Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Clock progress

Posts

Clock progress

#1

Clock progress

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I was able to start dimensioning the maple for my Shaker Clock today.

Thought I'd share some pictures.

Thanks for looking.

Cross-cutting some pieces


Pieces parts


Reawing to rough width (most all the pieces are 1/2" thick), then to the planer



I might use these off-cuts from resawing the sides as the door panel



All the pieces waiting until I can work on it some more


Re: Clock progress

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Clock progress

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Great work, love the way you have managed the depth of control to isolate the focus of attention...The B&W is perfect!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Clock progress

#3

finishing- time to start practicing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Time to start practicing the finish. Curly maple is difficult to finish. The best I have seen has come out of the Headley shop. They use a dye stain to emphasize the curl and provide the yellow brown color. Then top coat for protection. Keep in mind that the maple will darken and the finish will become more yellow with age. That is one of the reasons that maple is hard to finish. One is finishing for what will look best a year or two away.

Ideally you can find a piece finished to your satisfaction and learn how it was done.

Re: Clock progress

#4

Re: finishing- time to start practicing

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I'm not sure yet what I will do finish wise.

The last thing I made with curly maple was the half round table shown below a year ago. It has already yellowed a lot. I knew it would. It was finished with a coat or two of BLO (flooded on then wiped off), then oil based poly.

Like I said, I knew it would yellow, but it has more already than I expected.

For this clock, I doubt I will use poly. It won't need that kind of protection. I have some aniline dyes I might try on scrap. One is (don't recall the name exactly) some kind of antique Maple dye. It's kind of an orange-redish kinda color. I've used it on small things, but never had the guts to use it on something bigger that would really show.

On top of that I might use shellac. As I recall, shellac doesn't yellow as much as poly. I could try one of the (supposedly) non-yellowing water based poly's, but I thought I've read problems with those like you can't really sand them well or something. Whatever I use, I have to be able to wipe it on or brush it on. I still do not have spray equipment, so I don't know.

Honestly, I kinda regret using this maple. The maple, along with the color it might end up being, is a little bit more showy than I am used to or prefer. I probably should have stuck with cherry or walnut. But we'll see.

I plan on making a second one for my daughter. It will be cherry or maple.

Thanks.

Half Round table




Re: Clock progress

#5

Re: finishing- time to start practicing

David Yoho

Joe, have a look at my blanket chest in the Member Gallery. In real life it looks very close to cherry. I used two different water soluble dyes and Waterlox. It's the technique with the dyes that creates the contrast in the figure. If you would like more information I'll be glad to explain.

Re: Clock progress

#6

Beautiful table


Re: Clock progress

#7

Re: finishing- time to start practicing

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"If you would like more information I'll be glad to explain."

Yes, please do. Thank you.

I looked at your blanket chest, very very nice.

Re: Clock progress

#8

Shellac a good choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The luster is perfect for a clock. The color is largely stable. It is easy to sand level if necessary. And it will provide an opportunity for you to learn to French Polish.

With a premetalized dye beneath the color will be what it will stay. The dye part takes practice.

Contrary to the unscientific notions, it matters not how the shellac coats are built up before polishing. After build, sand smooth and polish.

French polishing is a form of solvent polishing, a common way to polish any polymer, natural or synthetic. It simply involves dissolving and smearing the surface of the polymer.

The clock would be perfect in rift cut cherry.

Re: Clock progress

#9

Reader's Digest version

David Yoho

I'll try to be as brief as I can but this might still be long.

You can use many combinations of dyes to get the look that pleases you. What I did on the blanket chest you saw was I purchased several colors of Lockwood water soluble dyes because I working from a recipe I had. I got mine from Tools For Woodworking, I think. The directions for mixing and use are available on their site too.

I starting by applying a trace coat of a medium brown dye, which does two things. This application raises the grain, becomes the highlight color in the curly figure, and will also show any lingering surface glue or sanding swirls. When dry, I sand with 150 paper until the surface is free of color and any glue or sanding swirls disappear.

Next, I mixed a couple of colors to achieve the final color I wanted (I'd have to go look up my recipe to provide the exact Lockwood names). I applied the dye mixture being careful to get it on fast but cover everything so there weren't any "witness lines" in the color. You basically have to keep the surface wet but I found wiping it on worked well. The best way would be to spray it on.

Once this dried, I started wiping on coats of Waterlox medium sheen. I probably put on at least 5 or 6 coats before I was satisfied with the look.

That's it in a nutshell. The sanding you do after the first coat of dye only removes it from the surface but it's still soaked into the figure. You'll see it pop a little when applying the final coat of dye but you'll really see it pop when you apply the clear coat.

Re: Clock progress

#10

Re: Reader's Digest version

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thank you.

I understand.

Re: Clock progress

#11

Re: Shellac

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"And it will provide an opportunity for you to learn to French Polish."

I have played/experimented with French Polishing on a small scale and found it pretty easy to do.

