Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Task lighting for detailed work

Posts

Task lighting for detailed work

#1

Task lighting for detailed work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Task lighting for detailed work

My brother-in-law is a lighting engineer and he has provided guidance over the years on lighting my shop. Sometimes I have to see what he is talking about to appreciate his advice. A case in hand.

PIC 1



My bench area is well lit even though I have no natural light in this basement shop. I have 8- T5 high intensity lamps over the bench. The bench surface and ceiling are light colored to reflect light back to the working area. The bench top measures 300 foot candles of illumination. A shady spot on a sunny day is 500 foot candles by comparison and a typical shop may only be 50. I can see even fine detail on the bench in this environment.

PIC 2


However, for sawing dovetails this arrangement is inadequate. I can not see detail on a vertical surface in the vice. It takes a complex arrangement of side spot lights to adequately illuminate scribe lines. The problem is my eye is adjusting to the bright background, rendering the foreground where I need to see dimmed.

PIC 3


The solution is to darken the background, and where possible capture “lost light” and reflect it back to the vice area. I temporarily accomplished this task by hanging a sheet behind the vice and putting a dark towel in front of the work piece.

PIC 4


The result is adequate illumination as well as eye adjustment to see the scribe dovetail lines. (note” these are just example lines for the picture. Note how well the black gel ink shows up on walnut.)

Re: Task lighting for detailed work

#2

Re: Task lighting for detailed work

CJ in MPLS

Bill:

What you are describing is an optimization between brightfield and darkfield illumination. BF illumination is where light moves directly from the source to the object and is reflected directly to your eye (or to a camera's pupil). The surface or field of the object appears to be bright whereas small imperfections and features that scatter or absorb light will appear darker.

DF illumination is the grazing light we are recommended to use to locate small scratches and surface imperfections. When light is incident on the surface of the wood at low angles, most of it is reflected off into the distance. Only light that is scattered from small scratches makes it back to your eye. As a result, you'll see a dark surface or field with small bright spots that are the particles or scratches.

When you darken the background (with the dark towel) and increase the amount of light on on the front surface of the wood with a light cloth, you are increasing the contrast of features of the wood, e.g. your incised scribe lines. Photographers do this kind of thing with their reflective umbrellas and black velvet drapes all the time.

In practice you should do exactly what you've done: move things around until you get the illumination you need to proceed. For most purposes, what you are trying to approximate, to a greater or lesser degree, is a dome illumination scheme in which light of appropriate intensity and wavelength is incident on your work piece from all sides and angles.


Throw in a little low angle grazing light, like the kind you get from a ringlight such as shown below, from time to time and you are golden.


Pendantly yours,

CJ

Re: Task lighting for detailed work

#3

Re: Task lighting for detailed work

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Good info.

I wish I had good lighting in my cold dungeon, er, shop.