Is there a formula to find if a tightly fit bolt with ring centered through the 3 1/2 width dimension of a 2 x 4 weakens or if there is no change to the 2x4's strength? I need to add a weight to the ring but don't want to risk the 2x4.
You did not describe the details of the load. But the short answer is that the details of the 2 x 4 ( growth rings, species, knots) is going to be more important to strength than this hole.
I took a timber engineering class back in college. It seems to me we need a little more info.
Even if we ignore the quality and qualities of the 2X4 and assume "it is what it is", we would at least need to know its orientation. (The hole might have a different effect on a straight tight grained 2X4 than on a shabby knotty one that might break at a preexisting defect before it broke at the hole.)
IIRC, from that ancient classroom, if you drill though wider face the 2x4 and then apply the load hanging perpendicular to the face (wider face down) It would reduce the strength by whatever percentage of the width the hole represents. So if its a half inch hole it would reduce the strength by about one seventh.
If you turn the 2X4 on its edge and then apply the load straight down and the hole is near the center of both the length and width, the strength would be reduce very little. Almost none. Ignoring the twisting force from the loop being on one side and assuming the timber is restrained form turning over.
If the hole is near the top or bottom edge the calculation would be different and the hole would reduce the strength considerably. As if you reduced the timber from 3 1/2 to 3" wide. OTOH, if the hole were near the end of the timber the effect would be greatly reduced.
The building code addresses this with a long series of rules because plumbers and electricians drill holes in joists all the time.
The answer, and I suspect you already know this, is yes, any material removed from the wood will weaken it. The real question is how much and is that too much. Is this some application where appearance is a big deal? Is the 2X4 easily accessible? If you can get to the other side of it, laminating some stronger material with epoxy and using a big washer to spread the load further would probably solve the problem. The laminating material could be anything from 1/2" plywood to steel. If you are going for a rustic look, as the eye-and-loop would suggest you could use an iron or steel plate maybe 3" wide and artificially age it to blend in.
building rule of thumb. Hole in the center 1/3 of the wood. Diameter of hole no more than 1/4 of the width of the wood. Will not appreciably alter the strength or load bearing capacity of the wood.
It seems I have two problems. (1) Strength of the truss wood, and (2)perpendicular weight that can be exerted on that truss. Perhaps this will aid in clearing the mud. There are eight of the pictured in my garage. All were here when I moved in well over a decade ago. (Seven are 3/8"screw ins and one is a 3/8" through bolt with washer. All are tight in the hole they occupy with no noticeable play.) They are located on four different very hard garage roof 24 foot span trusses. Some rings are near a wall support and three are more or less centered on the truss. Right now five (on two trusses located nearest the rear wall hold coiled stuff like tree rope and a come-along or two. The remainder do not hold anything except empty straps, but I have used them in three seasons to stretch electrical extension cables above and across the bays to keep them off the floor. They have also been used with heavy string to hold finish drying wood upright. They do not directly support a drying object just hold it in a vertical position so that it can dry on both sides (think the sides of 8 foot tall book shelf balanced vertically) I don't worry about the three to five pounds of an electrical extension cable but every time I look at the others I wonder just how much weight perpendicular to the 2x4 would be excessive. Truss manufacturers, so far, have been unresponsive, and local lumber yards even less. My thinking has been that if a hole is drilled but then that space is tightly occupied by a material more dense than the wood (steel in this case), is the wood weakened, or the same? And by how much? Perpendicular weight is another matter and likely more important.
I can sister plywood or steel plate gussets almost any place around the bolts, but will drilling or nailing the truss further help or hurt the strength?
Personally, I wouldn't be too worried until I was getting over 100 pounds or so - this is just a guess. I believe that the filling of the hole by the bolt does not bring the wood back to full strength. If I wanted to hang a significant weight I would opt for the plywood or steel plate gussets and carry them a foot or so on either side. Probably overkill but cheap.
Gary, engineering review is always suggested if not required when drilling holes in beams as you've shown. The section modulus at that pont is directly affected by the hole and can result in a significant loss of bending and shear strength. There are guidelines for hole size and placement that you ought to check into before making your final decision.
In the case of typical trusses like you would have in a garage, the bottom chord's primary function is to keep the length of the truss constant, not to bear loads. When I rebuilt my shop/barn in '99, we used engineered softwood trusses with 2x6 chords. The clear span in the center came with some recommended maximum load, which was pretty minimal. Your actual mileage will vary with the specifics of your trusses, but it wouldn't hurt to gauge the maximum load you expect to hang from these bolts, add a safety factor, and then check with an engineering pal as to whether it will be safe, first of all, and then how much deflection you may expect, as this could affect other performance and appearance factors.
Here's a link to an engineering paper summarizing the engineering specifications.
You could get better info from truss builders if you could supply them with load information - how much and where. They will not be able to tell you what kind of load will be safe, but they will be able to tell you how to build a truss to carry the load you want.
Just by the seat of the pants, I don't think the hole will be the problem - it's where the hole is that is the problem. The bottom string is not intended to be loaded this way, and where the truss will fail is likely the joint between the bottom string and the diagonals. I would guess that the failure would occur well under 300# load based on the couple of truss failures I've seen - one doing something similar to what's in your garage. Another possibility is that the top string of the truss could pull away from the roof sheathing, though I bet the joints of the truss would go first.
If you have to, cut some 2x to join the area of the point load to the top string of adjacent trusses. But lifting point loads on even several roof trusses is just not a good idea. They are not designed for it and they are going to break in some way. People get away with it for a while, then get more confident and lift heavier things.... and then they start cracking truss members.