When we have a dog die, which is too often, I build little boxes to hold their ashes; yes we always have them cremated...

Below are two examples. Scrap pieces of maple, brushed on shellac, then polished with a rubber that

consisted of fabric (mulsin I think) with wadded up t-shirt inside.

I squirt a little diluted shellac (mostly dna) into it and a drop of mineral oil on the outside and start polishing.

I can see the oil go on then flash away as the shellac smooths out (or whatever it's called). Pretty simple.

Maybe someday I will try it on a larger surface.

"The clock would be perfect in rift cut cherry."

I agree. I do worry a bit that the wonky grain in this maple will cause problems with the door rails and stiles staying flat and not twisting... we'll see.

Thanks for the info/feedback.


Re: Clock progress

#12

The Curtis Buchannan design philosophy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

He allowed in a program he recently gave that no one element of a piece should dominate attention. Rather, when first encountered the eye should behold the whole of it, then search for details. I think there is merit in considering this design goal for furniture. The problem with figured wood when used in abundance is that the eye can be attracted to the figured wood.

I am reminded of an English table I saw a while ago at a shop in Shelbyville, KY. It was Federal, mahogany with satinwood inlay. Fancy that it was one first saw the attractive shape, then the accenting satinwood inlay. I think this table illustrated what Curtis was talking about.

Re: Clock progress

#13

Re: The Curtis Buchannan design philosophy

Jesse Cloud

I like that design philosophy. My personal hero, Michael Fortune, suggests that a piece should have no more than three interesting features, lest they compete for the user's eye and detract from the overall sense of the piece.

I have a hard time keeping highly figured wood from competing with the overall shape of the piece, so I use it mainly in small decorative details. I admire those with more talent who can blend curly maple into a cohesive piece.

Re: Clock progress

#14

Re: The Curtis Buchannan design philosophy

mdclor

"...a piece should have no more than three interesting features..."

Precisely!!! Thank you for clarifying that for me. I have felt it for a long time, especially in regards to some G&G style pieces, but have never been able to put into words so concisely. Thank you!

Re: Clock progress

#15

Are you saying my clock is ugly?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Just kidding. Maybe it will be.

"no one element of a piece should dominate attention."

Interesting. Something to keep in mind.

"The problem with figured wood when used in abundance is that the eye can be attracted to the figured wood."

What if that is the intent?

Re: Clock progress

#16

What works for Curtis.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

may not apply to all designs. Curtis designs chairs. He wants the customer to see the chair, and not be distracted by some element of the chair.

In the case of a table, the objective could be to celebrate the shape of the table and its elements- legs, molding, etc. In this case Curtis suggested imagining the table painted black. Would it look attractive painted black? In this case none of the decoration on the table should capture the eye at the expense of the whole of it. Krenov pieces are usually all about the shape and he doesn't distract from these shapes with figured woods or other ornamentation.

But the objective may be to celebrate a spectacular piece of wood. It could be tuned into a vase (or clock), but the vase ideally should have a nice shape if painted black, says Curtis.

I think a lot of Studio furniture is all about the wood, and there is much less to the shape. Or the shape is attractive but overwhelmed by the wood for no good reason.

I was inspired to more or less reproduce a desk a person made. An artist friend looked at it and started pointing to design elements and exclaiming, "what is this all about". There were 12 all together. But the shape of the table was gorgeous. I kept the shape, made it from plain rift ash with a splash of subdued curly ash here and there and it turned out pleasing. On the other hand I made a plane rectangular chest of drawers with crotch veneer drawer fronts. The only thing of interest to look at in a plain rectangular chest of drawers are the drawer fronts. About all I could do was proportion the rectangle attractively.

Re: Clock progress

#17

Re: Are you saying my clock is ugly?

Jesse Cloud

Actually Joe, I had you in mind when I wrote " I admire those with more talent who can blend curly maple into a cohesive piece." :D

Re: Clock progress

#18

Re: What works for Curtis.....

TomD

"may not apply to all designs. Curtis designs chairs. He wants the customer to see the chair, and not be distracted by some element of the chair.

In the case of a table, the objective could be to celebrate the shape of the table and its elements- legs, molding, etc. In this case Curtis suggested imagining the table painted black. Would it look attractive painted black? In this case none of the decoration on the table should capture the eye at the expense of the whole of it."

Dunbar 101, as far as chairs. It is as basic as not saying "that shape is a nice colour". You need to think in an organized way.

"Krenov pieces are usually all about the shape and he doesn't distract from these shapes with figured woods or other ornamentation."

Like spalted wood or marketry?

"But the objective may be to celebrate a spectacular piece of wood. It could be tuned into a vase (or clock), but the vase ideally should have a nice shape if painted black, says Curtis."

Raffan 101, he has videos where he does that, and was long influenced by the fact that bowls "all" turn black over enough time.

"I think a lot of Studio furniture is all about the wood, and there is much less to the shape. Or the shape is attractive but overwhelmed by the wood for no good reason."

