Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

New Shop

Posts

New Shop

#1

New Shop

Mark Stone

Hi All,

It's been a long time since I've posted. After losing my wife (7 years ago) I kind of shut down. Since then I have met a woman that is amazing. She loves my woodworking and has motivated me back into the shop which is too small. Her hobby is stained glass making and she is good at it. As we are engaged now and looking to buy a house together she insists that we find a place where I can have a real shop (a double garage, LOL). We plan on incorporating her stained glass into my furniture. I am excited about getting a real shop with room to work rather than my 1 car garage. I plan to install a dust collection network in the new shop. Can anyone point me to documents on how to set up dust collection the "right" way as to minimize dust from entering the house? I've read a bunch of articles, but have always gotten the right answers from Woodcentral. If anyone has a proven standards doco, please let me know. And BTW, it's good to be back.

Cheers to all especially Ellis who's upbeat attitude and sometimes comical replies on the message board were helpful in my return.

Mark

Re: New Shop

#2

Re: New Shop

TomD

Glad for you that life is good again. 6-7 years is the norm, sometimes a fast forward button might be a good idea.

Dust collection has eluded me, I have mostly concentrated on not making dust in the first place. I do some stuff with less efficient low dust options, to me, it isn't fast if turning it on swamps the place with dust and creates a 5 hour clean-up job. I have a dust collector, but it isn't plumbed, and I don't have the space, or the discipline to fix an open, limited floor plan.

My ceiling is normal for a garage, but it is not high enough to put the dust and power in the floor.

A big factor to any advice will be how, or whether you heat.

I keep the dust out of the house by having a separate building. That does not keep the snow out, from all the trips back and forth.

Unless you can exhaust out of doors which is tough in an urban setting, or an arctic one, then you are going to be living with some bad stuff. So I combine the extraction/filtration with some ancillary air cleaning, and a helmet. And I have very strict rules I never deviate from about what materials I will work in the shop. I build boats, and never sand glass in the shop, or if possible outside either. I do all knife or tool grinding out of doors. etc...

Re: New Shop

#3

Re: New Shop

Randy Johnson

My shop is a converted two car garage.

For dust collection, get the biggest (i.e. horsepower) you can afford. Mine is a three H.P. Oneida. Often, I wish it was 5 H.P. instead.

My shop has a mixture of T-12 and T-8 light fixtures. When any of the T-8s are on, the remote for the DC will not work. One of my roundtoit projects is a series of four way switches with a three way at each end that will operate a contactor to start the DC. All too often I will not bother turning the DC on for a quick cut because it is a bit of a pain.

My biggest mistake was not mounting the cyclone high enough.The DC system was the last thing done. I really wish it was mounted where a large part of it was in the attic, allowing a bigger drop from the bottom of the cone but by the time I realized how tall the thing was the ceiling was up and painted and there was 15 inches or more of blown insulation in the attic. If I had it to do over I would have mounted most of the cyclone before dry walling the ceiling and then dry walled around it

Re: New Shop

#4

Re: New Shop

Barry Irby

I would suggest Bill Pintz's site for info of DC systems.

Also, Onieda designs systems for people using their Cyclones.

If you really want to keep the dust out of the house you should not use the door between the house and garage and actually seal it. Eliminate any air flow from the garage to the house.

Also, keep the shop cooler than the house. In my case the shop is down stairs and if the air in it is warm it rises into the house, bringing the dust with it.

Set up an air cleaner as well as dust collection system.

Depressurize the shop. Have the DC system exhaust the air out side. That way it will tend to pull air out of the house and into the shop.

Have a completely independent heating and cooling system for the shop. Do nto extend the house system into the shop and co-mingle the air.

Re: New Shop

#5

PS:  Welcome Back.....


Re: New Shop

#6

Dust

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the main route of dust from shop to house is on clothing. After some shop work shake out your shirt in a sun beam to illustrate the point.

As far as dust collection, call Oneida, tell them what you need to gather dust from and write the check. It will work as specified.

