Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT Motor Horse Power question

Posts

OT Motor Horse Power question

#1

OT Motor Horse Power question

Barry Irby

I thought that by definition a horse power for an electric motor was about 746 watts and the best way to compare motors was to compare watts.

I bought a Kitchen Aid stand mixer at Costco for a Christmas Gift. The box boldly declared "1 Horse Power". My friend wanted one of the big heavy duty mixers, not one of the 375 watt models. I gave it them and they took it home and read something on the bottom that said the mixer had 350 watts. I called Kitchen Aid and they told me that that mixer had not been popular because of the (poor) bowl design and they had discontinued it. Costco bought the remaining stock and was discounting them.

Reading the (negative) reviews on the Kitchen Aid site indicates a number of users had the machine over heat under load and turn itself off and that many of them had had it replaced under warranty.

Kitchen Aid claims the motor is a DC motor and thus produces a horse power out of 350 watts. Is this possible? Can converting the power to DC increase the out put by about double?

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#2

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

Keith Newton

Hey Barry, If Sears can manage to produce 6.5 HP through a #16 wire on their shop vacs, I don't know why not. ;)

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#3

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

Henry Higginbotham

Barry, this is Marketing Horsepower, or HPM, as opposed to For Real Horsepower, or HPFR. :D

No, they can't get a continuous 1hp from a 350W motor, whether AC, DC, or AC/DC Highway to Hell.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#4

That's what I thought, and that's why....

Barry Irby

there is no mention of the watts on the box or the web site.

Fool that I am I trusted Costco to be reputable and not dupe me.

We will be returning it.

I have ordered the replacement. Its the current model that accommodates the full line of accessories. Its 575 watts, not a horse power, but better than 350. got it off Amazon. They are completely reputable, I just know they are, I'm really sure, I think.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#5

Re: That's what I thought, and that's why....

Henry Higginbotham

. . . Amazon. They are completely reputable . . .

Wanna buy a bridge? :) Seriously, I'd trust Costco with my SSN and mother's maiden name before I'd trust Amazon with my phone number.

I don't think you could hold the horsepower rating against Costco. They didn't make the claim. They're not Consumer Reports--they just sold a product from what used to be a good manufacturer. Now, if had been branded Kirkland, that would be a different situation.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#6

Re: That's what I thought, and that's why....

Barry Irby

You are right. I have dealt with Costco for years. I am just feeling duped. The stuff I bought from them in the past seemed to be very carefully selected, not just the tail end of a line that was discontinued and orphaned.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#7

Re: That's what I thought, and that's why....

Jesse Cloud

Unfortunately, I think the Marketing Horsepower bull is so widespread that if Costco only sold correctly labelled stuff, their electronics and power tool shelves would be empty.

But you are right to return it and it would be good if you complained formally to them. That kind of feedback is important.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#8

JL

Kitchen Aid Mixers

JL

The 4.5 qt is about 300 W.

The 5 qt tilt head is about 325 W.

The 6 qt is 575 W.

You don't get into the 1 hp range until you go for the professional models like the 6500 series.

I have a 4.5 qt. My B-I-L (who is a professional) has a 6500 and the 4.5 qt that was made by Hobart.

I have used the 20 qt and the 10 qt Hobart mixers.

I really want a 6 qt. I just haven't been able to justify it.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#9

Re: Kitchen Aid Mixers

Barry Irby

Thanks.

We played with it a bit before they took it home. It was surprisingly difficult to remove and replace the bowl. There was not enough room to remove the whisk without removing the bowl, but you could not remove the bowl without removing the whisk. You had to remove the whisk, drop it into the bowl, then remove the bowl and then remove the whisk from the bowl. The flared top of the bowl made it impossible to remove the bowl with the whisk in place. I am hoping the straight sided bowl will drop through the arms that support it allowing it to be removed with the whisk in place. It was a really poor design and I hope the new one will be better.

I truly do not understand how some really stupid designs get into production.

I have read the doe hook and beater are made of "burnished" steel (whatever that is) and it will rust. This thing sells for enough money they could afford to use stainless. sheesh.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#10

Re: Kitchen Aid Mixers

Mark Nowicki

The head of the mixer flips up (right lever on ours lock the head, left is for speed control)

Slight clockwise twist to lock the bowl, counterclockwise to unlock.

You didn't read the manual, did you? :-)

Mark

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#11

Different mixer......

Barry Irby

You are describing one of the tilt head models, one of them is 375 watts and the other 350, I think. One version is called the Artisan. 4.5 or 5 quart bowls.

