Gas furnace-OT
Dave
My 20 year old Bryant furnace is going out, the inducer motor 1000 dollars plus. I'm looking at another Bryant or a Lennox, both high efficienty. Any thoughts?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Gas furnace-OT
Dave
My 20 year old Bryant furnace is going out, the inducer motor 1000 dollars plus. I'm looking at another Bryant or a Lennox, both high efficienty. Any thoughts?
Cost/Benefit
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
We had to replace our furnaces about 10 years ago. We looked closely as the cost verses fuel efficiency figures and opted not to go for the high-E units because the fuel savings would take more than 20 years to amortize out the cost of the units. My HVAC guy confirmed our analysis commenting that he only puts the high-E units in new construction so that the increased cost gets "hidden" by the mortgage amortization. We went with Trane units rated at 85% efficiency. I have toyed with the idea of putting on stack exchangers, but never get a round toit.
we went with Carrier
Dick Coers
Replaced this summer, went with a Carrier 96% 2 stage furnace and 16 SEER AC unit. Based on old furnace and AC unit efficiency , we could get a larger rebate from the utility company and the cost was less than a 92%. Check with your utility company first. Ours cost $5,580 for everything, including new thermostat. Loved the fact the furnace is all sealed, combustion air is piped in. Also had a 4" thick return air filter system installed.
Re: we went with Carrier
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Dick,
What's the point of a 4" thick filter? Seems like it would put a big burden on the air handler and make the furnace run more to heat the same space with the reduced air-flow. Never seen 4" thick replaceable filters.
Last Autumn I got five bids using
Gary Smyth
Angie's list (mostly to assure legitimate suppliers) for a new gas ducted furnace (and AC) for a basement that had two feet of water after a main break. None of the bid replies were for anything less than 90% efficiency units. I'm told that Pennsylvania requires at least that for new installations. The difference between 90% and 97.4% was about $2100 no matter the manufacturer. A twenty five year old unit to be replaced was at 70% efficiency. The owner said that the old furnace was comfortable and not so expensive to run so to improve to 90% was good enough. Furnaces were Bryant, Carrier, Lennox. Warranties generally the same- 10 years.
Quite common.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
I've been in many, many houses, and often use a basement sink to wash brushes and such. I've seen many furnaces in those basements that use 4" filters. My church has 3 furnaces that use 5" filters. And per my friend who is HVAC trained/certified, I have a stack of 4 1" filters in my 4" filter box. The first one is a washable filter, then a cheap filter, a mid-price one, then a high-dollar allergen-type filter. Most of the time, all I have to do is wash the first one (I actually have two--I pull the dirty one and wash it, but install the clean one that's been "on standby").
That said, a 4" thick filter is usually just deeper plaits, so there is much more filter surface area for air to traverse without the filter media itself being any thicker. This slows down the air through the filter, dropping more dust.
Dust is bad for a furnace blower, and blowing it around a house is bad for the occupants.
Jason
Re: Gas furnace-OT
Pete in Holland MI
Find a different furnace guy. No furnace induction motor costs $1000. Draft induction motor should cost no more than $150 over the counter. Replaced mine about 5 years ago for a bit over $100. Main blower motor replaced by furnace guy for about $225.
Most furnaces are created out of fairly generic components.
Re: Quite right
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
The entire induction assembly should cost less than $250 retail (after markup) ~ almost all can be purchased for less than $150 wholesale. Replacement time should be less than 1/2 hour.
I installed and serviced furnaces as a contractor (second job, I retired as an Manufacturing Engineer), for over 20 years. I would certainly get some additional quotes as the prices quoted are RIP-OFFS. I have a 95% efficiency unit in my large home installed about 20 years ago (Heil Quaker) and a 98% efficiency unit in my shop installed about 8 years ago, neither cost more than $1,000 for the entire furnace. With complete piping, the shop cost was less than $2,000 + (free) labor for all material, with an additional cost of about $900 for the central air. Granted prices have risen and labor costs vary across the nation, but replacement of a furnace should take less than 1 day / 2 men. and wholesale material costs, including the furnace, sheet metal and chimney costs should be less than $2,500 ~ $3,000 (for a top of the line high efficiency furnace). If the air conditioning units are replaced when the furnace is replaced add another $1,500 for material and possibly 1 man/day.