Re: New Shop

#7

Cheap air cleaner

Randy Stukenberg

I took the fan unit from an old furnace and built a box around it, with a couple of filters in the front. I use a cheaper pleated one in front and a better quality one behind it. It is amazing how much dust it collects when I sand or spray finishes in the shop. You should be able to pick one up from a local HVAC company for $20-30. I also put a filter on the back (exhaust) to diffuse the air flow, or build an angled box over it ti direct the air up instead of straight out. It works pretty well for a small investment.

Re: New Shop

#8

Re: Cheap air cleaner

Barry Irby

I have one of those too. It comes on when the lights come on. I built mine as a frame and have filters on all four sides. Three inlets and one exhaust.

You should be able to get one for free if you can charm the HVAC guys a bit. Be careful to get one out of a gas furnace or other device that uses 120 volt current. Most of them in heat pumps are 240 Volt.

Make two, position them in opposite corners of the shop to swirl the air.

Re: New Shop

#9

Re: New Shop

mdclor

Mark, welcome back and I am glad you are getting your life back on track.

Bill Pentz site has everything you would ever want to know about dust collection which is a strength and a weakness, think info overload.

I agree that Oneida is the way to go. I was ready to buy a new DC because my 2hp WoodSucker unit really wasn't doing the job. After talking with a tech at Oneida, he suggested a number of options for me to try before springing for the new DC. Those options have done the job and saved me a bundle. They aren't the cheapest but they are very knowledgeable and they are an American made product. HTH

Re: New Shop

#10

Re: New Shop

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Mark, a suggestion....make a visqueen closet to remove all dust off your self and clothes BEFORE reentering into the house.

They work for the guys in asbestos removel...say four feet square sealed at every joint and a rug underfoot which can be washed off occasionally.

Re: New Shop

#11

Re: New Shop

Hank Knight

Mark,

I think you're overthinking the dust-in-the-house issue. I have a basement shop with a Clear Vue cyclone set-up. In the 20 years we've lived in this house, my wife has never complained about wood chips or saw dust in the house. There are two reasons we don't have a dust issue. First, of course, is the Cyclone. It really makes a difference. The second is the fact that I have to walk about 20 feet through a basement corridor and the furnace room to get from the shop to ithe stairs up to our living quarters. I try to dust off my clothes before I leave the shop, but whatever chips, etc. that remain seem to get left behind on my way to the stairs. I don't know the configuration of your planned shop, but the idea of a "clean room" is probably a good one. I don't think it needs to be very hi tech, just a place to dust off before you go into the house. Works for me.

Welcome back.

Hank

Re: New Shop

#12

Ellis Walentine

I was wondering

Ellis Walentine

I had a feeling you were getting your life back together, Mark, and it looks like I was right. Welcome back to WoodCentral. You still down in New Britain (Chalfont?)?

Best of luck with your new relationship and your new house and shop. Keep us posted on your doin's.

On the dust question, I'd think that positive air pressure from the house to the shop is the key to keeping the fine stuff out. Barry's suggestion to exhause your DC air outside should accomplish that, but you'll want to figure out how to do it without losing all the heat in your shop in the bargain.

Regarding Bill Pentz's system, I have an unopened box of all the sheet metal to build your own that I got from Terry in Arkansas when he was building them for Pentz. I never got around to using it, but I've seen the system in action at Garrett Lambert's place in Victoria, and it is really amazing. If you're interested, I'll sell it to you at a discount. (I'm going to have to look this one up; it was easily ten years ago that I bought it.)

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: New Shop

#13

Ditto... and *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Oneida is a class act. Great products, great customer service too.

I installed a (then) newly introduced 2 HP "Gorilla" in about 2005, and completed the ducting in about 2007. I am over the moon happy with it.

One thing to keep in mind when deciding how much to spend on a Dust collector (DC) is that it will run about as much as all of your dust producing tools collectively. This means you want a well made machine with a good motor. Mine came with a conservatively rated 2HP Baldor motor.

