Re: A far-ranging discussion for sure
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
"Joe, thanks for starting this,"
You're welcome. 
"I'm intrigued by the discussion of design that follows your post. There have been some really good rules of thumb detailed here."
I am also. But I am not well versed or trained in "Design". I go by seat-of-the-pants mostly.
That half round table I made last year, I made up in my head mostly. I did make a cardboard mock up to make sure it would fit, and look ok, in the space I planed to put it. I didn't draw up plans with measurements and details. I didn't draw it out and make sure the apron and table top thickness met some special Golden Ratio or anything. Just did what I thought looked right and made things up as I went along.
The clock too is kinda in my head. No drawings. I did read several magazine article to get some ideas on different ways to construct it and different dimensions and so on. But there isn't a plan or cut list.
I think most things I make are done that way. Tables, candle stands, and so on. Hand cut DT's? I dont' have patience to make sure everything is spaced precisely, just do it. Close enough for me.
Huge flaw on my part I suppose. But I don't have patience to create plans and plan ahead (another flaw - it bites me now and then I admit).
I have to admit, when magazine articles get in depth about design, ratios, geometry, math and what not, my brain goes numb and I start to itch all over. My attention span is way too short. Another flaw. I would add up all my woodworking flaws, but I'm not very good with math.
I like simple. Probably why I've always like Shaker stuff.
I wonder how much thought Issac Newton Youngs put into the design and look of his wall clocks in the mid 1800's. Again, not well versed in design, but I don't think the case dimensions are to any Golden Ratio or anything, but it looks right to me.
I realize I am painting with a really big brush here, and design theory aside, but doesn't it come down to what looks right to you? I don't make a living doing this and I've never made anything complex and beautiful like a Philadelphia High Boy. When I make a table and get man glitter (saw dust) all over me, I don't care if the neighbor likes its look or not (I don't care for him anyway). In my simple ADD brain, it's a bit analogous to photography; you either have an eye for it or you don't. In that case (case being you don't have the eye), I suppose design, design theory, details, and all the nuances that come along with it are much more important.
Can beautiful furniture be designed and made in your head and built to the dimensions you see in your head (specific joinery details aside), or do you have to design it out using design rules and theory?
I would be interested if you moved this to 'Level 1' but I wouldn't have much if anything to contribute, please do though. I'm a woodworking hack. 