Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, it's that time again -- time to toss out another contentious question for your thoughts and opinions. As usual we'll be distilling replies to their essence and sending them off to Woodworker West magazine, where our bi-monthly column "News & Views" has appeared for the past 15 years.

This time around, I would like to hear your musings on "making do," or getting by with less. Not everyone can afford every conceivable tool and machine, nor do many of us have the luxury of a large shop. So how do we manage to get things done. I'll be interested to hear some of your coping strategies. How have you arrived at the right mix of resources to accompllish what you want to accomplish? (Hint: It might involve outsourcing some things you can't do alone.) Has your formula changed over time? Do you adjust your ambitions to the tools at hand, or do you tool up to meet your ambitions?

We all get by with what we have. Let's hear your stories of how you do it.

Ellis Walentine, Host

WoodCentral.com

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#2

Approach changed over time

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the beginning if I faced something to do and didn't have the ideal tool to do it I acquired the new tool, if it was affordable. Over time I have drifted to only buying something new if something I already have can't be made to work.

I don't carve. To become proficient would require more effort than I am interested in devoting. Hence, when I need a carving I hire someone to do it.

The decision to learn or hire out depends on interest, how hard the new skill would be to learn proficiently and whether the new skill would be often used in the future. In any case, not knowing how to do some detail does not stop me from building something I want to build.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#3

ebd

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

ebd

I pretty much have every machine (though not top-of-the-line) I need. However, I recently joined a woodworking club that has a magnificantly equipped shop (multiple machines of every concievable type) and even a loan section. It's less convienent, but those whithout the money, room, or enough need can get just about anything they want done by using the facilities. There are even special interest groups that meet weekly that will give you a hand on something you are ot sure of or have not done before. It's a phenominal resource.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#4

An Old AW Editor's Piece...

David Yoho

When I first starting receiving the old black and white issues of American Woodworker magazine I remember reading a piece by David Sloan that talked about this very topic. Since I was in the infancy of my woodworking journey, it had a real impact on me at the time.

In the early years when money was tight I made due as best as I could. My tool arsenal consisted of a router, a radial arm saw, a circular saw, a drill, a saber saw, and a belt sander. I added power tools as I could afford them from the money I made making stuff.

Probably the one tool I use all the time that I "make do" with is my free-standing maple work bench that I built many years ago. I say "make do with" because it's not like the normal woodworker's bench. There are no vises attached, nor tool trough, no storage below, or dog holes, or hold fasts on my bench. It's just a simple heavy duty work bench that doubles as an outfeed table for my tablesaw, a surface where I do most of my joinery work, assembly, and finishing. I use various clamps to hold parts to my bench when sawing, routing, or any other function where the parts need holding. I've been working this way for over 25 years and it's worked fine so far.

My shop doesn't have space for a lathe in addition to the equipment I have set up so whenever I need something turned I just hire someone for the task.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#5

I cheat

John in NM

By shamelessly making use of tools at work. Lucky for me the manager does not mind (at least not much). A knee mill makes a fantastic router btw.

The mill is the only thing I use for woodworking, but it does enable me to do stuff I could probably do no other way. I've also made a fair number of tools and jigs out of steel and aluminum that make working in my own shop far easier.

Other than that, lacking the right expensive jig or machine is what often pushes me to use a hand tool to do the same job. Some of the joints I used to make for chairs were good examples of this - difficult to hold and index using machines, as trivial as cutting to lines with hand tools.

In the last few years, most of my woodworking has been stuff for sale, and that has made me much more ready to just buy the machine I need. That really does change the equation.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

chrispy

Vacuum bagging. I built a credenza with curved doors, basically by cutting 5/8 in deep cuts in the back of cherry plywood every 1/2 in and then bending the ply to the required curve and filling the cuts with an epoxy/microbaloon mixture. The ply was then veneered. Rather than an expensive vacuum system, I put the laminate (ply and veneer) in a plastic garbage bag with the end of my shopvac hose wrapped inside and all reasonably tightly sealed with 2in packing tape. The end of the hose was inside a auto wash mit to prevent the hose from sucking up the plastic bag. The veneer was glued with regular yellow glue and left with the shopvac on for about 1 hour. That was about 5 years ago and no problems so far. A VERY CHEAP SOLUTION TO AN $800+ VAVCUUM PROBLEM!!!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Mike Circo

I "make do" by trading time/patience for tools.

