Chisel Steel Theory
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What I will report is based on studying edge failure/dulling of several chisel steels under high magnification with a metallurgical microscope. Some disagree and I invite them to provide data to support their theories.
Background: Steel has three main properties- hardness, abrasion resistance and toughness. Hardness as measured by Rockwell indentation predicts the steel's resistance to bending. Toughness predicts whether the steel will fracture when stressed (bent) or resist fracture and chipping, like when chopping dovetails. Abrasion resistance, often incorrectly confused with "hardness", is the steel's resistance to abrasion. Abrasion resistance is largely determined by the amount and type of carbides formed by the alloying constituents during heat treatment.
Chisels fail/dull in use either by microchipping or edge deformation (bending/folding). Unlike plane blades that plow through hundreds of linear feet of wood, chisels are rarely if ever are exposed to enough abrasion to get dull by metal loss. Hence, one wants a chisel steel that has both high hardness and high toughness. Abrasion resistance is largely irrelevant.
In general as steel is made harder it gets less tough. By picking an optimum steel composition the steel can be hardened to a high degree during heat treatment while preserving its toughness. Hence, a good chisel combines optimum steel composition and heat treatment.
PMV11 chisels are exceptionally hard (Rc over 60) and they resist edge deformation better than any I have used. Japanese chisels, legendary for their performance, are similarly hard. Yet they are also exceptionally tough and resist microchipping. One can conclude that the composition and heat treatment were optimally chosen. The PMV11 metal is expensive to fabricate into a chisel of conventional shape and the price reflects this fact.
PMV11 is closely related in composition to the 440 stainless steels and in fact it may(speculative "may") be considered part of this family of cutlery steel. However, note that the PMV11 chisels are hardness over 60 while the Perfect Pattern are in the range of Rc 56 to 59. While 56 might be dandy for a knife I predict that the edge of a chisel hardened to Rc56 will deform unacceptably when used for chopping dovetails. Disclaimer- I have not used this chisel. I nearly ordered one to test my assumption, but they only come as a set and my curiosity was not worth $75.
I don't know if 440 C, or one of the other variants used for knives, can be hardened enough without loosing toughness to make it a good chisel. If I was still making chisels it would be a test I would do.
From this discussion you can see that the name of the steel by itself does not predict performance. Manufacturing details and heat treatment play an important role.