make their money selling ink.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#7

Ink cost

Walt

Here's a possible solution for high ink costs. I've been using these for a few years in Brother inkjet MFDs. They're not available for all printer models. Some 3rd party inks tend to clog the nozzles if they sit for longer than a few days. Ink Owl seems better in that respect.

http://www.inkowl.com/index.php?C=10&S=25

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#8

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

don stephan

Extremely happy with our HP OfficeJet Pro 8600. Uses our home wireless network, scans well, two sided printing, . . . There is flushing of printhead before each discrete print job but probably common of all inkjet printers today.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#9

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Keith Newton

Thomas, I switch to getting my ink from Cartridge World. The fill the cartridges with more ink, for about half as much $. Besides selling the ink, they do troubleshooting, so they know what is good, and not so.

Also, I think if you have one near you, they would be a good place to ask about what you should get. I took my HP in to see if they could help me troubleshoot, along with some of my nature prints to show what it was doing. He liked my photos, and had a used printer setting there that one of his clients brought in, then bought the best one he had, just leaving the older one. He just gave me that trade in for free, rather than fooling with the one I brought in. The one he gave me was a better one that mine. What is not to like about that!

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#10

INK

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have an ancient Samsung that uses powdered "ink". The cartridges are trivial to refill and the last refills I bought were about $15. I haven't spent $50 on "ink" (probably may be called toner) in years. Print quality is good. For just printing I would suggest getting something similar. When you buy be sure that the thing that holds the powder can be easily refilled.

Separately I have a new Epson V600 scanner that is easy to use and does a nice job on documents and photos. On documents it is quick, seconds. I like it.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#11

Sounds like a laser printer

John in NM

I have an HP from about 1995, and while we don't refill the toner ourselves, I've only replaced the cartridge once.

The experiences I've had with ink jet printers of any type have not been encouraging, at best one gets 200 pages out of an ink cartridge, and not even that much if it either sat on the shelf for 6 months or you go 6 months between 10 page printings. I associate the things with endlessly purchasing little $12 cartridges of ink.

If I needed color I would probably find myself a color laser and hope for the best. As it is, all I need to do is keep a computer that can talk to antiques, which is not a difficult thing to do.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#12

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

Gary Smyth

I do lots of printing, mostly B&W. Sometimes manuals, many times articles and documents. I do 800 pages a month. I use a Brother MFC8910DW B&W laser. Prints both sides of a sheet, is a all in one printer (fax, scan, print). Decent controls for photo images. Get 8000 pages from the toner cartridge. Ultra convenient wireless printing from my laptop anyplace in the house. I can, for example, call up a manual on my laptop from my garage, print it, and have it waiting for me when I get to the office. It can't be hidden easily. It's BIG a little over 18" cube, black in color, pretty ugly in visual design, on arrival it looked flimsy compared to my old 12 year old printer (that could not support Windows 8.1), but it works. Set up was a challenge, but Brother customer service is terrific with help -- crawled me through step by step. May be too much for your needs, but, it can grind out stuff all day at 30-35 pages/per/minute. It can do 50 pages at a time of loose pages at the document feeder too. It is a current model, but goes on sale near holidays. I agonized over many days and at least ten "best printer" type reviews - and still felt I was taking a leap of faith when I pulled the trigger. Not disappointed after 13 months. -- by the way, it would hurt to spend the money, but if I were to do it again, I'd not flinch (much) to get a laser COLOR with similar features. Given what my experience is I'd not look much past Brother again.

Re: Slightly OT Printers/scanners??

#13

Re: Slightly OT  Printers/scanners??

TomD

Epson c88+ has a good reputation among t-shirt printers, at the low end. You can hook it up to a continuous ink system, which seems outside of the interest here, but it impressed me that this was seemingly the baseline printer for entry level users. The add on gear seems always to be available fo this model. They seem to deliver good results and run for ever. Stuff changes all the time, so check out some T-shirt or photography forums to get the latest grades.