Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Jointer vs. Planer

Posts

Jointer vs. Planer

#1

Jointer vs. Planer

Tom Colligan

For 15 plus years I've had an 8" jointer and a 15" planer in my two car garage. I don't think I've used them more than twice in any given year. I'd like to unload one of them and try making do with a hand held planer, perhaps a Makita or Milwaukee.

Does anyone else get by with a hand held planer or are these tools a disappointment?

If you think this is a workable arrangement I'm having trouble visualizing which stationary tool to unload, the planer or the jointer? Your comments would be appreciated and thanks in advance.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#2

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

David Yoho

It doesn't sound like you do much, if any, dimensioning of rough lumber. The frequency you say you use your two machines suggests you either don't work at making much in your workshop (could be related to available time) or you buy your lumber already dressed.

I couldn't begin to think about not having both in my shop as I'm almost always dressing rough lumber for two reasons. First - it's less expensive, and second, I get flat finished stock at whatever my desired thickness is.

All that said, if you mostly work with dressed lumber you might get away with only a jointer. Learn to use a hand plane to dimension your stock when it's necessary.

I just don't believe you'll get satisfactory results using a hand held power planer. Not knowing what type of work you mostly do, it's hard to say. But if you build furniture, where precise dimensions are required, you're better off keeping what you have. Also, if you have a source for rough lumber in your area and realize the savings are worth it, you will have the equipment to properly dress your own finished stock.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#3

Re: Jointer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can dispense with the planer if you work pre-dimensioned (s4s) lumber, but a jointer is, in my view, absolutely necessary for getting hair-line glue joints in panel or multi-board glue-ups. I have a very good saw and blades to match, but, even on its best day, the saw-cut surface on a glue joint can't compare with what the jointer will produce, especially if there's a bit of compression in the board.

I do work rough lumber and have a 13" planer, but since getting a Performax, I rarely pull the planer out of its niche. The sander has served my need to face-joint wider than 6" because I can run rough-faced stock through the sander using sleds and get dead-straight stock with a minimum of wood loss and thickness to .000" of spec.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#4

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Dick Coers

I'm with David. Along with his comments, I can't imagine making quality work with stock that has been dressed by someone else. Once it sits in the rack for a week, it probably moved some. They don't seem to work to the same tolerances I do either.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#5

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

joe mohnike

If you got em, keep em. If you sold either one of them and at a later date decided to purchase another one, it would cost you a lot more than what you sold the old one for. Also the quality may not be as good as what you have now.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#6

Re-posted from Hand Tools *LINK*

Keith Newton

If I had to just go with one tool, I'd go with the Makita 1806 B Power Plane. I've had one since the late seventies, and really like using it. I have a 12" jointer in the shop, but when I go out to work on job sites, this serves as the jointer there. It also sees a lot of use in the shop. I've added some wider jaws to my vice which allows it to be clamped upside down, allowing me to quickly handle smaller parts over it like on a stationary tool. But for larger stock, the wood lays on the benches or horses, while I handle the tool over it.

This tool has a longer infeed bed than all of the smaller 3" tools that I've used, and really provides a wonderful cut with sharp knives. The knives are quick and easy to change, and set perfectly every time.

But I think you still need a planer, but maybe you should downsize to the more portable ones which can store on a shelf under your bench too.


http://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-6-3-4-in-Corded-Planer-1806B/203162062?cm_mmc=Shopping%7cG%7cBase%7cPLA%7cD25T%7cPowerTools&gclid=CIzdqd-zq8ICFQyFaQodTLMA4A&gclsrc=aw.ds

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#7

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Lars Parrington

It's less labor to do the jointing by hand than the thicknessing. Think about which of your tools produces more chips. I use my jointer a lot, but could give it up without too many tears. If I had to give up my planer, I would be a lot less productive.

For edge jointing, a hand plane does a better job of edge jointing than the jointer anyways, and is not all that much more work. For edge glue-ups, I always refine the machine jointed edge with a hand plane.

Also, a hand plane can be used to roughly face joint a piece of lumber before running it through the planer. This is really just taking off the high spots to create a decent reference surface to run against the planer bed. This can be more work than edge jointing but still not too bad.

I just purchased a powered hand planer a few weeks ago (a makita 1900B, 3" cutting width). I'm finding it to be a useful tool for situations where I want to remove a lot of material quickly, such as taking out the majority of the twist/bow/crook in a board before moving onto finer tools. It is not a good tool for fine work. If I planed a surface with it, I would expect to do lots and lots of sanding afterwards.

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

#8

Re: Jointer vs. Planer

Rob Sandow

Ditch them both and replace with a combination machine. I have a 12" Robland that works great and takes up the same space as just one of the discrete machines. I got mine used for $1500 10 or 15 years ago. The best part about it is that the jointer and planer are the same size (12"). An 8" jointer and 15" planer are just a mismatch for dimensioning lumber.