Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Ebay Issue OT

Posts

Ebay Issue OT

#1

Ebay Issue  OT

TomD

I bought a machine off ebay. I was top bid, the guy held my money for a day. Didn't contact me about anything, then I get this message saying that my money has been refunded. Reason given was out of stock. But that would not apply since the item was unique, not some drop shipped thing. This ended up causing me a lot of costs. I had ordered a motor for it and expensive accessories. I contracted for cross border delivery. A lot of the bad stuff for me about the situation comes from the cross border nature of the deal. That is hardly the sellers fault, though I think that incurring costs around such a purchase would be pretty common.

Oddly, once the sale is overturned, that's it. There is nothing one can do. No resolution center; no ratings; nothing, just as though it had never happened. But should some schmuck not communicate effectively, not ship speedily, then you can hammer him in the ratings. The only thing I have is a reversed sale that is stuck at the top of my list of purchases as an unpaid item.

While this guy cost me money; sold my property for a profit without my knowledge (I suppose); probably wire fraud; etc... I don't intend to do anything about it. There isn't any upside to that, but I just wonder what one could do, or why there isn't any recourse when you can kill someone's business over trivial stuff through adverse comments.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#2

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

Randy Stukenberg

You could try contacting eBay people. Sometimes they can resolve it or contact the seller. If it was a shady seal, they might even drop him. He probably had someone offer him more outside of the sale.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#3

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

Gary Smyth

Contact ebay. Remember though that ebay is seller centered as that is where their money is. Tell them what occurred. They will actually try to resolve the problem. Depending on where the item is located it may not work and for certain you will lose time, but its better than stewing thinking that there was no where to go. If the sale was to China, for example, at least one seller simply refused the sale if the winning bid is less than they think it is worth. Happened twice to me. Ebay dropped them but wouldn't you know it an identical (unique) item item turned up the next week but with a different seller name. Not much I could do, but call ebay's attention to it and learn my lesson. Try ebay and talk with a person. They will at least try to clear away the bad apple, and clear any undeserved negative ebay record, but since the money was returned, the most you can hope for is to be grateful for that. If you used PayPal your money is guaranteed by the way

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#4

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

BrianMonumentCO

If you bought something in anticipation of winning and receiving an item, I would call that premature.

It sounds like you did exactly that.

An alternative way to view what happened is that he listed it on ebay and had it for sale in a shop somewhere. In the days immediately surrounding your auction, it sold in that shop. Out of stock. Effectively you lost the auction. Easiest answer. Nothing criminal, no conspiracy, nothing really wrong..... Not great ethics. But not illegal. Your losses implied, perceived real or imaginary are more or less of your own making.

Sorry to burst your bubble, but that is how I see it. No offense intended.

Same reality readjust that I have had to do in reaction to several gunBroker auctions

that have gone bonkers in similar ways.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#5

Bill Blasic

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

Bill Blasic

Sorry Brian but he won the auction and should reasonably expect to get the item. If he won the item and decided not to pay he would be subject to penalties. The seller in that particular auction should be barred from Ebay. If the person sold it prematurely he should have stopped the auction.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#6

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

TomD

Thanks guys. Brian, you have a point, this is how there are oddball aspects that have to do with the Canadian angle. I couldn't send the item to Canada, because the seller didn't offer that option, and because it would have been hundreds of dollars. So I send stuff like this to Buffalo, and then make a trip there to pick it up (well I did once before, I avoid the border crossing as much as I can these days, too risky). To do that with the xmas rush, I make a number of parallel orders that all hit Buffalo at the same time. And then go down just the once. If it was local or the guy could have sent it direct to me, I would have waited to see. I guess in the future I will wait also, but in my small ebay experience of only about 150 purchases, I had never had this problem. And since I didn't snipe the product at some ridiculously low amount, my auction was 200 above another similar one that sold the week before, and if one does searches on the product most people say they sell for 500 while this one went to 1200, there is increased interest in this item. So I had no reason to believe he would behave this way when he should have been pretty happy with the deal. But I guess if one is unethical, every little bit helps.

The reason I brought up my minor losses is just to point out that while I wouldn't deal with ebay if bad stuff bothered me, I do wonder why there isn't recourse for stuff like this where I am out several hundred, when there is recourse for stuff like the seller wasn't fast in shipping which is really a pretty massive yawn for me. It is also subjective. What is fast? Selling my property though, is pretty black and white. I come from the patient generation. I don't expect fast, or a "good experience"' You can't afford to be too picky if you are from Canada. Ebay, hulu, amazon, etc... are all comparatively crappy "experiences" from here. I just count myself lucky to have any access at all, and I have a US internet friend who aggregates for me at considerable time and expense to him, for which I am also grateful

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#7

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

BrianMonumentCO

Bill, I respectfully disagree. As no money has been permanently taken without product.

In all my well over 500 eBay purchases, I have seen this happen a few times.

On GunBroker also an auction site but for firearms, I have seen this type of thing happen more than a few times.

In my book UNTIL money changes hands it is only a minor foul. I don't consider it to be a breech of contract. It becomes a problem when money changes hands without product. If the money is returned it is simply a minor foul. In my book this example is only a minor foul. It would be nice if there was a rating type entry for this situation but eBay is seller centric and wont hurt their money basket.

In any event since eBay is a seller centric system it is unlikely that any seller in this situation would be barred from eBay. That would be like eBay shooting themselves in the money basket.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#8

Bill Blasic

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

Bill Blasic

Brian I'm over 700 purchases on Ebay and twice someone has tried that. Neither got away with it. Ebay is very good at keeping things on the up and up. If you buy it it is a contract without money being exchanged. I would not let them get away with it.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#9

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

BrianMonumentCO

Bill. Sounds like you have been lucky. But what if the item is nearly one of a kind and the seller actually sold it. What happens then? In any of your two cases did the item not sold actually get shipped to you or did something else happen?

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#10

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

TomD

"Bill, I respectfully disagree. As no money has been permanently taken without product."

Brian, part of my reason for bringing this here, along with knowing one can get some pretty informed discussions on Ebay matters, is precisely because I want to know what the rules are. Normally if you have a contract for sale, which Ebay constantly tells us we do following an auction, and money is received, the product is the buyer's product. My opinion is he took my property, and sold it to someone, then sent me some random amount of money. If this happened with a stock and the stock had gone up, it would be illegal regardless of whether the amount of money returned was equivalent to that received. If this was a male/female 3.5 mm headphone cable, I wouldn't care, there is no particular variability in price day to day, and the market is saturated with other copies. This was a somewhat rare item, and I am guessing the value took a jump the moment that the auction was concluded.

I should restate that while communications was unsatisfactory, and I am certain the guy pulled something on me, I don't know anything for a fact. perhaps he dropped it prior to packaging, and he doesn't have an item to sell. But I don't think that is what happened.

Update is that while this item is still in my unpaid file after cancellation, I was now able to leave feedback, which was negative, though I made no guesses or assumptions about matters I didn't know about. I don't know if ebay will accept the feedback as I wasn't able answer questions like how long it took to ship, whether the shipping was reasonable, and so forth. :)

I have to also guess that ebay was unpaid in this mater, if the guy did a deal outside of ebay.

Re: Ebay Issue OT

#11

Re: Ebay Issue  OT

BrianMonumentCO

I suppose that about now some think, I am on the sellers side.

REALLY, I am not. What he did was wrong. But should he be destined to got to He77 or be banned form selling on eBay... Absolutely NOT. Unless this is the Nth time this has happened. But I also see in both the "buyer" and some other commentors what appears to be bordering on the interest in obtaining a pound of flesh for the infraction.

My views on this issue stem from the believe and view that right, wrong or indifferent, I believe that eBay is more akin to something that is between a hobby and a smaller business more than big business relative to the buyers and sellers not from eBay or PayPals view. That the people who sell and buy are more interested in doing things easily and not getting wrapped around some legal axis.