Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

Posts

jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#1

jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

cameron

I've been using my old Delta 12.5" lunchbox planer for ~14 years now and it looks like it may be at the end of it's life (can't keep the rollers feeding, making terrible noise and now is resulting in noticeable chatter marks across the surface even with new blades, think its just worn out.) I've been eyeing the Grizzly and Powermatic 15" spiral cutter models. The Powermatic 15HH is on sale today for $2600 vs $1695 for the G0453PX, I'm not sure the PM is worth the premium (better cutter head and a better outfeed roller, appears the Grizzly roller is serrated and marks the planed surface)... In poking around I've taken notice of the 12" planer/jointer combo machine with a spiral cutter head: G0634XP for $2350. I already have an 8" jointer but am wondering if this combo machine would be advisable as I do occasionally run into situations where the wider jointer bed would be useful. Are these combo machines a good product (typically I've found combination items to multiple things but poorly...) or is it better to going the dedicated route? Thanks

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#3

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

cameron

Thanks. By the way, don't see too many people named Lars (my son's name...)

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#4

Ellis Walentine

Good choice

Ellis Walentine

I've owned two Inca jointer/planers -- the original 510 and the later 570 models. They are excellent choices in the small (10") category. Hammer, Grizzly, Rikon and others make larger models in wider widths. They vary in their fit, finish and features, but all share the same advantages: They take up less floor space than two dedicated machines; you only need one circuit to run them; your maximum width is the same for both jointer and planer; you can joint wider stock than you can with just a little 6" or 8" jointer; you pay one price for both functions.

The drawbacks are also worth noting. You have to either swing up the tables or otherwise convert the machine from jointing to planing mode, which can be a pain, especially for short runs. Usually, the planer is operating in the 1" to 2" thickness range, and when you need to joint something, you need to back the table all the way down in order to avoid choking it with chips. On some machines, the depth adjustment screw is fine-pitched, and it takes an endless number of turns to run the planer platen up and down. The dust collection fittings can be awkward, too.

Different machines have differing quality pressure bars, different cutterhead speeds and other subtle differences that can really add up. I haven't personally tried very many of the bigger machines, but I wouldn't hesitate to recommend buying one.

Ellis Walentine

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#5

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

Jesse Cloud

I have some anecdotal data. I took a class in woodworking machinery maintenance about a year ago and one of the things we did was to fine tune new machinery that students had just bought. Two combo machines came in: a Grizzly (smaller than the one you are looking at) and a Jet. We spent about 3 hours getting the Grizzly properly aligned. The Jet was dead accurate out of the box.

We ran a few boards through and switched back and forth from jointer to planer. I don't remember the details but I came away thinking that they would be ok for light usage, but I would probably want my dedicated machines back for a big project.

Definitely they save a huge amount of floor space if that is a concern for you.

Also, I wouldn't take my observations too seriously. I touched only one example of each machine. They may or may not have been representative.

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#6

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

John McGaw

I have a Robland combination machine with a 12" jointer/planer. The only complaint I can bring up is that the jointer beds really need to be longer. This would not be very practical given that, with their heavy cast iron construction, the short beds take a bit of effort to flip. I've not found the changeover time to be a serious problem although it does call for some pre-planning which separate machines would not need especially when one is doing edge work where the workpiece needs to be ripped after the first edge is jointed but that is really down to the saw being part of the machine and sharing the other side of the jointer fence..

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#7

other thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know anything about these machines. But if they sacrifice jointer bed length, I would avoid them. With a jointer, buy as much length and width as you can afford.

And, a less obvious consideration. For a jointer preparing edge joints the knives must be sharp to prevent burnishing, ridges, and the like that results from dull knives. When I only used a jointer for edge jointing the knives stayed sharp for years, while the planer dulled in months. For this reason alone I would not consider a combination machine.

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#8

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

TomD

I think the combo machines (no specific knowledge of the ones you are considering), are a valid option. They do certain things better than anything else other than two equally large machines. There are machines out there that cost 20K, and are marvels. The people ponying up for those are not just doing it to save floor space. Every machine you buy has certain limitations.

The short beds are normally not a problem. Most people don't understand how to use jointers. Or if you don't like the way that sounds, you can just take it that there is more than one way, and one of those does not involved many end runs. Other than practical consideration, a 20 ft jointer would be nice some days, but for the same area, I would give up length over width every time.

The advantage to width and over under operation is that it allows one to process full width boards on both machines. The name "jointer", and the narrow long aspect ratio, show where the head is with these machines. The name planer (as in English), and the wider for it's length/same as the planer width, shows where the head is with the euro inspired machines. The fact they often tack on a mortise machine (something I could do without), is further evidence of these machines being made for solid wood makers, not the tacky end of the spectrum. Of course if one could have one of everything, that would be even better.

The other thing you can look at is how the machines work, I actually quite like some of the features on the american style machine; the dado cutter; the ability to cut tenons; the adjustable outfeed. And of course the table length doesn't hurt in operation either. The main advantage to the euro ones has already been described. Used to be they had easier to change blades; and there is the footprint; and there is the usually safer guards and such. But maybe there are some hybrids that include all the better features.

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#9

Re: other thoughts

John McGaw

Or at least buy a machine that has easily replaceable flip/toss blades (or retrofit as I did). The old wide and thick knives on my Robland were great until it came time to remove them and sharpen them and replace them. It took only one cycle of that before I went hunting for replaceable blades.

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#10

replacing blades is just another skill

Dick Coers

that is practiced by a craftsman. I have had no trouble replacing blades, on any machines up to and including my 24" thickness planer. It is an acquired skill, like all the others we gain. I can understand getting inserts if I ran lots of exotics, but since I only used domestic stock, straight blades are just fine with me. I fully expect someone is working on carbide tipped hand plane blades and cabinet scrapers so young woodworkers won't have to sharpen them either. Didn't Stanley try throw away blade inserts on their hand planes in the 60s?

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#11

Re: replacing blades is just another skill

TomD

Yeah, rali has/had them and there are Japanese planes with them, there are chisels I saw once. Sometimes there are reasons like the materials as you mention, possibility of inclusions like nails.

Replacing blades as a skill is usually due to design flaws in the product. They do index off the top even if that have jack screws, but the absence of jack screws was a design flaw in my opinion, though work arounds are pretty easy. There isn't any reason for it to require skill. The problem for me used to be having a job where getting time to go get a blade from an industrial supplier would take a vacation day. If you can't sharpen the blade also, then a system that can use mail order parts and be done by an idiot makes a lot of sense. Same thing with welding. Where I live there are few gas suppliers, for a region that is heavily populated, and there aren't any retail gas suppliers. While in BC, there is one retail supplier that will fill your bottle while you wait, with evening hours. Junk like that can have a major impact.

Re: jointer/planer combo or dedicated planer

#12

Re: Well, I kind of disagree!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I designed and debugged hundreds of automated machines in my job as an Engineer for about 40 years. I have several precision instruments and tools in my shop. I am somewhat anal about precision setting of my equipment alignment and do have the equipment and experience to set joiner blades to within .0005". But it did take me quite a bit of time as the blades shifted when tightening. I now have carbide inserted spiral type heads on both my joiner (Grizzly) and planer (Byrd). There are many benefits to these besides the almost foolproof setting. I have ran domestic hardwoods like locust and figured maple that would always have some tear out, even when I wet the surface and took very light cuts with new sharp straight blades. With the carbide spiral style I never have that issue. I have yet to have a surface that is not clear with one sanding with 100 grit paper. The carbide inserts stay sharp 4 to 5 times longer than my "straight" blades. Then I rotate them and they have a brand new surface, The actual life with the 4 surfaces totals 16 to 20 times more life than the old blades. Another advantage is that if you do "chip" a blade when you hit a foreign object, you just rotate or replace 2 to 4 inserts instead of replacing or sharpening the entire set of straight blades.

I would never go back to the old blades. I have never heard anyone that has used them say they were not fully satisfied with the spiral head nor anyone that would not buy them again. You really don't know what you are missing!