Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

cutting board finish

Posts

cutting board finish

#1

cutting board finish

Ryan

I've been asked to make 75 black walnut serving boards (10x10 in) for a local restaurant and am wondering what sort of finish I should use. I've done these in the past and have used a variety of finishes but am not really happy with any of them. Tung oil is the best but it takes a really long time to dry (this is an asap project) and smells ugly for a long time. Mineral oil is a no-go because it doesn't last. Watco, dries fast but also smells. I want something that will hold up reasonably well under tough conditions (this is a restaurant after all) and doesn't smell. Am thinking of General Salad Bowl Finish. Any other suggestions from you experts?

Re: cutting board finish

#2

JL

Re: cutting board finish

JL

There are those who say no oil or any finish. Just let the natural fats and such give you a finish.

I prefer mineral oil. If I need a longer lasting finish, I dissolve food grade paraffin wax in warm mineral oil and apply it warm to a cutting board.

YMMV.

Re: cutting board finish

#3

Re: cutting board finish

Terry in Edmonton

I second the 50/50 paraffin/mineral oil mixture. I like to put the item in a large pan an leave to soak in a 250 oven for 15 to 20 min. Make sure to tell the restaurant not to put the boards into the dish washer and if they do there will be no warranty.

Re: cutting board finish

#4

Re: cutting board finish

Don in Central Illinois

Walnut oil.

Re: cutting board finish

#5

Re: cutting board finish

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Ryan,

I've used the General Finishes Salad Bowl finish, and have been pleased with the result, a durable finish that looks good for a long time, even on a cutting board that gets used.

The other thing to consider is that the GF SBF is labeled by the manufacturer as being " a non-toxic when cured" finish "for any surface that is to come in contact with food."

For 75 cutting boards, to be used on a commercial establishment, that would be a good thing to be able to point to should the question ever come up of what was used to finish the serving boards.

my $.02, (and probably worth less).

Bob in NJ

Re: cutting board finish

#6

+1 for the GFSBF

Ron in Sterling, CT

I agree with the GFSBF for the cutting boards. I have had excellent results with it. It does need refinishing eventually however, and I am not sure how long it would stand up in a commercial environment. I agree wholeheartedly with an earlier post that all claims & warranties are off if run through a dishwasher. My 2 1/2 cents worth. Good Luck.

Ron

Re: cutting board finish

#7

Re: cutting board finish

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Do not use any vegetable or nut oils. They all eventually go rancid and can taint the food you cut on it. Mineral oil does not go bad, but should be renewed periodically. Salad bowl finish is great, but on a cutting board it will get damaged.

Lee

Re: cutting board finish

#8

Re: cutting board finish

DizD

I have settled on Mahoney's Walnut Oil finish - it's labeled utility finish oil. He also makes an oil wax finish, which I have not tried. Available at woodworking specialty stores and online.

One step which I think is beneficial is to wet the boards with water to raise the grain prior to final sanding/finish application.

Re: cutting board finish

#9

Re: cutting board finish

David Yoho

Ryan, this question gets raised here often enough. There are those that like the mineral or vegetable oil with or without some wax option. I say if it works for them, why not use it.

I'm from the school of thought that a film finish like the General Finishes product or Waterlox does a better job. The trick for cutting boards is to only apply enough to soak into the wood and not build a film on top of the wood. I recently completed a 32" x 41" maple butcher block countertop extension for my son for Christmas. Most of the surface was taken up by a large microwave he has but the remaining space would definitely see cutting board activity. I thinned some Waterlox and gave it two coats, being sure to wipe away any excess each time. The result is a finish that cures down in the wood - not on it. There are no shards of finish to chip away and get into the food and the protection lasts much longer than oil does.

Re: cutting board finish

#10

Along those lines...

John in NM

I once experimented a little with putting some wood + linseed oil in a vacuum chamber (oil was too thick and I didn't want to add a thinner). Idea was to fully soak the wood of course. May try it again with some thinner one day.

I'm also thinking of sending a couple cutting boards off with the next (and hopefully last) batch of burl parts to be stabilized. From what I've read on food forums, the foodies react to resin impregnated wood as something even more horrifying than simple plastic, but it seems like a pretty good solution to me.

Re: cutting board finish

#11

Re: cutting board finish

Barry Irby

I would suggest going to Russ's Corner and read until you find his suggestion. IIRC he basically said no one wants or will buy a bowl or cutting board that smells of finish. Everyone is skeptical that anything that smells of finish is ever going to food safe, regardless of the data, or what we tell them. His suggestion was to use either sunflower oil or safflower oil, I can't remember which. (Sorry, that's where the reading part comes in.) The theory is the oil has little or no smell, is food grade and used in salads and cooking, and whatever smell it has smells like something you would eat and no one is allergic to it.

I have done a lot of cutting boards with sunflower oil because that is what they had at the grocery store. No complaints and no one died. Incidentally some people are allergic to walnut oil. You can buy some that has been treated, but why? If they believe they are allergic, they might react anyway. And, The walnut I have and have made cutting boards out of does not smell like anything delicious. Some people are allergic to it.

Re: cutting board finish

#12

Re: cutting board finish

Howard Acheson

>>>> the GF SBF is labeled by the manufacturer as being " a non-toxic when cured" finish

Any and all finishes sold in the US since the mid 1970's are required to be non-toxic when cured. Therefore, any finish could claim that their product would be "safe" to be used in contact with food.

Re: cutting board finish

#13

Re: cutting board finish

Ryan

Thanks for your input everyone. Now I need to decide but I'm leaning towards GSBF rather than oil. These foodies don't have time for oiling boards on a regular basis. And they know about dishwashers!

Re: cutting board finish

#14

Another thought..

Barry Irby

Saw some of the wood that had been thermally treated. It was darkened all the way through. Claims to make it decay resistant. I think some of it was poplar and it was about the color of walnut. It smelled like caramel. It was cheap,and does not solve the finish question, but it might smell better than walnut.

Dishwasher=all bets are off.

Re: cutting board finish

#15

Re: Another thought..

Ryan

I've also seen some of that thermally treated wood - what I saw was maple. Didn't like the colour (the colour of s**t) and you're right, it smells cooked. These guys have the bucks so price of wood isn't a concern, they want high end.

Re: cutting board finish

#16

Coming in late but

Gary Smyth

you state in your subject "Cutting Board Finish" but the restaurant wants 10 x 10 serving boards. Does food actually touch the boards? Some steak houses put their hot plates on a board (Regular size for a restaurant dinner plate is 10") for delivery to a table. So while the boards are subjected to heat, no food purposely touches the serving board. Most answers here address safety and contact with food. Seems to me that board intent might make a difference. I have no dog I this fight but you might like to review their definition of a serving board vs. a cutting board. Maybe there is a difference for the client.

Re: cutting board finish

#17

Re: Coming in late but

mdclor

Gary, you very well may be correct, but we were at a "trendy" place last week and LOML's fish sandwich and my burger were served directly on a glued up slab about 8x12x1 inches. There were some cut marks indicating that other people may have cut steaks or similar. I was not impressed with the restaurant's wooden trenchers complete with cracks and failing glue joints. FWIW

Re: cutting board finish

#18

Hope they had big napkins...

John in NM

Those cracks and joints sound like a recipe for a lapfull of Au jus! :D

Re: cutting board finish

#19

Re: Coming in late but

Ryan

Thanks Gary. The boards are for serving charcuterie (gourmet term for salami and other cured meats). They are going to be solid pieces of wood, I'm not a fan of laminated boards for obvious reasons!