Re: Anybody got a humidifier you like?
Grant in Iowa
We use a large portable for our home. It lives in the basement and gets filled every other day or so when it is below freezing outside. With two people in our five year old 3600 square foot home, we don't make enough moisture with our own activities, and need a boost with a humidifier to keep from having skin issues in the depths of winter. And, I like to avoid the wooden items in the home from moving more than necessary. <- might be my main reason, really.
We like the portable because I can easily see all of the parts and can therefore continuously monitor any mold growth. And, when it fails, I can buy another one easily. We humidify to about 30% RH, and don't try for much higher. Most sizing charts are for people desiring 40% or more RH, so they get sold on thinking a portable unit will not work for them.
No way would I install one on a furnace. Even if you have your ducts cleaned regularly, you are basically creating a large mold and mildew machine. Ask any HVAC guy, or home inspector (who doesn't sell them). Most of them will have seen what the inside of the supply air ducts look like after a few years of running an attached humidifier. I don't get too bent out of shape about mold, but this is one mold maker that is easy to avoid.
Commercial systems use steam introduced to supply air ducts, which is a notch better but still a mold factory long term. It is better because the steam better dissipates into the supply air stream, and is less likely (though still pretty likely), to condensate within the ducts. Such systems can be had from Honeywell, if you have your mind set on such a system.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa <- Facility manager in a large museum where we make lots of humidity