The ducting is expensive, but after I shopped around and toyed with doing my own using HVAC parts, I ended up writing a check to Oneida for their standard piping system. Since I can weld, I saved some money by making my own reducers from their straight piping. Their standard ducting is actually very heavy duty, you will need a metal cutting bandsaw or cut off saw to cut it. I used a 4" angle grinder with a cut off wheel.

My DC has a seven inch inlet, and my piping layout kept it at seven inches until it got to two main branches, where I reduced it to 6". I then ran 6" to every machine except a drop to my drill press, where I used a 4" gate and a 20' length of flex hose left over from my old system. This allows for quick shop cleanup, and an added line to use for odd situations.

I did design my own DC system, mostly since I am a control freak. I read up on dust collection at Bill Pentz web site on the subject, link below. As I said above I made my own reducers to go on the tool side of the blast gate to reduce it to a size the flex hose would fit over. I simply cut a piece of straight piping about 8" long, then using an angle grinder with a cutoff wheel, I made about a 5" cut beginning at one end, parallel to the pipe. I used a hose clamp to squeeze that end until it fit in the 6" hose. I then ground the galvanization off where I wanted to weld and tacked it back together.

As I assembled the system, I used silicone and an acid brush to seal up every joint.

I should say that an important step is to "live" with the new shop and tools for a year or so...at least several projects. During this time, use a long flex tube between machines to gather dust. I believe this is important because the machines will then "declare" where they want to be, so when you install permanent DC lines, they will not need to be changed. Short of this, think about how to organize the machines to be able to cut the longest boards you are likely to work with, or how you might be able to accommodate a sheet of plywood on your table saw without conflicting with other tools in the shop.

I also discovered that I could save money by having tools in groups, where they could share one drop from the ceiling. An example is my Band saw, Jointer, and Planer are all situated back to back, and share one drop, but with three blast gates and three permanently connected hoses. This works good, since the work table of each is at a different height, and they don't interfere. The more you can overlap in feed and out feeds of machines, the more efficient the space can be for a one person shop.

My machines all came with 4" DC connections, if they had one at all. These are inadequate in my opinion. I used locally sourced HVAC parts and some homemade parts to build 6" adapters. True, I didn't have the heart to cut 6" holes in every tool, but a 6" flex tube butted to a 4" hole will still move a bunch more air than a 4" flex line on the same fitting.

I should take some photos and do a write up on how I did my DC piping some time. I incorporated a lot of ideas from many years of thinking and reading about the subject before I finalized the design.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


Bill Pentz dust collection

Re: New Shop

#14

Re: Ditto... and

Grant in Iowa

I would add:

If you get a cyclone, and you get a well made one, they really aren't that loud. Mine is sort of a low roaring sound with a bit of air sound mixed in. You will find that if you are hearing a lot of air noise, you probably don't have the ducts sealed. You can easily talk to someone standing next to it. So it isn't as loud as you might imagine. Where the noise comes in is when you open a blast gate on something like a big planer. You get the air raid siren effect...now THAT is loud. Point being the majority of the noise on these larger systems comes from the tool, and the air moving through the tool. Putting the DC exhaust outside isn't going to help much.

If you worry about the DC making too much noise, put up a small closet for it to reside in, and have a baffle or two that the air runs through as it flows back in to the room.

I would not advocate putting the exhaust side outside of the shop. Here's a bit of quick math:

My shop building is 45'x30'x9' high, drywalled (stealth gloat). 12,150 cubic feet. A well made 2HP Cyclone can move up to roughly 1200 cubic feet per minute. That means if you place the exhaust side outdoors, you will replace the air in that space every ten minutes. It has to come from somewhere. That is a lot of air to heat, dehumidify/ humidify, etc. Not really feasible in any climate requiring heating and cooling, or humidity control.

I do agree that in an attached garage, you would ideally have a higher air pressure in the living space than in the work shop. This would nicely keep dust out of the house. This can be achieved with a small bathroom style exhaust fan ducted to outdoors, however. Turn it on when there's fine dust in the air, or finishing with solvents.

Enjoy the process of building a new shop. Ask lots of questions before you leap.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa