Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

How to saw walnut boards

Posts

How to saw walnut boards

#1

How to saw walnut boards

Yonak

A friend of mine has 11 walnut logs varying from 18" d. to 30" d. and has asked me for advice. As I don't have the proper knowledge base, I'm asking the brain trust.

Is it worthwhile to have walnut quarter sawn or should he go for a better yield ? I'm sure he doesn't have specific purposes for this lumber and is cutting it for general use.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#2

Re: How to saw walnut boards

Barry Irby

This will be interesting to watch.

I had about 5000BF sawed tree run. My assumption was that there would be enough of every description to cover what I wanted. (Gross and sloppy, right?)

I personally think quarter sawn walnut is rather plain, pardon the pun.

I had some white oak quarter sawn. The sawyer cut it into pieces that were something like eight inches this and then flipped the pieces to get as much quartered grain as he could. He was working with a band mill. I got a good yield of quartered and rift sawn. It started as a 42" diameter log.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#3

recommendations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

By now it should be apparent that I hang around saw mills. Here is what I would suggest, but first some information.

That could be a lot of lumber to do something with and half to all of it will be #2 common and worse. Does anyone have a use for hundreds of bdft of #2 common lumber? Consider selling some or all of the logs. If there is little interest in the logs it will indicate what kind of lumber they will yield. The walnut market has been strong and I have seen some amazingly poor logs bought. Or sell the logs and buy back some or all of the upper grades.

1. Unless someone has a pressing need for rift or quartered lumber don't consider sawing this way. For what it is worth, of the several thousand bdft of walnut logs I have had sawed I never attempted any quartered lumber and only in one special case did I saw to get rift cut lumber. I don't know why quartered walnut makes any sense anyway.

2. If the logs are to be sawed by someone that saws graded lumber for sale into the market let them saw it as they would their own logs for best yield of higher grade lumber, unless.....someone is into natural edges and other artsy lumber slabs. In that case ignore any advice I offer and you need an artist for advice. If the mill does not saw for the market find a mill that does otherwise it is the blind leading the blind on how to saw. (you might read my Article in the Article s section on "Where hardwood lumber comes from" to lean a bit about sawing strategy at a commercial mill).

3. Don't saw it all 4/4 and saw the 4/4 to market standards- 1 1/8". In many cases the lumber will then yield 7/8" dressed which is ideal for a lot of furniture. Saw some 5/4 and some 8/4 according to anticipated needs, maybe even thicker depending on needs.

4. Does anyone know about drying lumber? A few thousand dollars worth of walnut is a poor place to learn.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#4

I'll agree with Bill, except

Keith Newton

If these trees are still standing, I wouldn't cut the smaller trees. I personally don't care for the big contrast between sap and heartwood, so only want lumber with good clear heartwood.

Since an 18" tree will have at least 2.5" of bark and a sapwood all way around, it is down to 15", I'm assuming at the butt. That is down to 13",less another 3" boxing the heart, which only leaves 6" of good wood out from there, and even less at the small end.

I think Walnut needs to be at least 24" D to start getting good.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#5

The economic realities of trunk diameter

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Note: Logs are measured from the small end for it will be the small end that determines what you can get out of the log.

Veneer log buyers will pay veneer log prices for a clear log 14" in diameter on the small end. "Clear" to an experienced buyer means there are no healed knots below the bark surface as determined from bark pattern irregularities or lumps in the surface. Veneer logs fetch a large premium to saw logs. If you have a veneer log it is worth considering selling the log and buying lumber with the profit.

A deep woods walnut tree, meaning it shed its lower limbs early in life, will have clear lumber nearly to the center of the log. And it will have minimal sapwood because it is growing slowly. I would not hesitate to saw a 14" log from this environment. 12" logs will be bought by log buyers and selling them is a reasonable thing to do with small logs. Commercial lumber is steamed so these buyers don't care about how much sap wood will be in the lumber.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#6

Re: recommendations

TomD

I agree with most of what Bill said, with a few exception:

- #2 common was what Maloof ordered, I believe, at least at the time he wrote his first book (and that was presumably some kind of California walnut {they have stuff from all over the world} so it would be different to boot). But the principle is the same. And that is that by the million bft where you are taking stuff like flooring, the junk wood is not appreciated, but it is exactly the stuff you can find your pieces for studio quality work. You need character, you need grain that runs in odd directions to mirror parts and so forth. There will be waste. So commercially mark what Bill said, but for high end furniture it is not the same issue. You get a lot of dead straight walnut, you have a lot of boring wood.

- You need a fair amount of quartered wood to make real furniture. Though depending on how you saw the wood, it can come from flat sawn wood. So you need a quartered 1x2s to get your frame stock out of, or you need to saw some 8/4s and rip it off the edge of the board. If your pal flat sawed the whole mess there is plenty of quarterd yield from the heart slices, but you need to keep your share of that stuff for cabinet uses. There is a fair amount of cabinet wood that needs quartered stock, but you can find it without quarter sawing. I have no idea who has the gear to quarter a 36 inch log, while I nearly have the gear to flat saw it. Also keep in mind that quartered wood will all comeout half or less the width of flat sawn, and part of the appeal of these large logs is the width of the boards. You will take a hit of the bft rate if you make them smaller. Though selling really large boards is harder, in general.

