Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

Posts

Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#1

Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

cameron

I've decided to upgrade from my drill press to an oscillating spindle sander for some curved work that I need to complete. I read FWW's 2006 review and they recommended the $199 Rigid EB4424 as their best option (heavily swayed by the 4x24 belt sander conversion as most of the other dimensions were similar.) I also see that Woodcraft has their model on sale for $129 (no belt sander and the table doesn't tilt.) I'm not sure a tilting table would get all that much use (please correct me if I'm wrong). I am wondering if any of you guys have any opinions on these machines in general and specifically if you find the belt sander useful. I have had to clamp my belt sander in my vise in the past to use as an edge sander but not very often...

Thanks

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#2

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

Joe Pack

I have the Rigid. It works well for the limited projects I use it for. I particularly liked the belt sander before I got a larger 6x48 floor model. My only real complaint is the machine is NOISY! Ear protection is needed if you are going to have it on for more than a couple of seconds. Even then, if muffs were close by, I would use them.

Can't comment on the WoodRiver; haven't seen or heard it run. I will add that I was impressed by the Delta Boss for my limited purposes. So smooth and quiet that I could barely hear it running. But I already had the Rigid, so...

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#3

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

Randy Johnson

One thing I would consider is the availability of the sanding sleeves. If you don’t mind having to always buy online, it won’t make a difference. I have the Jet, and even Woodcraft (that sells the machine) doesn’t have the sleeves in the store anymore. The several times I have been in the store recently (Cincinnati) I wasn’t paying attention to sanders, so I don’t know if they stock sanding supplies for the Wood River sander or not. I will just about guarantee that Home Depot has sleeves for the Rigid. Likewise, Menard’s always has sleeves for whatever brand they sell.

For no more than I use my Jet, if I had it to do over again I’d buy the Rigid just to have easier availability of sanding sleeves.

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#4

I use the Rigid too

John in NM

I've had it maybe a little more than a year. Usually I leave the tilting table down since I'm using it free hand with both belt and spindles - sanding fairly small curves in the grips I make.

The belt sander is very useful I find, as much as the spindles for what I do. I'm not sure the unit is going to last under the kind of heavy use I give it, but at the price I was willing to find out. I would have the same concerns about any $200 spindle sander.

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#5

That's a good point....

John in NM

Rigid used to sell individual sleeves and pairs in the smaller sizes. Now all HD carries are sets of the whole range in two grits.

When I bought my machine I found a bunch of sleeves at a liquidating vendor through Amazon and bought as many as I could.

Woodworkers Supply in Albuquerque might carry 4.5" sleeves, I'm not sure - they do mail order, btw.

The other thing to consider is that most of the heavy machines use a 9" sleeve, IIRC. Put on a trashed bandsaw blade and make two 4.5's :D

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#6

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

del schisler

i have the ridgid for yrs now , the only thing is the nut that hold's down the sander , make sure you loosen it up after each use, or it will not come loose, the first unit i had i used a pipe wrench and couldn't get it loose, i took the unit back and got a new one , that is the only thing that i found wrong, other than that it is very good machine and a life time warrenty on mine you have to regester the unit tho just not on line but i belive you have to mail in the upc off the box ? good luck

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#7

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

cameron

That is a good point, it seems like every time I go into Woodcraft they have less inventory (like only 3 hinges last weekend in the style I wanted).

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#8

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

Paul Blackwell

I've had a Grizzly for many years, and never had an issue with it. It's quiet, has spindles from 1/4" to 4" and has a tilt table. Dust collection is fairly good. Larger spindles are 9" long with the smaller ones down to about 4" I believe.

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#9

That is a good unit...

John in NM

And my plan B if the Rigid cheepie doesn't hold up.

Also depends on the day job, if I get the one I most recently applied for, I won't have time for the side biz and the need for one of these will go away.

That heavy Grizzly is the one I'd get though, I've heard good things about the design.

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#10

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

David Hay Denver

I have the Rigid and mostly like it. It has a bit more vibration than I'd like, but I don't really have anything to compare it to either. I need to try clamping it down to the bench to see if that helps.

I picked up a set of sanding sleeves at Harbor Freight that fits the drums on the Rigid. From what I can tell, it's a standard size. The belt is also a standard size (4x24, IIRC)

Good luck with your decision!

David

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#11

Durability vs. Service

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I bought my Rigid on an "open box" special at the BORG for $180. It was missing a few small parts but Emerson sent me an entire new set of accessories for the call.

I've used it (hobby use) for 8 years. The vertical cam broke about 6 years on so I called a service guy for Rigid asking about cost of repair. I wasn't going to mut real coin into fixing a $200 unit.

"Free" was the answer!

Took it in and got it back in 7 days with an entire new motor unit installed,

Can't beat that kind of service.

PS: Mine is anything but loud. The belt makes some noise and the sound of the DC's air moving makes noise, but I ain't deef (yet) and have never needed hearing protection with the tool. Sounds like somebody needs to get some service done.

Re: Spindle sanders: Rigid or WoodRiver

#12

Kneale Brownson

PC portable

Kneale Brownson

When I wanted to do some intricate sanding on a large piece, I got the PC portable spindle sander. I've since used it mounted to a piece of ply so I can clamp it to my saw table. I've used wedges to create a tilt.