Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Drill Bits - Educate Me

Posts

Drill Bits - Educate Me

#1

Drill Bits - Educate Me

Joe Pack

I know a good drill bit when it keeps an edge and when it drills what I expect it to drill...wood, light to medium metals. I have a few of these by accident, but also have some that get dull just chucking them into the drill...no contact necessary.

How would a novice, or even a old novice like me, tell the difference? High Speed; Black Oxide; Black Oxide Coated; Titanium; Titanium Coated; Tool Steel; Carbon Steel; High Carbon Steel; Cobalt........ Split Tip; Cone Tip; 135 degree Tip; Aircraft Bit; Parabolic Flute; Jobber Length...... Best for Wood; Best for Steel, Best for Aluminum.....Those for general use; Those for specific use; Those to buy as 'throw-aways;' Those to invest in.....

I know a bit more than my question might imply, but not a lot more. And maybe someone else needs the lesson, too.

Let's see what we can learn.

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#2

Here is a good place to start  *LINK*


Grainger

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#3

Buy US made HSS drills....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

for wood and mild steel. Price is a good guide. I keep a set for metal and another for wood. The various coatings may help a tiny amount. Cobalt is for vary hard metals.

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#4

I used to work in a machine shop and... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I used to work in a machine shop and the drill bits we used were Huot brand. We had some coated bits for stainless or other special materials, but most were HSS. These bits last well for general use. I use them still today, replacing broken ones by visiting our local tool supply house (NOT home depot, NOT Lowe's). I go to Acme tools here in Cedar Rapids for my needs but Fastenal has good bits in stock priced each and Whitecap also does.

You didn't ask, but I will tell you anyway that Apex company makes great quality impact driver bits. From my experience both as a hobbyist and pro these bits outlast and outperform anything else I have found. Used extensively in industrial applications, these are also available at tool supply stores that cater to machinists and other pros. See an example bit below I found at Amazon. Get some of these in the common sizes and thank me later.

By now you have figured out that while Makita, Milwaukee, and DeWalt make good power tools, the bits they sell of the same name are simply lacking for heavy duty use. The Apex bits will, so long as you do your part to keep the bit in the fastener, last indefinitely.

I also cheaped out and bought a large forstner bit set at (I think) Home Depot around Christmas time one year. Actually, the larger ones aren't true forstners and are instead spur bits. Out of the box they were garbage, but upon inspection it was clear that they were poorly sharpened. I sharpened each one by hand with a 3 sided file and they now work OK. The ease at which they are sharpened with the file tells me they are not good steel. They fill the need, but I lust after a better set. For whatever that is worth.

Once you have a good set of drill bits, the rest is on the shoulders of your technique. While not as important when drilling wood as for steel and other metals, there IS a proper cutting speed for wood and each other type of material and for each cutter type. If you use too high of a cutting speed or too little feed pressure, you will overheat the best bit and ruin it. The take away is on any bit being pushed in to steel you need to push hard enough to get a curl of metal out of the hole. Less speed and more pressure (feed) is the general mantra to keep it simple. When it comes to wood, keep the hole clear of chips by backing out often and consult this chart: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/159951557/DRILL-PRESS-SPEED-CHART-Woodworkers-Guild

There's much to know, and I have probably forgotten much of what I was taught as a machinist apprentice. The above is what I have retained and what seems to work for me. I invite anyone to add to the list of do's and don'ts.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Apex #2 phillips bit on Amazon

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#5

Re: I used to work in a machine shop and...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I frequently go to a machinist friend for questions of this sort. The info in your answer is exactly why. Thanks, Grant!

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#6

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

Keith Newton

It sounds like the question is mainly about twist drills. The speed of spiral determine the sharpness angle of the cutting edge, so a straight flute will have a wider angle than a faster spiral, if the top grind is the same. Usually the standard spiral will clear chips better than slower, and will require less power to make the cut. However, everything comes with a tradeoff. A sharper angle is usually more fragile than a wider one.

Hardness usually come at the expense of brittleness, so carbide usually has a wide sharpness angle to prevent the edge chipping. Titanium Nitride is up there in hardness as carbide, and can be coated onto tougher bits, plus have a natural slickness, so I'm fond of those. Add split point, which is the little grind that crosses the web between flutes, which can be substantial on larger bits, so that is a real plus. I've got a good very fine diamond wheel on one of my grinders, so I add the split point on any of my bits that I'm sharpening.

