Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Air dried Walnut

Posts

Air dried Walnut

#1

Air dried Walnut

Bill P

Can I start to use some Walnut that my dad had cut from the property 4 or 5 years ago. It's been stacked and covered since then. It varies in thickness from 1 1/4" to over 2". The widthes also vary from 6 to 16 inches. Would it be better to have it run through a kiln first.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#2

Re: Air dried Walnut

Barry Irby

The general rule is a year per inch of thickness. This is a very loose rule and depends on how well its covered, what your climate is and probably some other things. I'm in central Virginia and I have built many things form air dried walnut that was an inch thick and dried about a year. You could test its moisture content with a meter or you could do the calculation by oven drying a piece. You would have to have a meter or an accurate set of scales. You could bring a piece or two inside and carefully measure the width, wait a month or two and measure again. See if it changes. It would be good to bring it all inside and let it acclimate anyway, even if it were kiln dried.

My guess is that you can bring it in, start to prep it while it acclimates and you are good to go.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#3

Drying is good

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Would it be better to have it KD? Categorically yes, if, you have a place that knows what they are doing. That is a big if. Many small kilns are sloppy. I have seen 4/4 lumber put in with 8/4, for example, with the result that the 8/4 winds up stressed. And there are a dozen other ways to screw up drying lumber in a kiln.

Properly KD, it will be all of the same moisture content, it will regain less moisture and it will reliably be ready to use. The drier it is the less you will have to know to build something that doesn't tear itself apart when it is put into a living area.

The rules of thumb for drying are utterly useless and it would be well to let this folklore lapse into extinction. Your lumber has set long enough that it has equilibrated with the humidity of its surroundings. The humidity of where it is at and how long it has been at this humidity are the only variables that affect what its current moisture content is.

It is not possible to recommend whether it can be used as is without knowing what you are going to build, joinery to be used and what the current moisture content is. That said, if you move it into an area with similar conditions to your living area with good air circulation, in a couple of weeks it may be good to go.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#4

Re: Air dried Walnut

Yonak

I use almost exclusively air dried lumber and have never had a dryness-related issue, that I can remember. 4~5 years is plenty of time for the lumber moisture to equalize with the environment.

I would be more concerned with bugs, if it's been stored outdoors for so long. Now, I don't know if the bugs hibernate in the cold weather, but you could bring it indoors for a few weeks or a few months. That way, it would equalize with the indoor atmosphere and it would give time to see if sawdust piles begin to show beneath it.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#5

Depends

Dick Coers

Where do you live, and where (and how) was it stored? It would be pretty rough to mess up kiln drying it with that much time air drying. Measure the moisture content, and either have it kiln dried, or heat it up over 135 for a few days till the core reaches that temp.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#6

Works

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

to kill any resident bugs as well.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#7

Re: Air dried Walnut

don stephan

One of the above comments is the first time I have seen the one year per inch of thickness guideline challenged, although I have from time to time seen the suggestion to add one extra year for good measure. My recollection is that after air drying, which is generally considered to take the wood to 12% moisture content, the most common recommendation is to bring the wood into a conditioned space (HVAC) for six months, stacked and stickered, to further lower the moisture content.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#8

Why the year per inch "rule" is useless guidance

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How fast lumber dries after it is sawed and what moisture content it arrives at strongly depends on temperature, humidity, air flow and species. Given the huge range these variables can span, predicting a drying time to achieve workable lumber is impossible without knowing the drying conditions. It could be three months for poplar in a southern summer with good air circulation, or three years to never for oak in a cool damp location with poor air circulation.

Taking the example of poplar and oak as an illustration of how quick lumber can dry, it takes a modern drying facility 30 days to dry oak from saw to 7% moisture content, but less than 7 days for poplar. Oak doesn't yield its water readily, while poplar does.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#9

Re: Air dried Walnut *LINK*

Keith Newton

Rather than dealing with finding a kiln operator who would work your lumber with whatever green wood they are running, which would be a mistake, here is a simple process that anybody can set up cheaply.

Besides getting the MC down, it will kill any insects. One other thing I've started doing, is use one of those internal meat thermometers on the end of a cable, with a display outside the oven. I Just drill a hole the size of the probe into the middle of a board, then I'm sure when it is done.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_946.shtml

Re: Air dried Walnut

#10

Re: KD mythmaking

TomD

"Properly KD, it will be all of the same moisture content, it will regain less moisture and it will reliably be ready to use. The drier it is the less you will have to know to build something that doesn't tear itself apart when it is put into a living area."

