Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Posts

OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#1

OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Joe Pack

3 year old Gerber toilet worked fine...would almost suck you down when flushed. 5 days ago I flushed and the toilet almost overflowed. I let it slowly drain down and flushed again, with the same result. So, out comes the plunger and I plunge/flush several times, still essentially clogged, but would slowly drain down to normal. After 10 minutes, I walked away, figuring I'll go find my drain snake and go to work after dinner.

One last time before going out for the drain snake, I flushed again...and the toilet worked just like normal. I flushed several times, and each time the toilet worked just like it always did. Figuring something inhumanly large had finally dissolved and passed, I walked away glad that I didn't have to do anything.

3 nights ago, the gremlin came back. After my 3 a.m. "old man's wake up call," I flushed and everything worked as usual. 4 hours later, though, the toilet gremlin struck...the water simply filled the bowl and swirled, very slowly going down. Since then, the toilet will not flush properly. The tank will empty, the bowl will fill and the water will slowly go down. But now the water in the bowl goes almost all the way down instead of the 3-4 inches normally in the bowl.

Laws of physics say that the water level standing in the bowl should be equal to the water level in the built-in S trap in the toilet, but mine is a good 3" below where it was before the problem. It seems that the water level in the bowl continues to go down long after the flush has been completed, almost completely draining the bowl.

The tank fills properly. The bowl fill spout is working properly. In other words, the "innards" of the toilet are fine.

For what it's worth, there are three toilets on this line. If you visualize a line of three toilets, the ones on either end of the line work just fine. It is the one in the middle that has the problem. What gets me is that the toilet worked fine, then would not flush, then worked fine for a couple of days more, then again will not flush. A clue, I think, is that the water in the bowl of the problematic toilet seems to be siphoning down on it's own...no evident cause for this to happen.

I imagine I will probably have to remove the toilet to get to the problem, but I'm hoping some of the self-professed toilet gurus here might have a thought...or magic spell...to help before I go this route. All ideas and smart-ass comments are more than welcome...I could use the help and/or the laughs!

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#2

Beats the crap outa me!   


Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#3

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Joe...I am a retired plumber....my wife had a suggestion when our line backed up onto the patio....she said she had bought the single sheet toilet paper and that might have been the problem with the backup.

I put my garden hose down the drain opening and flushed it for many minutes to clear any blockage in the drain sewer line. We went back to using the double sheet and maybe tripple sheet paper and things are fine now. Just a suggestion....

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#4

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

If you have a septic tank the tank could be full or there is an accumulation of stuff in front of the inlet baffle in the tank.

If you are on a city sewer system, there could be issues with the nearest pumping station that handles your house.

Since you are in a northern climate and it gets cold, the vent pipe could be clogged with ice/snow or an animal.

Lee

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#5

More Data?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1st floor, 2nd floor, sewer, septic?

If septic, time from last pump-out?

Caps on roof vents?

Overhanging trees?

Issues with other drains on same vent line?

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#6

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Barry Irby

I am assuming your three toilets are "left", "right" and "center" and the center one is giving you the problem.

This is a guess, but I am betting there is a partial, nearly complete blockage in the center line, either before where the others join in or perhaps afterward. I am thinking the water fills the pipe back to the center toilet and it slowly drains away. If the other two are far enough away that their water is stored in the pipe without affecting them until it two drains away or if their section of pipe is not blocked, they just drain properly.

The location of the blockage will dictate the length of the snake you need.

You might be able to blow it out with one of the rubber stoppers that fit on a hose and allow you to put it down the pipe and when the water is turned on, it expands and seals the pipe in your direction and flows water into the sewer to push the clog out. (Lowe's has them) If you try this, be careful because its easy to blow water up through other toilets or fixtures. Have people stand guard at all the other fixtures and start with the water going slowly.

I have not done this inside the house, but have used one to blow out the main sewer by putting it down the clean out in the yard. That way the fixtures in the house were not affected.

One you get the plug moving, no matter how you do it, run copious amounts of water down the drain to flush it thoroughly and into the main sewer.

If you live in a house on a crawl space, you should had cleanouts in the crawl space that give you access for the snake and you may not have to remove the toilet. there may be some inside the house as well.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#7

Re: More Data?

Joe Pack

Clogged toilet is on the 1st floor, approximately 15 feet from the other 1st floor toilet. A third toilet is on the 2nd floor

Septic pump out 2 1/2 years ago when we bought the house - essentially no effluent even prior to pump out; only 2 adults in our house.

No caps on roof vents

Yes to overhanging trees.

No to other drain problems on this vent...MB toilet, shower, wash basin; kitchen sink; dishwasher.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#8

Re: Beats the crap outa me! 

Joe Pack

I'm hoping that's all there is in it!!! :-)

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#9

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

John in NM

All I can figure is that there is a partial blockage below the toilet that had the initial problem but not as far down as to cause problems for the next in line. Probably the same mass that caused your initial clog. Perhaps the reason it seems intermitent is due to what gets flushed each time and the frequency of flushes. Mostly water and the problem takes time to occur. More solids and the problem shows up again faster.

