Tenons
David Frame
Hi all,
I was wondering why is it necessary to make haunched tenons?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tenons
David Frame
Hi all,
I was wondering why is it necessary to make haunched tenons?
Re: Tenons
Jack Guzman from Maine
The haunch keeps the ends from going out of alignment over time.---Jack
Re: Tenons
Ellis Walentine
Not totally necessary, but when you do cope and stick joinery, the haunch fills the slot at the end of the stile. Also, as Jack said, it keeps the tenon from twisting and it helps mitigate a serious short grain condition at the top of the mortise.
Makes life easier. 
Ellis
Think if it as an appendix
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It was useful in times past. When the groove for the panel was plowed with the hand plane it extended to the end of the stile. The tenon had to have a haunch to fill the groove.
I thin the anti twisting explanation makes no sense. That piddly bit hardly adds to the already considerable anti twisting effect of the rest of the tenon.
Right about twisting
Ellis Walentine
Not significant, but still a potential visual through joint if not plugged with the haunch.
Ellis
Re: Tenons
Dick Coers
Also ties into the history of hand chopping the mortise. You had to hold it back from the end so you wouldn't blow it out. The stile was also left long till the joinery was done, but you still had to keep the mortise back. In smaller scale work, I feel it still serves a purpose.
Re: Think if it as an appendix
Sgian Dubh
"I think the anti twisting explanation makes no sense."
Bill, in a situation where the tenoned rail of, let's say, a coffee or dining table is inset from the face of a leg I agree, the haunch is probably not necessary at all.
However, in the situation where the face of the rail and the face of the leg are flush, the haunch does have a role in reducing the chance of misalignment at the shoulder line that might be caused by cupping of the tenoned rail. Granted the role of the haunch may be small in a small structure, but when used with a wide rail in some sort of construction (not necessarily a table), say 8" or 12" wide, the haunch may take up an inch, inch and a half, or more of the rail's width towards the frame's outer edge, and preventing or limiting cupping becomes more important.
Note that I'm not necessarily disagreeing with your 'anti-twisting' analysis, I'm highlighting a well known reason for including a haunch where it's not needed to fill a groove or similar, e.g., in a panelled door construction. Slainte.
Re: Think if it as an appendix
Jack Guzman from Maine
Bill,
I repair old furniture and I have seen such movement personally. Usually the piece with the tenon cups.It isn't alot of movement but it would not have happened with a haunch. It does happen.---Jack