Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

Posts

1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#1

Bart Goldberg

1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

Bart Goldberg

I am looking to replace my very old PC model 340K 1/4 sheet finisih sander. I am tempted to get a Festool - but am turned off by the need to buy and use their Sandpaper. Any suggestions? Price is not an issue.

Thanks

Bart

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

Dale Lenz

If you google Festool sandpaper there are off-brands selling paper that will work.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#3

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

mdclor

I have a Festool ROS and tried using Klingspor discs. After a very short period of time, the discs started flying off the pad when in use. I called Festool and they indicated that using a different brand would have a different hook & loop structure that would shorten the life of the pad. I switched back to Festool paper and the issue was resolved. This was some years ago so the H&L issue may have been fixed by the other abrasive manufacturers. FWIW

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#4

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Think about using hot glue to stick the pads to the frame of the sander. It can be removed when

another pad is to be installed.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#5

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

David Yoho

Bart, since you say price is not an issue, go for the Festool. It's worth the extra money. I have two Festool sanders but primarily use their 6-inch ROS that's for finishing. I have it hooked to one of their vacuums and it not only increases the sanding pad life but leaves virtually no dust on the work or in the air.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#6

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions *LINK*

Gary Smyth

I still like the Speed Block Porter Cable 330 palm sander. It's rugged and my goto sander for quick jobs as well as my finishing. I'm sanding so I expect dust. Internal dust collection is of little consequence. I wear a mask when sanding and use a separate vacuum to remove dust. The design is at least 30 years old but these work for me and parts (if needed) are no problem. Because they are of old design they are often priced (used) easily in the forty dollar range. As a result I have four. Picture below. Amazon page with picture and holiday promotion but most any tool distributor carries these. Read the Amazon reviews! Shop around if interested. Check Craig's list and perhaps find one local for even less.


http://www.amazon.com/PORTER-CABLE-330-Speed-Bloc-Sheet-Sander/dp/B0000222Y9/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1418485009&sr=8-1&keywords=porter+cable+330+sander

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#7

Me Too

David Yoho

I have the PC 330 and an old Makita with dust bag palm sanders that see a considerable amount of action. My Festool finishing sander sees the largest amount of use in my shop, however.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#8

Are any of these machines faster than hand sanding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How do they compare to a random orbital sander? What I am getting at is whether it makes sense to buy this format? I owned a circa 1970's model and it was uselessly slow.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#9

Clint Searl

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

Clint Searl

I like my Bosch because it's easy to change paper and holds the paper really tight. Also convenient for scrubbing with maroon scotchbrite, which can be left loose.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#10

Bart Goldberg

Anyone have the Makita BO3710 Finishing Sander?

Bart Goldberg

I saw a review of this sander on-line and it also has decent feedback on Amazon. While not a 1/4 sheet sander (Its a 3rd sheet), close enough for my interests and somewhat similar in size to the Festool.

Bart

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#11

Re: Are any of these machines faster than hand san

John in NM

I use one for sanding curved surfaces (convex for the most part). It is faster than hand sanding, and doesn't wear the skin off my fingers like hand sanding does.

I would probably replace mine if it croaked...

I'm not making much furniture these days, I didn't find them terribly useful for flat surfaces - RO's are better for that.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#12

Re: Anyone have the Makita BO3710 Finishing Sander

David Yoho

My Makita is the BO4550. Don't know how the two compare but I've had mine for a very long time. The sandpaper size is about the same as what fits my PC 330.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#13

Re: Are any of these machines faster than hand san

David Yoho

In some instances I think my palm sanders are faster than hand sanding. Most certainly random orbit is quicker than either. However, that said, Michael Dresdner has always advocated sanding by hand as your final stage of sanding by using a garnet paper of the same grit of your last machine sanding to remove any swirl marks left behind.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#14

I hand sand

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hand sand the final grit. If nothing else it causes me to focus on the surfaces which enables subtle defects to be found and fixed before they show up after finishing.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#15

I have to ask

Keith Newton

What other sanding equipment you own. Do you have belt and random orbital sanders? If not, save your money, and get a RO first.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#16

Bart Goldberg

Re: I have to ask

Bart Goldberg

Yes, I have all the typical sizes/types, 5 & 6 inch ROS, belt sander and 1/4 and 1/2 sheet sanders. I prefer to use the 1/4 sheet sander for small and narrow parts as well as for the inside of case goods where a round sander can't reach.

Bart

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#17

Dale Lenz

In that case....

Dale Lenz

I recommend the same as David: Makita BO4550 or some model close to it. Have been using the Makita BO4550 for probably 30 years...just plugged in my 3rd one the other night. The weak part that goes bad are the 4 plastic post that hold the pad to the sander's body, they break...I drop mine a lot, my feet often hooks the power cord on the floor below the bench and pulls the sander off the bench and falls to the floor, over time will damage/weaken the plastic support post. I prefer the hard felt sander pad over the softer rubber pad. On softwoods like pine you get more wood removable between the soft springwood and the harder summerwood, get a wavy surface. Using the harder felt pad or gluing a piece of thin cardboard to the rubber pad will remove the "wavy" sanding issues. Not sure that Makita still makes the BO4550 model...I go to Ebay and look around. Just like the feel of the Makita BO4550. Have the PC 330 sander also, but still prefer the Makita.

Your mileage may vary?

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#18

Bart Goldberg

Re: In that case....

Bart Goldberg

Dale, looks as if Makita makes a somewhat updated version of the BO4550 now called the BO4556 . They also have a 1/3 sheet sander (BO3710) - which is why I asked if anyone has one. It looks very good and still gives me the capability of the 1/4 - rectangular foot print, albeit a slightly larger one, and allows me to use the rather large stock of sheet sandpaper I already own.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#19

Dale Lenz

Re: In that case....

Dale Lenz

I like round-over edges and the Makita I use works/handles very well sanding the edges and outside corners.

Re: 1/4 Sheet Sander Suggestions

#20

Re: In that case....

Keith Newton

For what you fellows describe, I like using the smaller air random orbit sanders. The older one that I have is a Sioux 3", and I've forgotten what the newer one is, but I use a smaller disk. They both are variabal speed, and feel great in the hand, with the pad just in front of the knuckle of the trigger finger, offering good control.

I haven't used my 1/4 or 1/2 sheet sanders in years, but maybe they are different now.