Re: Why I like a planer
TomD
I wouldn't say I know why SC did it with the granite, but if it works, I think it is a great idea. What I mean by "if it works" is that I wouldn't have known off the top that the material would be supported and yet allow some of the finer details to be strong enough. But since it seems they can there are a lot of advantages.
In a lot of ways it is probably cheaper. If you look at the cost of granite surface plates of Taiwan quality you can get a fairly large pieces, larger than most bandsaw tables or wheels would require for about 30 dollars retail. Using cast is tough, few people think the Asian castings are any good, even on very expensive machines they sometimes just snap off. But god made the granite, and his work is pretty good. Tough to really mess it up.
Granite has that luxury reputation at the moment, and all you do is grind it, no arcane seasoning
One of the things that appeals to me the most is that many hobby tools either live in badly heated places, or end up there for a while before they find their next owner. I found a great deal on Inca tools, but it had rusted in many places, in only the short period the previous owner was sick, and then the few months to sell them. Of course Inca is aluminum so there are a lot of other bits and pieces that can be the problem when condensation gets to work. I have had several saws that got ruined with condensation, like when an overhead pipe that had never sweated, one year up and does. it's nice to have a table that isn't affected by such things.
Weight has it's place, overall I am more for light weight stuff, like Inca. But there are many people who like the weight, and granite has that.
Finally, it was something new. There are so many copy cat tools out there, we already have all that stuff.