Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Chair question?

Posts

Chair question?

#1

Chair question?

Barry Irby

Why do we make chairs with thin legs and rungs as cross braces? It does not seem to make sense form and engineering point of view. It seems the braces should be at more of an angle, creating triangles. The way they are now, much of the strength comes from the resistance of the rungs to bending at the joints. I have not phrased the question well and I am hoping you get my drift.

Re: Chair question?

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Chair question? *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm not sure if this will answer your question but near the end of this video Michael Dunbar explains the reasoning behind the construction of a windsor chair.---Jack


Michael Dunbar and Woodcraft

Re: Chair question?

#3

Re: Chair question?

Sgian Dubh

Barry, it’s not surprising that through abuse, glue degradation over time and other factors, the side rail to back leg joints of old and antique chairs exhibit more failure than other joints in the framework. The narrower the side rail the greater the stresses the rail and joint have to withstand. A wider rail increases the ability of both the rail and the joint to resist stress. A wider rail may be an aesthetically unacceptable feature of the design and an alternative to a wider rail is to add a stretcher or two below. This construction mimics the effect of a wider rail as it too increases the mass of the joinery, but this form of structure also adds strength because it triangulates the frame across the diagonals of the enclosed rectangle. These strategies spread the load between all the structural parts affected by applied loads, and there are design opportunities through including stretchers that may benefit the overall appearance. Slainte.

Re: Chair question?

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

In part...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...because it's "good enough", and more wood = more weight. Most people don't like heavy furniture, in my experience. I prefer heavy and over-engineered, myself.

The way the legs are typically braced now also allow for some symmetry with turned braces and a place to rest your feet on the front brace. If the braces were in an 'x' shape between the legs, it would be much more difficult for them to be turned and still symmetrical.

Jason

Re: Chair question?

#5

Re: Chair question?

TomD

"Why do we make chairs with thin legs and rungs as cross braces?"

Almost everything we do with furniture is based on tradition, not on engineering principles. If you look at one of those 500 chair books, there are many modernist chairs that use other design principles, or materials, and from a purely engineering point of view, and indeed others, might be superior, but tradition prevails. One modest issue with modern stuff is patent protection. While I doubt that is really the main issue, improvements in design are occasionally protected by pattens (or more likely trademarked), though some of the most likely to be violated brands are reputed uncomfortable, not to mention other reasons this is probably not the main issue.

"It does not seem to make sense form and engineering point of view. It seems the braces should be at more of an angle, creating triangles."

Of course engineering is a relatively recent innovation, and some cultures either didn't know or use the triangular brace (Japanese). I think there is something to the idea it is not harmonious. That said there are triangularly braced chairs some Windsor back supports, and to some extent the windsor back form itself is front to back triangulated. There are many chairs that use little brackets. And there are other implementations of the joint that use diagonal bracing, like gates and hay rakes.

One issue is getting the joinery at extreme angles to be strong, without being heavy or ugly.

"The way they are now, much of the strength comes from the resistance of the rungs to bending at the joints. I have not phrased the question well and I am hoping you get my drift."

Of course this is a simple construction, and it makes for a space saving chair. Other products like ladders and fencing, and tools can be made with the same joint. I think when best engineered it shares the load throughout the structure, if you are going to make small parts that can almost be broken by stomping on them, it may be better to assemble them in a flexible structure.

And then you can rest you feet on them, and little hands/fingers don't get pinched or anulated in them.

Re: Chair question?

#6

Re: Chair question?

Barry Irby

In thinking about this it occurs to me that you are right about tradition and the design must be good enough to have survived long enough to become a tradition.

Light weight and minimal use of materials is probably another factor.

I wonder if the slight flexibility of the system is not a factor. Is a slightly flexible one some how more comfortable that a really solid one?

Re: Chair question?

#7

Re: Chair question?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Think about this chair, Barry....the Roorkee chair built by an Indian woodworker for the English troops in India which could be dismantled and transported easily. You can buy a set of plans from Christopher Schwarz for $24.99(download) and $29.99 for the book.

Look on www.shopwoodworking.com/build-a-campaign-chair-download.com

Re: Chair question?

#8

Re: Comfort

TomD

Mike Dunbar has said that the flexibility of the structure on Windsors is partly for, or contributory to comfort. I don't really find it that way, it isn't soft, it is resilient, so when just sitting against it, it digs in as much as it can. Then when one shifts it gives way, and one looses energy into the effort of repositioning. It seems the worst of both worlds compared to a soft couch that yields and supports, yet has some part one can haul oneself out on. But to each their own. I think your position is fully supported in the "literature".

One thing I remember from childhood, though I am only 55, is the degree to which in the past they didn't care a jot whether things were comfortable or not. Indoor heating was bad for you; starched collars were good; don't complain about the wool itch; horsehair chairs, showed devotion; and to this day my mother sits forward on the hard edge of the chair with her back ramrod straight. I think it is common to attach current preoccupations to earlier times whether they belong or not. Of course today comfort may be part of the reason certain designs are preferred.