Re: Jointer vs. Planer
Lars Parrington
It's less labor to do the jointing by hand than the thicknessing. Think about which of your tools produces more chips. I use my jointer a lot, but could give it up without too many tears. If I had to give up my planer, I would be a lot less productive.
For edge jointing, a hand plane does a better job of edge jointing than the jointer anyways, and is not all that much more work. For edge glue-ups, I always refine the machine jointed edge with a hand plane.
Also, a hand plane can be used to roughly face joint a piece of lumber before running it through the planer. This is really just taking off the high spots to create a decent reference surface to run against the planer bed. This can be more work than edge jointing but still not too bad.
I just purchased a powered hand planer a few weeks ago (a makita 1900B, 3" cutting width). I'm finding it to be a useful tool for situations where I want to remove a lot of material quickly, such as taking out the majority of the twist/bow/crook in a board before moving onto finer tools. It is not a good tool for fine work. If I planed a surface with it, I would expect to do lots and lots of sanding afterwards.