Hidden Defect - What Would You Do?
William Duffield
Monday morning, a friend arrived after a 2-1/4 hour drive and several dollars in tolls with a board of clear, straight grained, quarter sawn 8/4 x 8" x 10' Douglas Fir, Pseudotsuga menziesii.
Our plan was to saw three spars out of it for vintage dinghies, rip each in two, route grooves for a sail slot, glue the halves back together, dress all the faces and round off the corners, and whatever else we could get done.
Final spar cross section would look kind of like the drawing at the end of the post.
The board looked beautiful, and I anticipated making very good progress towards our goal, in spite of the worsening weather. Since 9 foot booms are a little difficult to maneuver in my shop, I got out the Festool track saw and rails, saw horses and the setup for breaking down plywood in front of the shop. It was for jobs like this that I had chosen the TS75 over the smaller but more maneuverable TS55.
We put the setup on the horses, the Doug Fir plank on the setup, bolted two rails together, laid them on top of the plank, put the saw on the rail and with one cut, faced one edge of the plank. The second cut, to separate the first spar from the plank, didn't go so well. Less than a foot into the rip, I turned off the saw because the kerf was closing up and about to stop it anyway.
At this point, we went to Plan B, which required shuffling lots of machinery, projects and wood around in the shop so we could get 10' in front of and behind the cabinet saw, jointer, planer and eventually router table. The first step was to separate the first spar from the remainder of the plank. Oak wedges and a hammer were necessary to keep from stalling the industrial SawStop. The last eight inches of the rip just popped apart. Using the jointer to remove the new curves that showed up was a challenge, but we eventually, with more wedging, ripped the spar in two.
First cut: tangential


Putting the ends of the spars together, there's a 3/4" gap at the center of 10'.
Second cut: radial


Putting the halves together, there is a 1" gap in the center. Showing all of the new curves in the surfaces is not possible with the camera I have.
It appears to me that they made a serious mistake with their kiln schedule.
We're going to have to wait a while to see if any of these stresses relax enough that we can cut the groove for the sail and glue it back together. The cup, warp and twist that showed up in the rest of the plank are going to make it difficult to get one more straight spar out of it, much less two.
If it were a reasonable distance, not a 4-1/2 hour drive and more than $20 in tolls, I would have been back to the supplier immediately, demanding a refund or replacement, but it wasn't my board, and not my spars.
There are other sizes available.