I think you are myth making there, even encapsulating it in epoxy won't stop it from returning to ambient. I don't know of any net advantage to kiln drying over air drying, but in the case of walnut if steamed during the process it can even out sap wood colour, which is either a disaster or a blessing depending on how you wear your pencil pocket protector.

In fact re-reading that para there are four errors there. The other 3 are:

- It is doubtless true about the same moisture content, but that is in no way unique to properly kiln dried wood, instrument wood that was air dried as say for violins or any other air dried wood that was properly dried will be that way also

- KD wood is only as good as it's last moisture content, unless you are building the furniture in the kiln, it will rapidly equalize, and be no different than any other wood. All wood is actually air dried. So KD is no more "reliably ready to use" than air dried. Particularly not if the place the furniture will live or be worked is nowhere near the KD moisture end point.

- It is ridiculous to suggest that the drier wood is, the less you have to know to build something out it. Depends on the differential as to where the wood will end up. It is true that there are less moisture points to the dry side of ambient than the wet side, but not where dried wood is concerned.

If you want an absolutely easy and foolproof way to build without having to know anything, just finish dry the wood in your house if the project will end up in your house, or some similar dwelling. If you are like me, and have a shop that is not exactly the same as you house, then you will need to be careful about leaving critical pieces too long in the shop. If you are buying wood from one place, processing it in another, and it's resting place is in a third, it is tough to just be stupid about it and get good results.

There also isn't just one KD result. Speaking of "properly" kd wood incorporates an element of tautology, but since one doesn't really know whether it is proper or not, it won't help.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#11

Re: Air dried Walnut

TomD

Bill P, It depends what you want to do with the wood. If you want to sell the wood as KD'd or want to even out sap wood color then getting it KD'd would help. I never do that and cut most of my own wood. If you have a piece, and you just want to use it. 4-5 years stacked and stickered is going to be more than enough to get it where it is going, but how dry that is, in your conditions, is open to question. If it wasn't stickered, you can't be sure it is dry even after that time.

One simple way is to test it, is with a meter. As with all electronics there are pretty cheap versions, there are also a few that are a joke, but maybe 15 bucks would get you one. Or borrow one. Remember that the meter may not get you results from deep in the plank.

A reliable way of calculating content is to put a piece in the oven and compare before and after weights. Put a sliver in your microwave, and look for abundant escaping moisture. Cut into the surface and sense whether it feels wet. Dried wood has some moisture, but it doesn't feel wet. When you saw or plane it, the smells and feedback should all be dry not wet. Walnut is a light wood, it shouldn't feel like you are moving elm.

The simplest way to prepare boards for projects is to bring a few planks into the house, if the house rules allow. If you have several places, like a colder dark garage, a basement, the house, you can ease a few boards through those locations and keep an eye on them. Make sure they are shaded, and that air can circulate. Watch them carefully the first few days you move them in, or after any major changes. You can ease all the boards in this way, if you are the end user. A few at a time, as projects progress. But even it that won't work, you can start getting some experience with the wood and just seeing how it goes.

Another thing you may be able to do is to do a few projects that don't care if they are wetish (your wood should be dry as a bone if it has been drying in proper conditions all that time). Stuff like stools can be undertaken with wet wood, and you will learn a lot making them about the condition of your wood.

Re: Air dried Walnut

#12

Re: Why the year per inch "rule" is useless guidan

TomD

That is very true, but at the same time the rule isn't totally useless to those who need to know what kind of commitment they are undertaking. Or as in this case where unless the wood was stored in a wholy inappropriate way or place, it should be done line diner, at least to the point where it should start to be positioned in places nearer indoor norms.

Where I live, the rule is generous, with trees cut from standing wood, so if you give it that much time in generally drier and warmer climates you won't be wrong. It would be very difficult to use if the objective was very speedy drying. But when one starts to acquire wood to use in this hobby many of us accumulate more than we can use right away. I met a LV manager who had three family member garages full of wood he had cut, and he looked in his twenties. I have hundreds of board feet at any time. Probably thousands. Plus ten oaks that are waiting on the saw after last summer's hurricane. The only time I worried about the inch rule was when I laid down the first wood 35 years ago. In that sense you are also correct, nothing to worry about.