Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Oak finish advice sought

Posts

Oak finish advice sought

#1

Oak finish advice sought

Larry Rupprecht

Just about to finish sanding on a red oak headboard. Very simple Mission style, 1-1/2 x 3" x 44" high posts, 3-1/4" wide horizontal rails supporting a set of eleven vertical stiles. Mortise and tenon construction throughout and no fasteners except pins on the back side of each joint through the tenons. The top rail is covered with a 1-1/4" wide x 5/8" thick cap. All edges and post tops are chamfered to break the sharp edges. The face grain is rift with a few very subtle ray flecks showing on some pieces.

The cap and the top rail are also showing a subtle tiger stripping and I'd like some advice on how to "pop" that tiger stripping so it is noticeable after finishing. Not looking for the dramatic highlights, just something more than the almost totally hidden look that red oak ray flecks and tiger stripping normally present once clear coats are applied.

My normal finishing sequence is to sand all flat surfaces to 220 and any cross-cut ends to 320 grit, apply Cabot's golden oak oil-based stain, dry 24 hrs minimum, seal with three or more wipe-on coats of Seal Coat shellac cut 50% with alcohol. Next sanding is 220 followed by multiple coats of water-based polyurethane with 320/400 rubbing between coats.

Thanks for any ideas. this headboard is the last of the Christmas gifts for this run....until I get further orders from the Boss, that is.

Re: Oak finish advice sought

#2

Re: Oak finish advice sought

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I wold use a lacquer to bring out the grain highlights after your stain. I've had good results with Deft Clear Wood Finish and Cabot Brushing Lacquer. You will need lots of ventilation as the fumes are bad. You can apply it in an unheated building. I've applied Deft at 10 degrees F. It just takes 24 hours to dry.

This box was finished with Deft.


Lee

Re: Oak finish advice sought

#3

Testing

David Yoho

Larry, I don't see why your usual method wouldn't work for what you're wanting, unless you've tried it before and weren't happy with it. My advise would be to test it on some scrap first to see.

I've used a little darker stain than golden on QS oak followed by varnish and the figure stands out good to me.

Not to be picking here but you seem to add extra work to your schedule that might not be necessary. I hardly ever sand beyond 150-grit before applying finish. Also three coats of Seal Coat seems like too much. Usually one or two is all I ever need. Once I start applying anything clear over stained or natural wood I only use 320 or 600 wet/dry paper. Anything more is removing some of what you applied, which in some cases is desirable, but not normally.

Re: Oak finish advice sought

#4

Re: Testing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've always sanded to 220 and on a few occasions 320 before staining. Generally I use either Minwax Antique Oil or a wipe-on poly (most of my projects aren't very big). However, I had a pro shop shoot a couple coats of pre-cat poly on a dining table and the guys told me not to go beyond 150 if I planned to stain because it wouldn't penetrate evenly. Go figure.

Re: Oak finish advice sought

#5

Time to experiment with dye

Dick Coers

Dye will kick the color compared to pigmented stain filling the open pores with colored pigment. If you want to accent figure, dye it the lightly sand it. That's tough to do on some assembled furniture. A lot of stock stains have pigment and dye. Some folks don't like the look of oak that doesn't have pigment to show the course grain, so take some scrap and experiment.

Re: Oak finish advice sought

#6

agree on all points

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In fact if you sand oak too fine and use a pigment stain the stain will not take well on the polished hard parts of the wood.