First time drying wood and I'm located far away. So I stickered a couple of walnut logs in August in a sizable but closed shed (12x24x9). Arkansas. The sawyer cut all to 5/4s. Maintenance man at the place opened up the shed a few times and turned on a huge fan to air things out. Yesterday I visited the stack for the first time. Looks good except for the black mold, only at the stickers. Looks like the initial moisture wicked into the dry stickers (cut from 3/4" ply) to sponsor the mold on them.
The mold isn't extremely wooly, and everything is quite dry to the touch now. But I'm wondering how much discoloration of the wood might have happened. Or perhaps all this is common. Perhaps I should restack and re-sticker?
All of the instructional information I have read on air drying suggested that continuous cross ventilation is necessary to dry the wood down to 12%. Depending on the volume of wood in the shed it might be necessary to ventilate every few days if continuous venting via windows is not possible. Can't suggest how large a pair of window openings would need to be, but one would not provide cross ventilation.
Don is right, you needed more ventilation at the start. It would seem rather optimistic to think you don't have any sticker stain. I've always been told to not use plywood. It wasn't oak veneer was it?
When putting up fresh wood for air drying you need to be prepared to shuffle your stack(s) and move your stickers at intervals. I move stuff on the 2nd, 5th, and 10th day, then once a month for 5 months. Stack and leave and you'll be "asking" for sticker stain.
Before stacking I also wash both the boards and the stickers with chlorine bleach water and lay the pieces out to surface dry.
Been drying pick-up loads of lumber since 1988 and have Never restacked my lumber. Not one sticker stain that I recall. Have dried: walnut, cherry, white oak, elm, sycamore, SYP and others. Even dried holly, during the winter, to cold for stain to set in.
The problem with the original poster as discussed is little or no ventilation, you have created a sauna.
In this case I would restack outdoor and cover, leave the sides of the lumber open by spring it should be AD ,<15%.
Yes, it probably was a sauna though the area is dry now. If my $50 meter is to be believed, with the short pins in, wood is at 12% after 5 months. No, not believable except maybe on the surface, but it'll be a long while before I have time to cut into it anyway.
I might write off those stickers and re-stack it with new stickers when I can.
Over the years I have seen millions of bdft of wood on sticks and I have never heard of anyone ever moving a stick, once stacked. There is no need to do so ever for easily stained wood like white pine and soft maple, providing the sticks are dry and there is ample air circulation through the stack. Shown is a portion of the several million bdft or oak stacked at the Baillie mill in South Carolina. These sticks don't move until the lumber is dry.
The mistake made here was inadequate air movement through the pile in warm temperatures.
Walnut is hard to stain. I have seen it dead packed prior to steaming in the summer with lots of mold established on the surface but the wood within was fine and the steaming, when it finally occurred, killed the mold. I predict that it will be undamaged. Let me know when you work some.
Bill has long history with this and knows this stuff.
I have only dried about ten thousand feet, not the millions he has watched. About six or eight years ago I dried about five thousand feet of walnut and cherry. We cut it off the family farm. I went to Lowe's and bought several stack of discounted lumber and sawed it into stickers. Literally about a mile of sticks. They were dry.
Stacked the wood in a shed on the side of a barn open on three sides. It dried fine.
Your mistake was putting in a space without enough air flow.
The plywood sticks might be part of the problem. Not sure, but the fact that it is a bunch of layers separated by glue might have had an effect, making them less absorbent. Also, I think it is wise to have larger sticks, maybe an inch or more thick to allow for air circulation. Mine were on the small side, about 3/4", but I got away with it because my stacks were in the wind.
Its IMPORTANT the stack be on a base or platform that is FLAT, as in a plane. And the stickers should be exactly the same thickness and aligned above each other.
Like Bill, I never even heard of anybody restacking the pile like Mark did. It might be good and certainly did not hurt anything and it saved him a trip or two to the gym, but I think it was over kill.
I think your situation is "over" and I would not bother to restack it. Out of curiosity you might pull out the worst looking piece you can get to and run it through a planer. I bet you like what you find.
never have used plywood for stickers but I believe the reason is: If you cut 3/4" plywood into 3/4" strips, they break easy. Could be wrong on that, but that's what I think.