The sure thing is to snake it, hopefully you have some sensible clean outs just for this purpose.

Another thing to try is some hot water down the drain. Shut off the water to the toilet, flush it to clear most of the water, and dump a bucket full of hot, hot water down. Do this a couple times and it should clear things up if the problem is caused by the usual soap scum, hair, and stuff that lives in most drains. If the problem is a root, you'll have to snake it instead.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#10

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

don stephan

Perhaps the water level drops in the bowl because a vacuum is forming in the drain line, pulling additional water through the S trap.

If you have a cleanout in the horizontal run under your basement floor, you could open it, then have someone else flush first one of the working toilets, then the other, and finally the uncooperative one, and compare the flows past the cleanout.

And if there is a tub or shower on the same branch as the uncooperative toilet, run a bolus of water from that and observe the flow past the cleanout.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#11

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

John McGaw

Just a guess but could you have venting problems? Has it been especially cold where you are? I've seen ice build up on rooftop plumbing vents in Alaska when moisture rising up froze when it hit the -20 air.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#12

Would Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

be the first time in bitter-cold weather than a squirrel went down a vent stack looking for warmth and wound up dead in the drain.

Try a double flush and running water in the toilet and sink/tub "upstream" from the problem unit, and watch to see if the level in "next" bowl rises. If you get a rise, the clog will be down-stream from the problem fixture. If not, then your clog is likely in the shorter lead to the main and a closet auger may solve your issue. While not a good idea, some builders (depending on local code and enforcement) have used 3" pipe for closet leaders to save a few bucks. They are prone to clogs.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#13

Maybe you have a part backwards?

Dick Coers

You wrote "If you have a cleanout in the horizontal run under your basement floor, you could open it, then have someone else flush first one of the working toilets, then the other, and finally the uncooperative one, and compare the flows past the clean out."

For that procedure, I would flush the toilet and let "someone" else watch the flow. Not a good friend either! LOL

I get on the phone to Rotor Rooter pretty quickly for these deals. Running snakes and such through my own waste is not something I prefer as a DIY. Maybe I scooped too much hog poop as a kid, but often I think they don't make a glove thick enough to separate me from the solids and that black goo in the sewer line!

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#14

But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You like honey and the bees absolutely LOVE "it" :D

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#15

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

Keith Newton

I was thinking it may be ice related too. But I was wondering if the drain line might be exposed enough somewhere before the first vent causing a constriction point. That would allow the tube to fill, then siphon the bowl.

Wondering if Joe is somewhere that gets extremely cold?

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#16

Extremely Cold

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

and that would be most everywhere north of Atlanta today

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#17

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

joe mohnike

just had the exact same problem, in frustration I replaced the toilet. I took the old one outside and started breaking it up I wanted to know what the problem was. A small bottle (travel size) was stuck in the trap section would not go down. It would toggle back and forth, one way a block and slow the drain down, the other way it would flush with no problems. After a week of plungers, snakes etc. I replaced it. Glad I did the new one uses much less water, the tank fills faster and is a lot quieter.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#18

Children or Grandchildren

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

By any chance have you had young children or grand children in the house just prior to the first instance of the problem? Someone I know had electronic tooth brushes and one of their kids dropped the brush part down the drain. They suffered from intermittent clogs right up until they pulled the toilet and found the brush jammed in the S trap built into the toilet. Paper products would build up and clog, plunging would clear it until the next build up occurred.

Lee

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#19

very similar story, my favorite really

Dick Coers

Our 3 year old son is on the toilet. He yells to my wife that he has dropped his apple in the toilet. She yells back to flush it. I get home and the toilet is plugged. I try everything, finally pull the toilet. There is a bright red apple, with one little bite missing, stuck in the toilet just above the floor flange. No more food in the bathroom, as if there should have been in the first place! The boy is going to be 35 this year, I've told the story often!

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#20

Re: very similar story, my favorite really

Barry Irby

When I was building, a recent client called and complained the toilet was stopped up. I sent the Plumber and actually met him there. Mother and daughter watched as the Plumber fished and fished. Finally he snagged whatever it was a carefully pulled it up out of the depths. A doll baby with a head about the size of a softball. In shock, we ALL looked at the little girl. She said "It Dolly and I flushed her!" The Plumber was stunned and spluttered, "I can't believe it went through the toilet". She said "I pushed Her!" and made a twisting motion with her arm.

We should be very careful not to tick off this kid.

Re: OT - Calling All Clogged Toilet Gurus

#21

Re: very similar story, my favorite really

Mark Nowicki

I manage my mom's rentals, and have to deal with tenants, who, despite being adults, sometimes are as intelligent as 3 year olds.

Once, my plumber snaked out a fork; apparently the W/C also served as a food disposer.

They were very unhappy when they had to pay the plumbers' fee.

Mark