Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Posts

OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#1

OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Bill Howatt

Last night I saw on Ask This Old House a segment on lighting a basement with one switch. That wasn't a big deal but the discussion in the shop after the job indicated that all new construction switch wiring required the hot to come into the switch's box first and then go to the fixture(s). The other method of putting the hot into the octagon ceiling box and then running a white/black to a switch was not allowed in new construction.

The justification for the change was that a lot of new electronic switch gizmos, such as timers, require both a hot and a neutral at the switch location.

Any comments? Is/has that been in effect long? Up here north of the border it doesn't seem to be a rule or known about.

Thanks,

Bill

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#2

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The old "Switch Leg" method's been a no-no in my area for quite a while.

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#4

Thanks for the info


Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#5

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I understand that's a new code requirement, but, as far as I know, you're not prohibited from running power to the light fixture and then back to a switch; you just have to offer a neutral in the switch box. You could get the same effect by running three-wire NM (or, if in conduit, three wires, all of this in addition to your equipment ground) from the powered box back to the switch box, then capping off the neutral.

But, of course, it all depends on your local inspector, and your local code.

A lot of new dimmers and other devices are powered, so you need a neutral.

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#6

Home Automation

Tony - Memphis

I fool around with a lot of home automationa and you definitely need a neutral for that. Our house was built in W. Tn in '98 and we have neutrals in the switch boxes (thank goodness).

Tony

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#7

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Jay Lombardo

Another of the many, many advantages of using EMT. You can always install another wire. Bring a neutral to a switch box, add a switch leg, add a separate circuit, etc. I spent 44 yrs as electrician in Chicagoland where all installations are required to be in conduit, no Romex or BX allowed. A good residential electrician can rough and pull a house just about as fast as it can be done in Romex, just my opinion, not looking for a fight. If you run conduit you can go anywhere first. I specify a residential guy because I would get fired on the second day of residential work ( not fast enough) but I spent most of my career running threaded rigid conduit in Commercial and Industrial projects, a lot of it explosion proof, 2 different animals.

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#8

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Barry Irby

Interesting. You say all residences in your area are wired in EMT or even rigid conduit? I have heard this, but I did not know for sure. Even detached single family houses? I have been doing home inspections in the Richmond, VA area for thirty years and have never seen a house wired in conduit.

In the early 70's I was building my own house on the side while working in commercial construction. I hired a couple of guys off the job to help me wire it. They were completely baffled by Romex (No way to do it, you don't have enough colors!) and quit. I had to finish wiring it myself.

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

#9

Re: OT: New switch wiring requirement?

Jay Lombardo

Barry, I know exactly how they felt! Many years ago I had to wire a good friend's cottage up in Wisconsin in Romex, never again I hated it!!! No there isn't any rigid used in residential but it is all in EMT, including detached single family. With all the foam insulation being installed these days it seems to me that would make it much more difficult to make changes with Romex. With the conduit you can make changes, additional circuits and upgrades a whole lot easier, just pull more wires in the pipe. You can stuff 13 THHN #14's in a 1/2" conduit legaly. I would never put that many in, it's very bad practice, but I'm pretty comfortable with 9. I suppose I'm a bit biased but we like it around here.