Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Different approach to dust collection

Posts

Different approach to dust collection

#1

Different approach to dust collection

bob murphy

I am currently debating setting up a dust handling system in my freestanding shop that would not collect and filter dust but would vac it from directly from each machine and exhaust it directly outside the shop.

I live in a rural area with no nearby neighbors and am located in Nor Cal so temperatures are not a major concern. Further, being retired, if its too cold, I don't work in the shop.

Any thoughts, suggestions on this approach would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#2

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have done that for years with a large planer.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#3

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Bill Howatt

Since you don't have the issue of the make-up air being too hot or cold your method is fine. I'd ensure that it remains where it is exhausted is not blown onto the side of your building or other undesirable area by the prevailing wind.

Bill

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#4

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Barry Irby

This is what I have wanted to do. I can't understand why anyone wants to COLLECT dust. I want to blow it into the woods and forget about it. (I can't because I live in a subdivision.)

This would also eliminate all the discussions about the quality of the filters and the reduction of performance as they clog up and etc.

Exhaust down wind so that the dust does not blow back into the shop and the system does not suck it back in.

Years ago I saw a blower made for this. Called a Dust Destroyer IIRC.

Once you accumulate a pile, you may be able to give the dust away. Make it easy for the neighbors to come and get it. (This raises issues about the quality and the species of the dust. No Walnut for horse owners or gardeners.)

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#5

Walnut Myth Busting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no reason to suspect that KD walnut shavings will be harmful in a garden. To prove it I mulched both tomatoes and peppers one season with no detectable harmful effects.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#6

Do you work with walnut?

Dick Coers

Walnut dust won't be very friendly to animals. Also fine dust may get stuck to the outside wall if the wind is wrong, and get stuck there in the fog. No woodworking on days with clothes on the line, although not so many do that around here like I do. I could still see an advantage of blowing it into some kind of container.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#7

What about wildlife?


Re: Different approach to dust collection

#8

Re: Walnut Myth Busting

Bill Howatt

Probably a garden problem not since the juglone chemical is concentrated in the roots. This is the chemical that keeps other plants from growing near the tree and stealing its nutrients and crowding it out.

Black walnut shavings and butternut are not recommended for horse bedding but if necessary it seems you can use them if you know they are aged for several months.

Bill

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#9

Re: Walnut Myth Busting

Barry Irby

I have never had any problem with walnut sawdust. I used to raise thousands of perennials. I dumped my sawdust in a pile and occasionally threw in a few handfuls of nitrogen rich fertilizer or some green grass clippings and then wet the pile. A poor attempt at composting. If you mix shavings in your soil, the decomposition of the shavings will rob nitrogen out of the soil. Never had any ill effects from it.

The decomp process produces heat. I saw the pile steaming and stuck my hand into it. OUCH! I stuck in a thermometer and it was over 140 degrees.

Rather than just blow the stuff out into the wind, it would be better to create some kind of confinement. Could be as crude as some pallets set in a circle. Could use some plastic fabric, whatever.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#10

Re: Different approach to dust collection

John McGaw

I read an article some years ago about a professional woodturner who did that. His shop was a shed on the edge of a gully IIRC and he had been blowing his cuttings and dust outside the shop and down the hill where it slowly decomposed. I recall a picture of a small mountain accrued through decades of turning.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#11

Juglone toxicity

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Ohio State University Extension

Black Walnut Toxicity to Plants, Humans and Horses

"Many plants such as tomato, potato, blackberry, blueberry, azalea, mountain laurel, rhododendron, red pine and apple may be injured or killed within one to two months of growth within the root zone of these trees. The toxic zone from a mature tree occurs on average in a 50 to 60 foot radius from the trunk, but can be up to 80 feet."

"Horses may be affected by black walnut chips or sawdust when they are used for bedding material. Close association with walnut trees while pollen is being shed (typically in May) also produce allergic symptoms in both horses and humans. The juglone toxin occurs in the leaves, bark and wood of walnut, but these contain lower concentrations than in the roots."

(Emphasis mine.)

http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/1000/1148.html

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#12

the way i do it

del schisler

i live in florida so here is what i do , i have 2 fan's each 36" in the west window that i turn on when i am sawing on table saw which dust goes out , i leve my door open all the time i work next to the fan , i have a 2 foot by 3 foot work ares that i sand item's down dust goes out the window , i spray lacquer their also so nothing stay's in the shop, when i do dovetales and pins i set up 2 router tables and do the cutting , i use a air hose and blow the chip's out the window, i have no body near me no neibor's , i also have a delta dust or chip colection for all my machine's so i use that also , when i clean my shop i start at one end with the air hose and blow everthing down to the west end and than blow it in the north corner and use the hose to pick that up , keep's the shop clean, i do this evertime i work in the shop, also blow all my tool's off with air hose so they are like new when i use them again, shop is clean i spray lacquer for yrs and no problum with dust , so i belive it must be real clean, i use a HVLP sprayer and have done this for yrs. my 2 cents also have the other fan in the other window when i use my delta leath so dust goes out that window also sure help's keep shop clean my 2 cents thanks for reading

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#13

Thanks for all the input.


Re: Different approach to dust collection

#14

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Fred Hargis

That's actually a good way to do it, if the loss of heated or cooled air isn't an issue. Most folks try to catch the chips and just blow the finest particles out. In your case, if you discharge everything, the larger chips may not blow away but rather start making a pile near the discharge.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#15

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Barry Irby

A friend of mine who has a commercial shop bought a "feed" bin from a farmer. A big metal box on a stand High enough to back a truck under and it already had a port in it for blowing the cattle food/chips into it. Had a spout on the bottom to empty it. Once a year or so, he backs his truck under it and carts away a load.

If I had one I would probably build a "tepee" out of some sort of rot proof plastic fabric and blow the stuff in from the top. Eventually I would either move the tepee or cart away the stuff.

Re: Different approach to dust collection

#16

Re: Different approach to dust collection

Jesse Cloud

I remember seeing a photo on another forum of a one-man rural cabinet shop that did just that. He had a trailer (actually the back half of an old pickup) parked under the output pipe. When the trailer filled up, he hitched it up and took the stuff away. Don't know where he took it.