Some very needy stuff is out there for sure, but there is tons of Studio furniture that is driven by form. For one thing a lot of it is actually painted in solids. Design is design: Some people worked their ideas out in their garage, and moved to a rural lemon farm; others went to art school, set up in a studio and distributed through urban outlets.

Re: Clock progress

#19

Ellis Walentine

A far-ranging discussion for sure

Ellis Walentine

Joe, thanks for starting this, because it has brought us full-circle back to the topic of design, with some very interesting insights on maple, finishing, stains, etc. that might be of use to you in your pursuit of this clock project.

I'm intrigued by the discussion of design that follows your post. There have been some really good rules of thumb detailed here. A lot of these observations aren't intuitive to many woodworkers. There are certainly a lot of variables that can enter into the design equation -- color, form and detail among them.

The notion of three centers of interest is probably sound, though it seems somewhat arbitrary. The intent of the designer, and his skill with combining elements of construction -- form, line, function, cost, negative space, features, materials, etc. -- are all important considerations.

I am wary of formulaic solutions to design problems. For one thing, they can lead you to predictable and non-creative solutions. To reduce the design process to this sort of analysis inherently forecloses other possibilities.

I guess if I were to advocate a particular approach to design -- which I am loathe to do -- it would be to start with the desired outcome and work back from there, considering materials, function, resources and any other constraints. Aesthetics are important to you and the customer, so those are the people you need to satisfy. If the customer is you, it gives you freer rein to design what suits you.

This said, there are aesthetic parameters that succeed or fail by the weight of their own validity. There are no prescriptions -- at least in my world -- for validating aesthetics. Dunbar and Krenov are/were friends of mine. They were secure in different ways. Mike's aesthetics began with his appreciation of the Windsor form and ended with his extremely pragmatic, scientific and organized way of reproducing it and transferring his understanding to a lot of people, who have gone on to produce extremely creditable furniture, in effect furthering and maintaining this classic style.

Krenov's approach was to show his reverence for wood and to discuss his relationship to the creative process, including the skills, tooling and awarenesses he brought to the party. They both have inspired a generation of woodworkers to understand and embrace their teachings as a jumping-off point for their own investigations -- Krenov more than Dunbar on this -- and to explore their own creative potentials.

I can get much deeper into this, but this seems like a logical stopping point for this particular post. I wonder if we shouldn't move the whole thing up to level 1 for further discussion.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Clock progress

#20

Moving to "Level 1"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I wonder if we shouldn't move the whole thing up to level 1 for further discussion."

You are just the person to get it started there.

Re: Clock progress

#21

Re: A far-ranging discussion for sure

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Joe, thanks for starting this,"

You're welcome. :)

"I'm intrigued by the discussion of design that follows your post. There have been some really good rules of thumb detailed here."

I am also. But I am not well versed or trained in "Design". I go by seat-of-the-pants mostly.

That half round table I made last year, I made up in my head mostly. I did make a cardboard mock up to make sure it would fit, and look ok, in the space I planed to put it. I didn't draw up plans with measurements and details. I didn't draw it out and make sure the apron and table top thickness met some special Golden Ratio or anything. Just did what I thought looked right and made things up as I went along.

The clock too is kinda in my head. No drawings. I did read several magazine article to get some ideas on different ways to construct it and different dimensions and so on. But there isn't a plan or cut list.

I think most things I make are done that way. Tables, candle stands, and so on. Hand cut DT's? I dont' have patience to make sure everything is spaced precisely, just do it. Close enough for me.

Huge flaw on my part I suppose. But I don't have patience to create plans and plan ahead (another flaw - it bites me now and then I admit).

I have to admit, when magazine articles get in depth about design, ratios, geometry, math and what not, my brain goes numb and I start to itch all over. My attention span is way too short. Another flaw. I would add up all my woodworking flaws, but I'm not very good with math.

I like simple. Probably why I've always like Shaker stuff.

I wonder how much thought Issac Newton Youngs put into the design and look of his wall clocks in the mid 1800's. Again, not well versed in design, but I don't think the case dimensions are to any Golden Ratio or anything, but it looks right to me.

I realize I am painting with a really big brush here, and design theory aside, but doesn't it come down to what looks right to you? I don't make a living doing this and I've never made anything complex and beautiful like a Philadelphia High Boy. When I make a table and get man glitter (saw dust) all over me, I don't care if the neighbor likes its look or not (I don't care for him anyway). In my simple ADD brain, it's a bit analogous to photography; you either have an eye for it or you don't. In that case (case being you don't have the eye), I suppose design, design theory, details, and all the nuances that come along with it are much more important.

Can beautiful furniture be designed and made in your head and built to the dimensions you see in your head (specific joinery details aside), or do you have to design it out using design rules and theory?

I would be interested if you moved this to 'Level 1' but I wouldn't have much if anything to contribute, please do though. I'm a woodworking hack. :)