- If you are sawing for yourself, saw it mostly 6/4s 8/4, and some even larger. I am sure Bill knows the commercial world, but you have much better luck air drying bigger stuff, and you will have much more versatility if you leave it large. Plus it is sorta less work. You have no idea how many stickers you would need to cut to lay up 4/4, with larger stuff you will have greater stiffness, therefore far fewer stickers, and to boot you have many fewer boards. They will be heavy though, but I can't help you there. The wood does slide around easily when it is wet and dusty.

So the main issue is cash or craftsmanship. If your friend just wants to convert to cash, then read what Bill wrote very carefully. If you want to keep some or all of it for local woodworking clubs, your own high end stuff, then the cut is different, and you need to think of what goes into a piece of furniture. There is often one or two pieces that are really large, like a carved apron, and nothing feels more ridiculous than doing custom sawing only to find you have all the stuff they sell at home depot, and none of the wood that you need for real woodworking projects. Just recently I scored some heavy maple, perfect for the next bench legs I make, you can't get that out of 4/4s. But equally if our 16x4 inch salad bowl blows after 20 years, I can cut a new one out of it, or if I want a jointer plane. And along the way, I made one cut for the 4 the 4/4s would require. I sealed the ends, and there is no visible checking.

If you want to saw out a few full width pieces for, say a church alter, live edge, then you might find a local guy with a chain saw.

I have no idea about liability. When I do this stuff I treat it as an adventure and if it kills/maims me I figure it might have been some other thing I like to do. But when bringing in people, one would need to know where one stood, because these logs are dangerous in a lot of different ways.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#7

Another view from someone that makes stuff

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One of the grand features of the WoodCentral Gallery is that if offers an opportunity to illustrate text claims with pictures of stuff made. Everything you see made in my Gallery was made with the top grade of lumber sawed at mills supplying the commercial market. This is the same lumber you can expect if one keeps the top grade of lumber professionally sawed from logs, presuming the logs are of sufficient quality to saw the top grade of lumber. You can come to your individual conclusions about whether appropriate lumber was chosen for the projects illustrated or whether some knots and sap would have spiced things up a bit.

I invite Tom to put up pictures of his furniture made with the lumber he suggests should be produced from these logs.

We sold lumber for about 30 years, including a lot of walnut and cherry. With one exception, we had no market for anything less than the top grade of lumber. Less experienced woodworkers don't know how to work the lower grades and experienced woodworkers for the most part don't want to bother dealing with the waste and cutting decisions. Disclaimer: we had no studio furniture customers. (there aren't many) In one case we had access for a short time to cheap #2 common walnut. We priced it cheap and sold many 500 bdft packs of it to people looking for a bargain, who by in large didn't know much about woodworking but had dreams. I expect most of it is still stored away in barns somewhere.

That said, there is a studio furniture trend that is all about figure and knots and natural edges. I call it art, not traditional woodworking. This market uses a tiny amount of hand selected lumber, often sawed to their specifications. Good luck turning a few thousand bdft of logs into product you can sell to them, or use oneself for this kind of furniture.

But Tom does make a valid point. Saw the lumber for the market you have in hand. That market must be large enough to buy the quantity of logs involved. If one doesn't know the market, then play the odds and saw for best grade, mostly 4/4.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#8

Re: recommendations

gary peterson

tomD said it...you do need rift sawn for furniture...rails and stiles...

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#9

Re: How to saw walnut boards

don stephan

Some people like flat sawn cathedrals and arches, some like quartered/rift straight lines. Personal preference to some extent, but sometimes suggested by design style. For example, rift and quartered might not look as appropriate for rustic furniture, while arches and cathedrals may be completing visually for a piece with lots of dovetails and curves. Pursue what you like for your lumber.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#10

Re: How to saw walnut boards

Yonak

Thanks, all, for your responses. I have forwarded them to my friend and he'll have to decide what to do. There were some great points made.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#11

Re: recommendations

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Hi, Bill, I thoroughly enjoy your articles and suggestions to us guys on good woodworking, finishes, etc.

You say you "hang around sawmills" right....well I just saw a home made double saw blade machine run by a Datsun motor and the guy is cutting anything from a 1x2 up to 2x10, and maybe a 4x4 if he wanted to with the machine.

you can watch him on YouTube cut down a tree and then saw up the log into boards.

Re: How to saw walnut boards

#12

Re: recommendations

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Many years ago, (early 60's) a good friend and I remodeled his garage into a family room, installing a wood floor above the concrete, level with the rest of his home. His father had a homemade circular saw mill set up on an old (around 1940) Oldsmobile chassis. The floor joists we used were 2X10 white oak sawed on that saw and air cured. He actually drove the saw from the drive shaft, and could shift gears to change speeds! I never saw the unit in operation, but the 2X10s were quite well sawed.