Level 1 - again...
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
I read this post yesterday on Chris Schwarzs' Blog.
Thought it was timely in regards to the design discussion in the post "Level 1"
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Level 1 - again...
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
I read this post yesterday on Chris Schwarzs' Blog.
Thought it was timely in regards to the design discussion in the post "Level 1"
Interesting...
John in NM
I have to wonder though, if this technique is really any more than an effective way of quickly rendering specific ratio rectangles. Once I clicked through to Walker's page that is what it looked like to me. A useful drawing skill at any time certainly.
Re: Level 1 - again...
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I found the reply by Jenohdil interesting. It is the same reaction I get to some of the design articles in Popular Woodworking. The concepts get stretched to incredulity applied to parts of a piece of furniture selected to illustrate a concept. I could find golden rectangles in a stack of hay bales if given the license to pick the bales.
In any case my design needs are not about proportion. I need a china cabinet. I will have no problem determining the height and width, nor will the design success be determined by this simple consideration. It is the moldings and feet that flummox me. And I expect some formal training will help. My artist friend looks at furniture and points of how a curve here gets reflected in some design element over there, etc..
I expect there are some principles that can be taught to a receptive student, the cove in the bun foot being an example. The easy to learn concept of a larger convex curve should flow into a smaller concave curve with the same radius is a "rule" simple to grasp and execute that results in pleasing turned objects. I have used the principle on pepper grinders where the base flows into the top.
Re: Level 1 - again...
Jesse Cloud
One thing I do when I am stumped on a design detail is to google something like "images china cabinets". It will produce a plethora of pictures, and it is tedious to sift through the mediocrity, but a few jewels may hide within. I print out a few that have some appeal, then compare them to help me understand what I like and why.
another source...
John in NM
I used to browse online antique websites, though I fell out of the habit eventually and I don't think I still have the bookmarks. But there was slightly less mediocrity there, since the pieces had to survive long enough to be considered antiques. That has a way of winnowing out particle board computer desks and the like 
Excellent point....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
But so far nothing I have found comes close. The problem is that I saw one made by a Krenov student some years ago that was the cabinet of my dreams. Problem is I can't remember its details, but I would know it if I saw it.