Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

Posts

Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#1

Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

don stephan

Prepping for a grade school talk about wood, and wondering why some woods like ash split so very easily and some do not. Couldn't find any discussion in Hoadley's Understanding Wood this evening. I remember reading that American Elm doesn't split because the tree alternates clockwise and counterclockwise spiraling as it grows.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#2

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

john Veerkamp

in general straight grained woods split easily and twisted grain woods don't. even trees of the same type can be different. Wood around crotches and burls is tougher to split than straight trunk sections. wood can become twisted through environmental conditions or genetic growth habits. Not the entire answer, ut a good start.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#3

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

Larry Barrett

Ash, Oak, and Hickory are classified as ring-porous woods. If you take a look at the cross-section of a red oak log, and zoom in on a few growth rings, you will see what this means. Each growth ring consists of early wood (the wood that grew in the spring) and late wood (fall). The early wood has large pores and is structurally weak. The result is that ring-porous woods usually split easily, especially when green. The weak early wood in ash logs is what allows individual growth rings to be separated and made into splints, used in baskets.

Some logs, like elm, have interlocking fibers which alternate direction from one growth ring to the next. This makes elm really hard to split, usually impossible.

If you have Hoadley, take a look on page 22 (1980 edition) to see illustration of elm. Page 15 shows magnified images of oak growth rings.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#4

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

Tom Dunlap

Don,

Larry is on track.

You wrote:

I remember reading that American Elm doesn't split because the tree alternates clockwise and counterclockwise spiraling as it grows.

This is something that I've never heard before and I'm confused about how it could be. I'm going to guess that you've remembered something in a wrong way. The coriolis effect may have an influence hemispherically but not on trees in situ.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#5

Dale Lenz

spiraling grain

Dale Lenz

I recall our post oak has spiraling grain in both direction and makes it difficult to dry flat. Check out the link below.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#6

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

Sgian Dubh

Frequently, those timber species that split easily have pronounced medullary rays that are, in common with all species, orientated radially. This is the direction in which the wood is 'weakest' and therefore most easily split. White oaks fall into this category and are relatively easy to split following the radial direction. Those species with less prominent medulla are also weaker in this orientation, but less prominently so. Interlocked grain, as others have already said presents a more difficult challenge for splitting. European elm, by the way, not a species noted for its external durability except when submerged and permanently wet (e.g., centuries old pilings under buildings in Venice) was much used in wooden warships because of its ability to resist shattering when struck by cannonballs, unlike oak.

Interestingly, it’s thought that in northern Europe the now common practice of sawing planks out of a log never happened before the twelfth century. The following thirteenth and fourteenth centuries witnessed improved technology. Better saw and steel technology provided the ability to saw planks out of logs. Yet we know that planking was used in abundance prior to the 1100s, e.g., in Viking long boats, so it must have been riven wood which, in all probability, means it was oak. A 25 mm (1”) thick riven board is as strong as a sawn board 50 mm (2”) thick. Slainte.

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: spiraling grain, try the link once again  *LINK*


Grain orientation

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#8

Re: spiraling grain, try the link once again

Tom Dunlap

Dale,

Thanks for the link. I've seen many trees with spiral in them, in fact, it isn't uncommon to find it once my eye was taught what I was seeing.

The author said that spiral could be seen by studying the face cut. There is an illustrating showing two cracks. If that were visible in a felling face cut the sawyer had better be careful. Never should a face cut be half the diameter of a trunk.

When I see canopy damage/decline I can usually look below and see some root damage. By looking at the bark spirals its pretty evident what swath of the tree will be in decline.

that said, I really don't think that spiral grain in elm has much to do with how hard elm is to split.

Tom

Tom

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

#9

Re: Why Do Some Woods Split Easily?

rfcomm2k

What Larry said is true. However, trees of the same species grown in different habitats will grow differently. A white oak grown in the south will have significantly larger early growth rings than a white oak grown in the forests of Canada. This is largely due to the longer "growing season" in the south.