There are times where a fast spiral causes problems, like when punching out the bottom, especially if the bit is coming out at an angle to the face. Once the center punches through, the flutes act like screw threads, pulling the bit down to the end of the flutes, and will usually break a small bit, or your arm if you don't stop on a large tough bit in a powerful drill. A straight flute drill doesn't have this hazard. If I know this is going to be a problem with a large bit, I will grind a secondary face bevel on the bit, which makes it easier to control.

Then there have been times when I wanted the fastest drill than I could get my hands on, like when I would be leading a crew of members of our sailing club building boat slips. There was a lot of hardware needing to be bolted on, so to help that part of our crew from holding up the others, I ground a sharper point to the tip, which makes an even sharper cutting angle, plus makes it even self feed, through treated pine.

Back to the straight flute, this is also used on plexiglass and glass, to keep from blowing out the bottom side.

You didn't ask about hole-saws, but most brands use too many teeth, and have too much hook angle on the face, which makes them snag too easily, and the gullets to fill, with no way to clear the chips. So I grind 2 of every 3 teeth off, providing a large gullet, and change the face to 90º, which eliminates the grab.

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#7

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

Don Evans

Hands down the best wood bit for woodworking is from Lee Valley, look for their brad points that are sharpened by CNC machine.

Two things they have over all others I have tried over 40 year period is sharpness AND most important to me is the point being center axis with the bit.

As long as they continue with the present quality I will purchase no others. Also they have these in metric also.

I don't do much metal work, some for that I have just cheap HSS bits jobbers.

My set of forstners are FREUD and they are great, I ended up with another set that wasn't sharp when brand new, did I use my time to sharpen them, NO WAY, they when back. You get what you pay for is true in this case.

Don

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#8

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

TomD

For Brad point bits I buy the ones that Lee Valley sells, since they are almost the nearest distributor to me, and as others have said the quality is very high. The other option that works well is to buy HSS twist drills and hand sharpen them, there are instructions in one of the Krenov books, and you don't need a big set up, I think he grinds them on a hand wheel. The advantage to hand grinding or however you do it is you can freshen and reuse the bits. Bits are like any other tooling, they are often worst as they come from the factory. The outer steel is a little brash. It certainly doesn't get any worse. I inherited a machinist' set and the bits are in some cases as short as an inch and a half. There are a whole variety of lengths like jobbers and stubs, but these were just sharpened over and over.

The other reason is because the grin on most brad points is such that it works best in machines, and the holes are far to deep relative to the clearance, something the Krenov grind deals with.

For twist drills, I buy whatever cheap set is on sale that I have some confidence in. Then I upgrade it as I burn through certain sizes. Say the 1/4 inch gets gobbled up, or isn't worth resharpening. I go and get a basic HSS drill from a machine supply. Up here I use Busy Bee, which is sorta grizzly with none of the stock. While there are all kinds of different grades, the cheapest letter grade, or by the thou is dirt cheap good quality, normally. Victornet would get my business if I lived in the states.

These driils can be shaped into brad points, particularly useful for thou overs when you want clearance for pins and such. I also keep a few of the cheaper chucking reamers around for very clean holes.

Jim Cummings shared a great tip on how to sharpen twist drills,: chuck them and run them at speed against a grinder so that you get a bullet point on the head (freehand process, takes seconds). Then you back of the bevel freehand on the grinder, just like grinding a chisel. If you don't do that step, then you have no clearance angle to take a chip. Easy to do with bits over 3/16, and only takes seconds, so you can do it over if you get it off center. The same process would work with brads, except you would need a shaped wheel, and the backing off would have to be extensive enough to shape the points.

I buy the budget forstners from LV, not sure what they sell these days. Another case where CNC makes a lot more sense.

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#9

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

Grant in Iowa

Keith,

Could you show us a picture of your worked over hole saw bits? I'd be interested in seeing what they look like. Could be article material.

Thanks!

Grant in Iowa

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#10

I've been computer-deprived....

Joe Pack

Sorry for not being involved in this conversation...I have all but been computer time deprived for a couple of days. Life sometimes interferes with having fun!

Thanks for all the information. Informative and interesting.

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#11

Re: I used to work in a machine shop and...

Joe Pack

Great information, Grant. Thanks!

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

#12

Re: Drill Bits - Educate Me

Joe Pack

Thanks, Keith.