Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Moisture meter reading variations

Posts

Moisture meter reading variations

#1

Moisture meter reading variations

Randy Stukenberg

I have two moisture meters: Wagner L609 (pinless) and Lignomat miniLIGNO E/D.

Measuring the same board, they give drastically different readings:

White oak air dried: Wagner 14% mini 7.2%

Red Oak kiln dried: 7.0 6.0

Poplar KD: 12 <6.0

Cherry KD: 8 6.0

The Wagner I picked up at an auction this spring, the mini I just got new today.

Which one do I trust?

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#2

Also:

Randy Stukenberg

The W/O is rough, but I handplaned a spot to check the reading, the rest were planed surfaces.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#3

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Yonak

Randy, I don't have an answer to which one to trust but my understanding is that you shouldn't have to plane an area to be smooth for the reading as the pinless measures at a depth of, like, 3/4".

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#4

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Larry Barrett

You can test a sample with your two meters, then dermine the actual moisture content (MC) of a sample by weight. This will give you an idea which meter is accurate.

To determine the MC of a sample by weight, first weigh and record the weight at the same time you measured its MC with your two meters. Call this weight W1. Then put the sample in an oven at 120 F (plus or minus). Take it out of the oven and check weight every few hours. When you get the same reading 2 or 3 times in a row the sample is oven dry and at 0% MC (or very close to 0%). Call this weight W2. The MC of the sample before you put in the oven is then given by

(W1 - W2)/W2 x100.

Compare this MC to the readings you recorded with the meters prior to the oven.

If you want to read more about this, check Hoadley's book, Understanding Wood (1980), chapter 5.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#5

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Bill Howatt

Buy a third one then average the 2 closest readings! ;)

What is the history of the wood? If it has all been in the same location for a considerable period of time then the moisture content should be roughly the same. This would say that the mini has it right.

I only consider 2 of your readings our of whack; the ones that differ by a factor of 2. Anything within a couple of percent is normal IMO and you can even find that much variation measuring different places in the same board.

Bill

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#6

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Grant in Iowa

Randy,

Did either of your meters come with a guide that instructs to make a calculation or switch setting change for different woods? If so, perhaps one of the meters needs a switch setting changed for oak, or one needs an offset calculated? I have a mini ligno and it came with a guide to tell you which switch setting (2 or 3) for differing woods.

Maybe you did take these in to account, if so sorry I raised the question. I thought it should be asked, however.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#7

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Grant in Iowa

Also,

You may already know this, but consider that just because wood was kiln dried to <6% at one point, doesn't mean it will stay that way. The MC% will still move with the humidity in the space they are stored. Less so in flat stacked piles, but it will still change noticeably.

I would also observe that the pin type is likely measuring somewhere around 1/8" beneath the surface of the wood, while the Wagner is likely measuring deeper. It might just be that your boards are drier on the outside than on the inside, or vise-versa.

A man who has one watch always knows what time it is, while a man with two watches is never quite sure

Regards,

Grant in Iowa<--Has only one moisture meter, and is sure of the MC of his wood.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#8

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Randy Stukenberg

I didn't know they read at different depths. That could account for the difference in the white oak (in the shop 2 weeks, heated floor) I did correct for the readings per the chart or setting.

Yeah, I was sure of the MC until I tried a friend's meter...

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#9

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Randy Stukenberg

Bill, the KD wood has been in the shop 2-12 months, the AD white oak 2-4 weeks. Heated floor, wood temp ~68-70°

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#10

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

del schisler

the temp. of the wood will make a difference also, try we say wood at room temp and out side temp and see what difference , at the same point on the wood, i use a meter also and figure a few degree's eather way, one is a delmhurst and one is a general , the meters are for a general idea on moisture, if kiln dried wood it will come back on some on moisture and air dryied will dry out in the house made product which can make a project go bad, i guess you could do what has been mention and weigh the wood ect.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#11

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

Barry Irby

I have been using moisture meters for years in my home inspections and in my shop. I don't even pretend to use them in an absolute sense, Only in a comparative sense. For example, if the wood at the back door is suspect, I meter a place on the floor several feet away that appears dry and then check at the door. If the floor at the door reads a few points higher, something is leaking.

I have both pin meters and pin-less ones in several differing brands. What I do in the shop is read a piece of wood of the same species in the house against a piece in the shop. The pieces in the house vary with the season and continually change and acclimate to the surroundings. They are never really stable. Your construction techniques must accommodate the residual movement. There whole books written on how to build things that will survive the movement and how to minimize the effect.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#12

Yep, this...

John in NM

If you want the true measurement, this is how to do it. Measure with both meters first and then use the weight method.

I have one of those pin meters from Veritas, since out here in the desert it's just a matter of time - all I need the meter for is to tell when :D

I often drive a couple nails into a sacraficial bit of board to get a more accurate reading - just touch the pins up to the nails.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#13

Re: Yep, this...

Sgian Dubh

"I often drive a couple nails into a sacrificial bit of board to get a more accurate reading - just touch the pins up to the nails."

John, I don't think that your method is guaranteed to provide a more accurate reading, just a different reading to that gained through the pin penetration possible using that type of meter. There is almost always a moisture gradient from the surface of the wood to the core. The average moisture content is usually about halfway between the surface and the centre of the board thickness. In a board 25 mm (1”) thick this means the pins get a good median reading at about 6 or 7 mm deep (7/32”±) deep. Similarly, with a board 100 mm (4”) thick the pins should ideally penetrate 25-30 mm (1” to 1-5/32”), and many of the more sophisticated moisture meters include a separate set of extra long pins with an integral sliding hammer device that can be driven into thick boards to get a reading via electric leads that plug into the meter. So, unless your driven in nails penetrate to approximately 1/4 of the wood's thickness their readings will only be as accurate as any other means of reaching that depth. Slainte.

Re: Moisture meter reading variations

#14

It's really a matter of not bending the pins

John in NM

The stock pins on that meter bend easily, so the nails get about 1" of depth and keep from having to hammer on the meter and have the pins get even more bent :D

Humid out here is about 20% RH daily average - dry is so dry that it cracks your skin. The meter just tells me if I need to let stuff sit another month to get to 6% or less :D

If I were in TX or the midwest, I might need to worry about the kind of accuracy you're talking about, but then I'd be doing the weigh and bake method.