The one I bought is a 6 Quart Bowl Lift version. The head does not tilt. She wanted the biggest baddest one they had for home use. I hinted at the 5 quart one, but no, it had to be the 6 quart version. I was about to order one when BOOM, miracle of miracles, Costco had about fifty of them sitting on an end cap and at about the same price. Labels all over the box declare it to be 1 Hp. I grabbed it and put it under the tree. Literally. Covered the box with a white sheet and put the tree on top of it. In spite of the fishing and hinting she was stunned.

Reviewing the reviews on Amazon and Kitchen aid was interesting. They get 5's and 1's. Fives seem to be mostly from people who bought it last week and think its beautiful, 1's come from people that actually used it. After a while I realized the reviews were all mixed up. They were reviewing ANY Kitchen Aid mixer.

I called Kitchen Aid and the young lady I got was quite blunt. The version I had had been roundly criticized by the buyers and many of them returned and they discontinued it and Costco took the remaining stock.

One of the general complaints was that people liked the tilt head version better because you can tilt the head back and let the beater drip into the bowl. Kitchen aid and those of us who bought it clearly did not realize how tedious it was going to be to get the bowl off if the head did not tilt and they did not provide enough "stroke" in the lift mechanism to allow the whisk to be removed or installed with the bowl in place. Another half and inch would have made a huge different.

I did read the manual, but only after I bought it. I wish they had had one out on display so I could have played with it a bit. Better yet, I wish they had had several versions out to play with. I bought a pig in a poke. The good news is, I will return it.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#12

It's all in the measurement method

Bill Howatt

Seeing over-rated HP claims is not unusual which is why the advice to "check the current" rating.

Electric lawnmowers, shop-vacs and a bunch of other stuff, typically with universal motors, get their HP ratings by a method that measures the current draw just before the motor stalls. Of course, the current is high and if it was a continuous condition the motor would burn out.

Bill

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#13

Re: Very true!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

When I was a young lad of about 19 (about 55 years ago) I worked in a motor rebuild shop. We rebuilt motors then tested every one on a dynamometer. Even then there were new motor producers that were deceiving the public a little. I could rebuild a motor built in the 1930's or 40's and dyno it, I could normally increase the load of the 1/2 HP rated motor to at least 3/4 HP and it would not lose RPM's or exceed the full rated Amp draw. Almost all of that era motors would also start under at least 150% of rated load. The newer motors built in the late 50's would barely start the rated load and would almost always stall shortly after reaching the rated load - and drew the full amp rating at the rated load. Actually at that time they were truthful, but we had several incidents where a person replaced an older motor only to find out the new one would not start the existing load or would overheat under the load, when the old motor with the same rating had ran for many years.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#15

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

A true 1 HP motor on 120 volts will pull about 11.6 amps. Thus 11.6 amps times 120 volts equals 1392 watts. The difference from 746 watts/HP is due to motor efficiency, power factor, and other complicated electrical stuff. Any true motor larger than 1 1/2 HP will not run on a household, 120volt outlet with a 20 amp breaker! Seven HP shop vacs are a BIG LIE. Do not fall for all their PR junk. Most ratings like this are changed to make them sound better. Fans are best rated by cfm. Cubic feet per minute. But against zero back pressure cfm almost means nothing! Compressor ratings rated at 0 psi fall to about 10% at 90 psi. Air tools need about 10 cfm/90 psi. Can you maintain constant use of your airtool?

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#16

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

TomD

I wouldn't want a 7 hp Shop Vac anyway. I like the cat and the little ones too much as it is.

The noisy tools often have HP based on the fact that e varies to the second power of v. But the noise apart, it isn't the same thing as stopping 50 pounds of armature. On the other hand a router so rated may well accomplish as much work as a saw of similar rating. If dust is the measure.

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#17

Re: It's all in the measurement method

Jerry Nicholson

I think they get the advertised hP by multiplying the stall current by the line voltage and dividing by 746. Of course it's all a lie because power is the rate of doing work (one HP is 550 pound-feet per second) and the motor is doing zero work at stall and so is generating no power, not matter how much it is dissipating as heat.

Jerry

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#18

Re: HP measurement methods - more info *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Jerry,

Thanks for the information about stall current being used to determine 'advertised' HP ratings.

Of course you led me to dig a bit more and I came up with this link to a pretty simple explanation of the motor horsepower rating methods that lead to my Rigid shop vac being rated at 6.5HP, in spite of the fact that it plugs into a normal 15A, 125 VAC outlet.

Bob in NJ


http://www.kevinsbrady.net/motors.pdf

Re: OT Motor Horse Power question

#19

Re: HP measurement methods - more info

kencombs

Brings to mind the old saying:

Figures never lie.

But Liars figure.