I have the essential equipment in my home shop to complete most of the tasks. But when I get to a special point in a project requiring that extra tool, I'll get creative. Instead of buying a new tool, I'll make a jig, pull out hand tools, improvise or (gasp) alter the design a bit.

Since I'm under no time constraint, I enjoy the challenge of doing more with less. I thrive on the problem solving that "making do" presents. Yes, it would be cool to have that next special thing in my shop, but I'm already tight on space and money, so I call it part of the process to get by with what I have.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Bill Marr

In 1985 when my good friend Tony got me interested in woodworking, the only power tools I had were a drill, skill saw and router. I decided to make a 7 ft bookshelf for the family room. Working in the garage, I dadoed the side panels for the shelves. During the glue-up I struggled getting the shelves into the dadoes because the side panels were bowed. To resolve the issue, I laid the bookshelf on it's side, put a 2x4 on it, made a 'T' with 2x4s that would reach the garage ceiling and inserted a hydraulic jack between the case and 2x4 to jack the side into alignment while the glue dried. It worked! Clearly "necessity was the mother of invention".

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Jesse Cloud

Be patient. Keep your eye out for that tool that you want on craigslist. With the large number of cabinet shops going out of business, I have been able to afford a few tools that were out of my reach.

Secondly, don't be a collector. When you need a new tool, look for an unused tool or two that you can sell to fund the new purchase.

Thirdly, build your skill with hand tools. A well used hand tool can do the job of an expensive, specialized power tool.

Lastly, don't buy trash, even when times are tight. I bought three tablesaws before I got a decent one - would have been much cheaper to save up and buy the decent one and be done with it.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Jim Hoeller

I watched an episode of "The Woodwright's Shop" with Christopher Schwartz as a guest. The subject was hand planes with a focus on the fore or scrub plane. He demonstrated the relative ease in flattening a board with a fore plane and, as importantly, that one can be made from a flea market jack plane that is in decent shape. If the iron is good, grind a slight radius in the edge (about an 8" to 8 1/2") and sharpen it. I had an old Stanley Handyman plane ($7.98 brand new back in the early 70's) that was ripe for a conversion. I built a jig for grinding the iron and getting it sharp. It has worked well and taken the twist or other irregularities out of quite a few walnut, oak, cherry and maple boards. The iron in the plane has held up better than I expected and saved me the cost of a new one.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Rum

Making due is partially a state of mind. If you feel oppressed by it it can be a bit inhibiting, on the other hand it can also be an interesting way to

Sometimes its an excellent method of skill building. There have been a number of times where I've wanted to make something and didn't have the "correct" tooling. This usually resulted in some compromises:

- redesign to fit the tooling I have. Often this is dropping some details or adjusting the joinery or in some cases re-thinking the whole project from the ground up in terms of what I have available.

- there is often another way to accomplish the same task that might just take longer or be harder to do.

When I was a kid we lived for years with no electricity so I acquired a mediocrity (yes that's the intended word) of proficiency with hand tools. Being low on dollars and far from town also lead to some innovative work. A lot of the tools we had were old, well worn and not necessarily well taken care of either (the number of hammered on chisel sockets I've seen still makes me sad). I'm sure I'm not the only person to whittle a coping saw out of two bolts and some wood from the kindling pile with his pocket knife (and a hack saw to cut the slots in the bolts), but I also suspect it wouldn't be the first thought most people would have. This has lead to perhaps a bit of an excess of "I can do/fix that" mindset.

A few years back I went on a bit of a tool upgrade/acquisition spree having "made do" for a long time before that (with a brief hiatus from making do in the mid 80s in high school wood shop where they had a very nice tool collection). I now have almost every basic tool I could want and fairly nice ones at that. My products are definitely much nicer and I generally enjoy working with them a lot more but I'm not entirely convinced I'm a lot better woodworker (still hopeful and hey enjoying it more is a treat in itself).

