Well it's crunch time, Woodcraft is having their 15% off Jet sale and I have to decide between the JWP-15HH palner and the JJP-12HH combo jointer/planer to replace my aged Delta 12.5" lunchbox planer. I already have an 8" jointer but keep going around and around in my head on whether I should spring for the combo machine to get the 12" jointer capacity? I have concerns on the low height of the planer on the combo machine, not sure if it's a justified concern...
I'd say about 1/4 of my lumber comes in >8" (just bought 250bf of poplar and more than 1/2 of it is >8"). Up until now I've been ripping the wider boards with a circular saw (or my ts if the edges are reasonably straight) and just pushing the pain of ruining a wide board down into the pit of my stomach 8-)
I am a fan of combo machines, and love the 12" capacity. I have a Minimax. All the cranking to drop the planer bed to flop over the dust chute is an annoyance, but I do all my planing at the start of the project. So, a one time deal per project. I vote combo.
i too have an 8in jointer...would love a wider one...if you like the jointer, keep it and get a nice planer...or if room doesn't allow then the combo may be your choice.
I like the long infeed and outfeed tables on my 8" jointer. A combo won't have that. Since you already have an eight inch jointer, maybe adding a new planer is in order.
Whenever I have stock wider than my jointer handles, I usually rip it and put it back together later. Done right it's hard to tell.
My personal preference is to have individual machines. I don't like the idea of breaking down a setup to do a second task. I guess I am too disorganized to do everything right the first time, many times I have disliked the grain color or match and prepared a second board for the project. I have an 8" Grizzly Joiner with segmented spiral head and a 20" stationary planer with Byrd head.
I know many have dislike of Grizzly equipment for some reasons, but I have had very good experience and service with mine. I had a 6" joiner for many years, my current 8" joiner, my 3HP cyclone dust collector were/are Grizzly. I also own other brands like my Delta Unisaw, Minmax mm16 band saw, Powermatic lathe and Drill press etc, the Grizzly equipment does a very good job especially considering the price.
I would keep your 8" joiner and purchase a 20" stationary planer. The extra width is great for planing glued up panels and exceptionally wide boards. You can make a sled to carry real wide boards through the planer - skipping the joiner face flattening operation.