OK, let's try a couple things
Tim Greif - West of Chicago
First off, let's understand what the GFCI is supposed to do. As others stated, it simply compares the current flowing out on the hot wire to the current returning on the common wire. If there's a difference of over 5 milliamps, it trips under the assumption that the missing current may be flowing through YOU. You can demonstrate this by plugging a test light into the hot side of the outlet and touching the common leg of the light to the box screw terminal. This should trip the GFCI if using an incandescent light. It will NOT trip if using a neon light since the current flow through the neon light is way below 5 milliamps. You might be able to detect 5 milliamps as a tingle, but it generally takes in the neighborhood of 250 milliamps to electrocute a normal human. Keep in mind, this is only a quarter of an amp.
Out of the box, a GFCI is normally in a "tripped" condition. Meaning it will not conduct if wired properly until you reset it. The little indicator light (on most) illuminates when there is power on the load terminals and the outlet socket terminals. Wired correctly, the light will glow when the GFCI reset button is released. When you push the reset button in, the light goes out until you release it, actually performing another test.
If you wire it up backwards (incoming line wires connected to the load terminals on the GFCI), the indicator light will always be on. The outlet will power anything plugged into it. Try that first on one of the replacements. If wiring it backwards doesn't let the compressor or anything else work plugged into it, you have a problem with the wiring coming into the box. Incidentally, wiring the GFCI backwards is not inherently dangerous, it just defeats the purpose of the GFCI, turning it into a normal outlet receptacle.
If the compressor works with the GFCI wired backwards, and will not power anything when wired correctly and reset, then I'm pretty sure it's a faulty GFCI. If you wire it backwards and indicator light does not illuminate, you either have a problem with the wiring coming into the box or you have a completely toasted GFCI.
If you're not comfortable doing any of this, then don't. But find someone who is. You may well have an electrical issue that needs attention.
Let us know how this turns out.