Another reason why plywood doesn't make for good stickers is that it isn't rigid enough to keep the weight properly distributed in the stack to keep the boards flat and straight. ..But I, myself, would feel more comfortable with 1" stickers if there isn't especially good air movement.
You make no mention how wide the plywood strips were, nor if you started the stack up off the floor out away from the wall.
If the strips are too wide, the MC will be slower to come down under them. The heartwood may not stain, but the sapwood surely will.
If you just started your stack on strips right on the floor, you certainly need to restack to get that bottom wood up on top. The MC will be higher down on the bottom, than it would if up on blocks.
As others have said, your main problem is almost certainly lack of airflow to take away moisture. I've never come across a drying operation that rotates stacks and resticks the lot once they're set up. However, there are stickers available that wood dryers use to help reduce the chance of mould or sticker stain developing. My US sources indicate that 3/4" thick stickers are pretty much universal for all drying situations there, and they're usually 1-1/4" or 1-1/2" wide. Popular choices for stickers are fir, poplar or spruce because they're neutral, quite stable and not likely to cause staining. Here in the UK sticker thickness can vary a bit according to what's being dried and what type of drying is being undertaken, e.g., air dried or kiln dried, or to increase or decrease the drying speed, etc.
However, here are a couple of types used to reduce the chance of sticker stain, the upper one being one example from the UK and the one below it a type from the US photographed by Bill Tindall to help me with a written project I was working on. Slainte.
Guess I learned from a "nobody," old Simmy Agin, who, until he passed several years ago, run his own mill here in NJ for more than 50 years. A walk through Simmy's drying barn was an opportunity to spend some real time learning about wood. "Shuffle & Weight" was Sim's method to get dead straight and flat boards in any species, all air dried.
The "US" stick was from a mill that dries poplar very fast (from saw to dry shed in days not weeks). The grooves promote air flow and drying in the stick area for these short drying cycles. Also, this mill exports lumber and these grooved sticks don't leave a mark on the wood that is an appearance issue more than anything. The export market is as picky about appearance as function. The mark left from flat sticks is removed in typical surfacing.
I have never seen a softwood stick on a hardwood yard. Typically the sticks are cut from some tough stiff wood so that they last over time and provide adequate bridging over gaps in the stack. Imagine assembling a stack of 10, 11 and 12' lumber , a typical case. The layers containing a 10 or 11' foot board will leave an unsupported stick bridging the gap. It must be stiff enough to support a 12' board piled above the gap.
Always eager to hear your opinion, could you speak to spacing for the stickers when drying lumber?
Like others, I have experience with drying my own lumber, around 10,000 board feet so far. I tend to err on the side of spacing stickers too closely, given that I don't have vast experience. I will generally space them on 16" centers for 4/4 hard woods (Cherry, Walnut, Oak, Maple).
I will deviate if I know I need to support some shorter lumber atop longer lumber. In that case, I will add a column of stickers as I build the pile so the end of the shorter lumber is supported when I get to it.
The stickers I use are 5/8", 4' long and cut from SPF several years ago. I ripped, then planed them to accurate thickness. While on the thin side, I copied what a local pro uses, since I bought a bunch from him when I started out and wanted to stay uniform.
Of course old Simmy also sealed his board ends using boiling (literally smoking) paraffin. In all times I went to his place to buy wood, I never once found a board with an end-check.
[No I don't do boiling wax to end-seal what I put up to dry]
I am usually stick short and wind up spacing 2'. Works for me but I don't recommend it if you have plenty of sticks. I use 1" sticks to promote more rapid air drying.
Mills with mountains of sticks space closer and spacing varies by species and thickness. In my article on "Where Hardwood comes from" I think I have data from the mill in Cranberry , NC. Seems like I remember 12 and 24" depending on species and thickness, but check.
The picture of the poplar coming out of the dip tank shows 8/4 poplar with 24" spacing.
The picture showing stacks being made shows a 12" spacing at each end (common) with either 18 or 24 in the center. Again 8/4 which doesn't require as many sticks.
I cut thick and use very few stickers, I don't worry about how many because I stack them on top of each other so the load has a column to follow. I see pro stacks come off where there is the odd pretzel board because the wood was thin and the stickers not aligned.