I would second the "don't buy junk" statement. Its better to make do with fewer quality tools than more junk tools. Junk tools make everything harder, and often just plain don't work. I was over at a friends house helping him make a chicken coop and he had three skil saw derivatives not one of which had a flat bottom plate and all them them were made from flimsy plastic and tinfoil so getting a straight cut was a bit more of a challenge than it should have been. In the end he'd have been way ahead to have bought one. A decent hand saw would have been almost as fast in this case and easier to cut straight with.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#12

Dat Mutha "Necessity"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

In the ShoeBox Woodshop we [that's me and the elves who keep stealing my pencils] make do in most every operation with what's at hand. When a 13" planer can't do the job, out comes the router-planing jig. If a piece is too big the be set up on a saw, either saw or other things got moved as everything is on wheels. The lack of space forces a workflow that is organized and thought out in advance so that each operation needed for the entire project is planned in sequence. Absent a fatal mistake on a component, the planer comes out of its niche once. Same for the sander. Same for the router table. Haven't purchased a new power tool (except to replace one) in over 10 years. Don't go to wood shows to find out about that latest doomaflitchee that I can't be a man, let alone a true craftsman, if I don't buy.

There's no question that, even though I have the T-shirt, I will not be the one to die with the most tools.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#13

Clint Searl

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Clint Searl

I still haven't figured out why I bought that double handle scorp 38 years ago.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

When I was a hobbyist, I used to go to the traveling woodworking shows. I usually came home with new gadgets. I used to think how handy they would be Generally they were specialty jigs, or widgets. All these years later, most are in the back of shop cupboards....often times still in their packages.

It's not to say that they are worthless. It's just that I develop basic approaches to my work or improvise in the moment, and forget I even have the widgets. (wherever I put them)

Now that I think about it, we are thinking of having a garage sale later this year. Maybe I have a good reason to hunt for those gadgets after all.

T.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#15

Ellis Walentine

Me too

Ellis Walentine

When I signed on at AW back in '92, Sloan mentioneed that that editorial was one of his most popular ever. At that point, I had already been making do for over 20 years. In fact, the first dresser I ever built was made with a hand saw, a block plane and a chisel, from rough-sawn hemlock that I surfaced with just that block plane. Try flattening a 10-in.-wide board with an old flea market Stanley block plane and you'll understand the true meaning of making do. But it's also a lesson in how to do it in a pinch. Lotsa valuable lessons there.

Thanks for the memory, David.

Ellis

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#16

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have been making sawdust in one fashion, or another for 65+ years. There are a couple of major items on my "make do" list. I have had 3 different shops over the years, and they have all been in the basement. I have learned how to adjust to a basement shop. With limited space, organization is paramount. A place for everything, and everything in its place. I keep my thickness planer in the garage, along with wood storage. Lumber normally gets milled to thickness outside before going to the shop. I set up a wheelbarrow at the end of the planer to catch the shavings and roll them directly to the shrubs as mulch, sweep up the dust, and I am done. This enables me to move lumber around easily, and there is no dust, or noise in the basement. Not the perfect solution, but it works.

The second "make do" for me is my 1967 Craftsman table saw. It has a solid cast iron top with a cast iron wing on each side which gives me plenty of table surface. It is well tuned, and does an excellent, reliable job for me. I do not do much work with plywood, and I break the sheet down outside, or in the garage with a circular saw when necessary. It has not limited me in any furniture, or home improvement project I have wanted to undertake.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#17

Re: some musical musings on the subject...

TomD

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/watch-on-line/2014-2015-episodes/

Check out the Woodwright's Musical episode, around 2:00 you get answers as to what happens between beginnings, and endings of accumulation.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#18

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

clay foster

Many times for me, getting by with less means figuring out how to move or make something without a helper. One job entailed making and delivering four 8 foot tall, 4 foot wide doors that weighed 500 pounds each by myself. I recently completed 32 linear feet of 8' tall display cabinets, delivered and installed by myself in a second story man cave. I'm not a big guy (5'8" x 150 pounds) so I've learned how to think smart rather than brawn. The last shop I built, I installed 18 24' long trusses by myself. Sometimes I think it might be easier not having a helper, although having a young flat belly to unload bags of concrete mix is sounding more appealing each year that I pass the three score mark.