Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Wood choice question?

Posts

Wood choice question?

#1

Wood choice question?

Barry Irby

I want to build a table that will sit in full harsh sun in a south facing full height window. I have several woods I could use. White Oak, walnut, Cherry, Poplar and Gum. (Not sure about the gum, its a spook, came as a surprise, but it smells delicious.)

I know the walnut fades over time and the cherry at least initially darkens. Not sure about the oak. Any of them could be stained.

So, what would you use? And what would you use for stain (dye?) and finish?

Re: Wood choice question?

#2

Clint Searl

Oak or Cherry - No stain - Waterborne floor finish


Re: Wood choice question?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Wood choice question?

Ellis Walentine

I agree with Clint on the oak or cherry recommendation, but the choice to stain or not should be governed by the larger design decision, namely, how will this piece fit into this room. There's no absolutely correct stain color (or method) for any piece of portable furniture, as it may be moved to another location where that color doesn't work as well. Architectural millwork, including paneling, trim, built-ins, even floors and moldings, on the other hand, should be designed and coordinated for that customer and location.

If you do stain, I'd recommend dye stain, and I've had decent luck with General Fiinishes products. You might want to then play with some pigment stain over the dye stain, on test pieces of course, to see if it adds anything desirable. I find that dyes tend to look too uniform by themselves and benefit from the addition of pigment to add depth and contrast. It's essentially a glaze and can really make a difference. Be careful with open pored woods like oak and ash, though, because the pigment in the pores can make it look too contrasty, and it really puts the spotlight on weird grain patterns. That's why I start with the dye and follow up with any pigment. It seems there's less pigment deposit in the pores, at least on diffuse porous hardwoods like maple and cherry.

All just my 2¢...

Ellis

Re: Wood choice question?

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Wood choice question?

Clint Searl

Beware the sun. The ash credenza I show in the "Members Gallery" is dye stain under lacquer. It has sat in a seasonally sunny location for the last five years, and has lost about half its color depth.

Re: Wood choice question?

#5

Re: Wood choice question?

Jesse Cloud

I would avoid cherry. It reacts to light for a long time. That's not a problem unless you like to set something on the table. The space under that thing will be lighter than the rest of the table. I had to refinish a cherry table that had the outline of the base of a lamp on it. I incorrectly thought that if I left it bare in the intense New Mexico sun for a month it would be as dark as it would get. Wrong!

I have a walnut table treated with a glaze as Ellis described and the finish has held up well, even though it gets direct sunlight.

Re: Wood choice question?

#6

You can put something on the table early

Dick Coers

if you move it around a lot. Once delivered a table of curly soft maple, precat lacquer satin was the only finish. Got a call back and they moved a duck decoy that was in the center of the table. A perfect spot on that new maple in the shape of a duck. I told them to move it around for a few months, and didn't get a call back after that. I vote no stain, but I always recommend that!

Re: Wood choice question?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Right

Ellis Walentine

I lost track of the original question which was which to use in a sunny location. Some dyes, notably the water-soluble ones, tend to hold up better under UV, but pigments are the best bet for retaining their color in the sun.

Thanks, Clint.

Ellis