Agree
John McGaw
I'm glad somebody injected this bit of wisdom. The inducer motor assembly in my furnace was acting up a few years ago and I changed it out myself at a cost of $125 IIRC -- just went to the local heating supplier's counter and told them what I needed. The actual changeout was simple -- a few screws, a connector and a little pressure-sensor hose to be swapped out. The whole process was done in less than two hours including driving across town to buy the part. BTW, the control electronics in the same furnace went bad too and I fixed that myself for roughly the same cost.
I won't argue that eventually any furnace needs to be changed out but I wouldn't do it unless the old unit was totally kaput, unsafe or so inefficient that the expense of a new ultra-high-efficiency unit would pay for itself in a few years.
Re: Gas furnace-OT
Grant in Iowa
Dave,
Most major towns have a supply house called Johnstone Supply, which caters to HVAC specialists. About five years ago, they began selling to the general public discretely. Their website indicates otherwise. Just know what part you want, walk in the door and tell them. When they ask if you are an HVAC pro, just say "this will just be a counter sale". Works for me anyway.
The issue you have is likely something you can fix yourself, assuming you know which way to turn a screwdriver, and that you are comfortable around electricity.
As others have said, the quoted price is a rip-off, unless the tech found a cracked heat exchanger or similar too.
If you replace the furnace (it is 20 years old, and therefore you may benefit financially in the long run). I would avoid Carrier, as they are quite proprietary in their parts and design. At least they were a few years ago when I had one in my former home. This means repairs cost more and not everyone works on them.
If I were in your shoes, and I wanted to replace a furnace, I would look at Rheem, Ruud, Goodman and others that are more widely available. The units that Johnstone and other plumb supply houses sell that seem to be no-name units are often made in the same factories as the popular brand names.
If you really want a name brand for some reason, I'd recommend Lennox.
As for features and efficiency, I would look for something mid-range in the efficiency department. One with around 90-95% efficiency. I built a new home about five years ago and bought a Ruud "90-plus", which is a line that is pretty good efficiency. You can buy one more efficient, but if you ask me, you are better off spending the difference in $$$ on insulation, caulk, new windows, etc. And, as a repair guy told me the more efficient they are, the less reliable they tend to be.
Ask yourself how long you want to live there. If the answer is "indefinitely", then it might make sense to replace the furnace. I would NOT go with the guy who gave you the repair quote, however.
It is also critical for the furnace to be sized right for your house. If someone quotes the job based on square footage alone, they are taking short cuts. There is a calculation that pros use that will tell them what you should have. Too big of a furnace is just as bad as one that is too small.
FWIW
Grant in Iowa<---facilities guy with ten gas house type furnaces to maintain.
Interesting
Tony-Memphis
We have a Goodman. I've not been impressed with it. When I talked to the HVAC guy last summer (the cap blew), he said he likes Goodman over other brands because he can go to any parts place in town and buy parts. He said that his company has had good luck with them. Ours is probably on its last leg. He said they usually get around 15 years out of them. Not sure what we'll do when the time comes.
When lightning hit our old house, we needed a new control board for the AC/Heat unit. Nobody would sell me one. Long story short, I paid the AC repair place and they gave me a receipt to use to go pick it up myself. Crazy, but still cheaper than a visit. Most everything is available online nowadays.
Funny, when we needed a couple of burners, the lady that refused to sell them to me said if I put them in wrong, I could burn the house down. I explained to her that it was, however, mush easier to get a pack of matches free at the restaurant down the street....which was more dangerous?!?
Tony - plenty of hot air today -thank goodness! (26°) this morning.
Re: Gas furnace-OT
Barry Irby
As a Home Inspector, I have no reliable knowledge that any brand of equipment is better than any other. I have not found any source that reliably rates them. I have not observed any brand in the field that clearly out lasts the rest.
I also know for a fact that the manufactures swap equipment. That is, one of them will manufacture smaller furnaces and another will make larger ones and then they trade, rebranding them to make it appear they make a full line. Also, many of the brands are owned by a single company. Carrier, Bryant, Day Night, and Payne are all owned by a single company. Rheem and Ruud are made in the same plant and painted different colors. I watched someone open the box for an AC unit and a little box fell out and it had four or five different badges in it. You chose the brand in the field.
Also, the comments about sizing the equipment are true. Its hard for most Americans to understand and believe, but slightly undersized equipment is more economical to buy and to operate, but we all believe Bigger is better. AND, it would be wise to spend some money upgrading your insulation and caulking and weatherstripping and downsize the equipment. Sadly, since HVAC companies sell equipment and NOT insulation, not one suggests this to home owners. Rant off.