Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

Posts

Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#1

Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

William Duffield

Monday morning, a friend arrived after a 2-1/4 hour drive and several dollars in tolls with a board of clear, straight grained, quarter sawn 8/4 x 8" x 10' Douglas Fir, Pseudotsuga menziesii.

Our plan was to saw three spars out of it for vintage dinghies, rip each in two, route grooves for a sail slot, glue the halves back together, dress all the faces and round off the corners, and whatever else we could get done.

Final spar cross section would look kind of like the drawing at the end of the post.

The board looked beautiful, and I anticipated making very good progress towards our goal, in spite of the worsening weather. Since 9 foot booms are a little difficult to maneuver in my shop, I got out the Festool track saw and rails, saw horses and the setup for breaking down plywood in front of the shop. It was for jobs like this that I had chosen the TS75 over the smaller but more maneuverable TS55.

We put the setup on the horses, the Doug Fir plank on the setup, bolted two rails together, laid them on top of the plank, put the saw on the rail and with one cut, faced one edge of the plank. The second cut, to separate the first spar from the plank, didn't go so well. Less than a foot into the rip, I turned off the saw because the kerf was closing up and about to stop it anyway.

At this point, we went to Plan B, which required shuffling lots of machinery, projects and wood around in the shop so we could get 10' in front of and behind the cabinet saw, jointer, planer and eventually router table. The first step was to separate the first spar from the remainder of the plank. Oak wedges and a hammer were necessary to keep from stalling the industrial SawStop. The last eight inches of the rip just popped apart. Using the jointer to remove the new curves that showed up was a challenge, but we eventually, with more wedging, ripped the spar in two.

First cut: tangential



Putting the ends of the spars together, there's a 3/4" gap at the center of 10'.

Second cut: radial



Putting the halves together, there is a 1" gap in the center. Showing all of the new curves in the surfaces is not possible with the camera I have.

It appears to me that they made a serious mistake with their kiln schedule.

We're going to have to wait a while to see if any of these stresses relax enough that we can cut the groove for the sail and glue it back together. The cup, warp and twist that showed up in the rest of the plank are going to make it difficult to get one more straight spar out of it, much less two.

If it were a reasonable distance, not a 4-1/2 hour drive and more than $20 in tolls, I would have been back to the supplier immediately, demanding a refund or replacement, but it wasn't my board, and not my spars.


img

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#2

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I don't know what size groove you need, but it might be possible to cut the groove after the two pieces are glued up. Take a look at this bit. There are other sizes available.

Lee

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#3

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

TomD

I don't fully understand your problem here, but at a glance, I don't see much problem gluing the boards back together with that small gap in them. I doubt the wood will straighten it is probably some internal stress or reaction wood. You could put a small piece of paper at the outboard ends to preserve a minimum amount of glue space. Use an epoxy filler blend that is not easily blown out.

Another option is to flip one piece and glue so the piece takes the curve, but if I get it correctly that would be a port-starboard curve. But if the curve could be aligned with the CL you could have a pretty curve to the spar. That would require having your luff cut to take the new shape. But either the sails don't currently exist, or you would ideally want to fit them to the spar bend anyway.

A third option is to rip it into whatever thickness slices, and just laminate it. Then you can finish it with epoxy and not worry too much about wood movement, while the current pieces look as though they may violate the 3/4 inch rule. But as you say, you would have less spar yield.

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#4

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

Keith Newton

I didn't see where you said whether this was a Mast, or Boom, and if there would be any tapper. I suppose these parts fold over like closing a book, rather than gluing back like they are laying, where the bends would be working against one another. That would bring them back straight. Otherwise, that half inch in each doesn't seem too bad if there was going to be any tapper, you could work that out doing that.

If this is a mast, there is a lot of bending that can be done with rig tensioning, depending on where the shrouds attach. Back when I was racing sailboats, we would tune the rig before each race. We would pre-bend the mast to flatten the main on high wind days, and loosen it on light air days to make the sails fuller.

And on the Boom of course, you can get some shape control with vang, sheet / traveler, and outhaul. If it is a boom, where does the mainsheet tackle attach? If it isn't out on the end, I think you might be better off with a little pre-bend, that the sheet tension pulls out. I'll bet you can easily close that gap by squeezing with one hand. If you can, that is exactly how much pressure would be needed by the sheet tension to straighten is, if it was somewhere toward the middle.

I would suspect those wooden spars are pretty bendy, and bending is just part of what great sailors do to make their boats fast under whatever conditions arise.

But, if you are getting a new set of sails cut for the boat, I would talk to the sail-maker to see what they suggest. However, if you are not planning to race this boat, just don't worry about this. Most people just out for a daysail do so poorly at knowing how to pull all the strings that make for good sail shape, that this small amount is nothing to worry about.

Otherwise, my only other suggestion, is to straighten the side with the bolt-rope, glue it together, then plane the other side straight, then glue on a third piece with the glue line perpendicular to the first, to get right on the money.

Just wondering what design this boat is, and would like to see some pics when your done.

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

Jesper, Denmark

Bill,

It should not be a big problem gluing a 10 foot board with a 1" gap. Use Weldwood glue, not epoxy. Reason: UV resistance.

More concerning is that the spar section seems much too heavy, irrespective of whether a boom or mast. Typically, these would be hollow section. Assuming these are existing dinghies, check to see how the original ones were made.

I built a sailing dinghy many years ago. The 19 foot mast is glued-up from 4 boards, with shallow rabbets in the port and starboard boards. Tapered and rounded, using the 4-8-16-32 edge plus final sanding method. No bolt rope slide, but stainless hoops around the mast made from thick wire.

The 9 foot boom was a birds mouth construction, tapered in both ends and weighing about a pound finished.

Material is spruce, from selected 2 x 4 and 2 x 6's at a local lumber yard, scarfed together as necessary.

After preparing the stock on table aw and planer, glue-up and finish planing is done on a spar bench or carefully lined-up sawhorses. Hand planing is neither hard or difficult. Finishing with a belt sander belt turned inside out and driven by a roller on a hand drill.

I suggest having the owner go back to square one and check the design - either with the old spars or with the design if new.

I can take some pics of my spars and the finish sander if you need.

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

#6

Re: Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?

TomD

UV is no problem inside glue joints. Epoxy is almost universal in serious wooden boats these, days, though in a spar, given the fact that it is nicely joined, you can use a range of glues like the mentioned weldwood plastic resin cement. Epoxy has the added benefit of limiting moisture in the part (which requires a comprehensive approach, and not requiring much clamping.

One thing that is sometimes done is rather than having a milled bolt rope groove, bonding in a PVC tube. You then rout it open. When epoxied in, it becomes a permanent feature which then eliminates concerns over wear and maintenance in the bolt rope track. You can then wrap the whole spar in glass, paint, the spar, or paint only the top of the spar, and it should be pretty much maintenance free and even storable out of doors.

To get a good bond on PVC with epoxy, you either haze it with a flame, or prime it with PVC primer.

Of course if this is just a fun boat, there is a lot to be said for skipping the whole bolt rope thing and using Bolger ties. They do pretty well on air flow, and the whole thing is easy to use and looks very ye olde nautical. Some interesting options using Amsteel and fancy splices.