Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

French Cleat - Design Parameters?

Posts

French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#1

French Cleat - Design Parameters?

William Duffield

When making a French Cleat, for example to hang a tool cabinet or a clamp rack or a plane till on a wall, there are several structural parameters one takes into consideration to make sure it is not overloaded, causing fastener failure and catastrophic collapse. There are some obvious material and technique choices which we can discuss further, if we want, such as how best to fasten the fixed half of the cleat to the wall and the moveable half to the cabinet, but right now I have one question which has been nagging me for quite a while, leading to a case of paralysis by analysis.

When I take the board that will make the cleat to the table saw to rip it in two, the rule of thumb is to set the blade at 45°. Why? Is 45° really optimum? A higher angle (approaching 90°) would reduce the wedging action which puts tension on the fasteners.

Of course, I understand that in locations subject to earthquakes, a lower angle is better, because it may lessen the chance the S-wave will bounce the cabinet off the cleat, but there are other ways to mitigate that failure mode.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#2

Don't forget the metal brackets

Tony-Memphis

Those appear to be vertical. Thinking out loud here, you have the pull action attempting to pull the fastener from the wall and then there is the shear that is trying to break the fastener. With the vertical metal brackets, I would think the pull would be minimized. All of our kitchen cabinets are installed with screws through the backs and hopefully into a stud. When I look at the weight loaded in those things, I cringe, but I've never heard of a failure. I'm curious what it would take to snap a typical #8 screw? Seems like McFeely's used to publish such data. Interesting stuff. I'm an ME but haven't practiced it in many many years, unfortunately.

Tony

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#3

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

Tim Caley

No scientific answer for you, but a question. If you had the angle at 90 degrees, wouldn't you have to worry about the balance of the cabinet/rack and not put too much weight on the outside half?

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#4

I've seen one failure, not a french cleat

Chad Pearson

My mother's over counter cabs fell down. Two 30 inch cabinets screwed together, both of which were filled to capacity. Turns out the entire 60 inch span was held up by a single screw which eventually snapped. All other screws missed their studs.

Its amazing to me that they didn't fall down the first time a single coffee cup was put in the cupboard.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#5

The 45

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

does two things.

1. It operates as the obvious cleat with an equal amount of wood on both sides of the "joint" so the shear-angle stress in equalized.

2. The wedging action tends to pull the case into the wall and use the friction of the case/wall contact points for additional holding ability.

3. The 45° wedge channels the stress on the fasteners (screws) to a point close to the wall surface where they are least likely to bend and most resistant to the shearing force.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#6

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Anybody who says "But that's 3" gets a red flag :D

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#7

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

TomD

One can eliminate the wedging action as far as the cleat on the wall is concerned, by making integral cleats in the thing you are hanging. That way the cleat just bottoms out and the transferred load is in shear. The hung item, I guess is experience a wedging action but it doesn't seem to be materially large. Here you can see my lumber handing from an integral plywood cleat on the bracket, and another cleat (can't see the actually interface) that was just cut into the side of a 2x4.


Another option you might consider is square cleats with biscuits where you want an interface. It has the advantage of not having a big dust collecting gutter on the top; Of getting your forces at 90. If you size it correctly then you can add additional locations whenever you want by indexing the biscuit cutter (or domino) off the wall. With my French cleats, though. I pretty much have something on them along 80+ fee of wall, so I guess one might as well just start out with everything cut to 45 since sooner or later you will want to hang something, and maybe joggle it side to side.

My cleat is held to the wall with the largest flat head screws I could find they are like small lag bolts. There is one every 16 inches. I remember when we pulled out a huge kitchen cabinet, one that was made of heavy pine and had carried a lot of dishes and stuff for decades, it turned out to be held in place by two nails, neither of which was in anything other than the plaster wall. Of course having two adjacent walls to hang it from helped enormously.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#8

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

Barry Irby

Somewhere along the way, long forgotten, It was loaded into my brain that a sixteen penny nail in shear was capable of supporting 100 bounds in shear or withdrawal. 12 penny Cement coated sinkers were roughly equivalent. A deck screw with the same shank diameter would probably have the same strength in shear and better strength in withdrawal. Dry-wall would reduce the shear strength a bit.

If you drive the fasteners into studs securely and use fasteners the diameter and length of 12 penny nails you can probably use 100 pounds as the strength of each fastener.

Glue may improve the performance of either screws or nails substantially.

As the above anecdotes indicate, The 100 pound "rule" may be very conservative.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#9

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

John McGaw

I always just default to 45-degrees and have never had any suggestion of failure. I guess that if the 'wedge' problem was really uppermost in your mind you could eliminate the angle and cut a rebate (or rabbet if you prefer) in each piece of the cleat which would maximize the shear and minimize the tension on the fasteners. The downside of that being that you'd need to be more precise with the dimensions.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The downside to that approach

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One of the beauties of the 45º bevel on the French cleat is that even if there are imperfections in the wall (waviness, for example), the two pieces of the cleat will still engage easily and quickly--no fussing. With a precisely-cut rabbet on both pieces, if the piece on the wall follows some slight curvature, you'll never get that cabinet fully seated.

As to the other concerns, if the cleat on the wall is drawn tight to the wall with the screws, there is a huge amount of friction between the cleat and the wall resisting the shear forces on the screws--they're almost entirely in tension, which is typically how they're strongest.

Jason

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#11

Holy Cow!

Tony-Memphis

One one hand, I'm amazed at the shoddy workmanship, on the other, like you, I'm amazed they stayed up as long as they did! I miss being a "real engineer" and working on figuring stuff like this out. I'm stuck in IT.

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

#12

Re: French Cleat - Design Parameters?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I see no reason to redesign something that really works quite well. I made and installed about 40 ~ 50 running foot of cabinets in my shop using french cleats. I fastened the wall cleats using countersunk 1/4" lag bolts into my 2 X 6 studs. I built the cabinets using 3/4 birch (Borg quality) plywood, and use a dado to install the back so that the cleat ended up flush with the cabinet back. That cleat was glued and screwed to the sides and top of the cabinet. Some of my cabinets have in excess of 300 ~ 400 lbs of tools and haven't shown any sign of a problem in about 9 years.