Gary, The phrasing of your OP left me confused. You asked about drilling through the face and then showed a picture of it being drilled through the edge. Also you did not mention the thing being drilled was the Chord of a truss. This changes two or three things.
Generally, trusses are Engineered and not supposed to be cut drill or altered on site. The Engineer designed it and stands behind the design unless you alter it.
The bottom chord of a truss is usually in tension. Its being "stretched". Your thought about the shaft of the bolt replacing the wood does not come into play here. If the wood was in compression it might help to have the hole filled.
With the wood in tension. Drilling a hole through it would have the effect I talked about above. Assuming its a 1/2" hole through a 1 1/2" timber would drill away one third of the fibers and thus about a third of the strength. It would be the same effect as setting a saw to cut a half inch deep and saw a kerf right up the side of one of the 2 x 4's. Assuming the hole goes all the way through.
Why haven't the trusses failed? They were over designed. A 2 x 4 is the smallest piece typically used for the bottom chord of a truss. If the calculations indicated a 1 x 4 or a 2 x 3 would do the job, they would have used a 2 x 4 anyway. They also make a lot of assumptions. there will be two feet of snow on the roof along with an inch of ice at some time or other. Some of the connectors will not hold as well as they should. There might be a roof leak and some rot. Or maybe they would have been acceptable on 32" centers, but they put them on 24" centers anyway. Or maybe some home owner is going to drill into them to hang up his canoe.
This is one of the reasons they developed the Gang Nail truss plates. If the calculations said a 2 x 4 was just barely large enough and you were going to bolt the connections (reduce the strength/cross section) by drilling holes through it, you would have to increase the size to a 2 x 6.
In your case, if you feel you must increase the strength or repair it to what it was before you should glue a piece on both sides. It should be a similar species and probably about a foot long. Say, two pieces of pine 1 x 4. If there is a waxy coating on the existing lumber or other finish that would interfere with the glue, sand it off.
If you want to increase the loading on the loops (vertical) then you might increase the length of the 1 x 4's to something like four feet.
Don't use a 2 x 4 on one side, it unbalanced.
An easy fix. Some 1 x 4, slather on some glue, screw it securely to both sides.
Having said all that, unless you hang hundreds of pounds on the hooks, you probably don't need to do anything.
Sorry. Meant centered on edge dimension of 2x4 through the 3 1/2" width to the center of other edge. Should have waited till the morning to add the picture.
If it is a truss then the bottom cord is under tension, and the tensile strength is reduced in proportion to the wood fiber cut. If you are hanging something like a flower pot, and the beam is compromised by the hole, then that is reduced in proportion to the fibers cut. But in that application you have stress riser effects, also.
About the only case it doesn't mater is a horizontal hole in a joist, as for wiring, so long as the hole is centerred in the joist and not within 20% of the edge.
However the framing for most homes is seriously overdone and many fairly drastic things get done to structure without much happening.
The “fuss” as you put it confronts not only what exists but what I intended to do. In part, the fact that whatever damage that was done years ago, while not catastrophic, may have been further compromised by the passage of time is important to me. – If it can be prevented, I do not want to replace a truss. Another part of the “fuss” is that I would like to store lumber, summer lawn and garden, and fencing above in the web of the trusses. That adds mass. Finally, before getting the information provided by the folks above I had new planned use for the existing, and possibly installation of additional, bolted rings. If I’m approaching weight and stress limits with what already exists I believe that that would be useful information to have.
OK, Gary, now I understand, but a better explanation at the beginning of your first message of what you had been thinking would have probably brought better responses from all. Please excuse my "fussing" message.
Gary, I did not mean to be critical, but to give you a good answer, I need a good question.
Tom above is correct. Most construction framing is seriously over done and redundant.
I have seen seriously damaged trusses that had been damaged for a long time and had not done any apparent damage to the house. I've seen at least a hundred houses where they completely cut the bottom chord of the truss to install a set of pull down stairs. In most cases, they did nothing to compensate for cutting the truss. I've seen a bunch where they cut out two or three web members to make room for an air handler. The worst one I saw, they thought the web members ruined their attic for storage, so they cut them ALL out. The house looked like a pagoda.
I have also seen seriously over loaded trusses. One fellow had four car engines and more auto parts than you could haul in a pickup stored above his garage.
So, there a lot of room for error. That does not mean you should make an error on purpose. It would be smart to reinforce or beef up the structure if you are going to seriously increase the load.
If you go back to the engineers that designed these trusses to start with they will tell you not to modify the trusses or to overload them. That's really all they can say. They do not want to increase their liability.
If you go to a different Engineer, they will be reluctant to tell you anything without getting a clear understanding of what you want to do and then charging you a fee for their service. Once they give you advice and a set of drawings, they are accepting the liability, and they have insurance they have to pay for, let alone their time and expertise.
Barry, that one is hilarious - or it would be if it weren't for the somewhat tragic ignorance!
One thing about truss roof's, trusses are very predictable and you can probably get an engineer to design modifications to suit your needs - though that would obviously be expensive.
When ordering trusses, the manufacturer will generally figure in whatever your needs are, so long as those needs can be clearly articulated in dimensions and loads.
My understanding is that most of it is done by computer software in any case, so it's relatively little trouble as long as the changes are something that the software can work into a structure. Adding the proper overbuild for attic storage is something they do routinely I bet. Considering this, I bet Gary could get engineering at a price for whatever his needs may be.