Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

Posts

How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#1

How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

Tom Colligan

That is, can it be sharpened to take and hold an edge as well as the more common steels for edge tools?

Lee Valley offers the Perfect-Pattern chisels, 09A02.25, that are made of 440 SS and I wonder if this could be a disappointment in their sharpening and holding of an edge.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#2

Lee Valley PMV11 is a stainless steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does that answer your question? Some of the best knife steels are stainless steel. But, beyond composition there is the heat treating. If not done optimally for a chisel even the best steel will suck as a chisel.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#3

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

Terry in Edmonton

PMV11 holds an edge very well. I bought the low angle blade for my block plane and I don't know if it is sharper than the carbon steel blade I had in it but it holds it's edge far better. It seems to be easier to sharpen than other SS blades as well.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#4

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 is not a stainless steel

TomD

Stainless isn't a destination it is a range. Until they start using it in dive knives, and maybe they do, I would wonder how stainless PM_V!!it is. The literature does not seem to make much of the fact, though they are pretty proud of the stainless ferules on the chisels.

Rob Lee has said iPM_V11 is almost as stainless as stainless, while noting this is a surprise (something that D2 is also noted for, to some degree). But the clear implication is that it does not fall into the category of steels called stainless, maybe due to some chromium level. So while it may prove that stain resistance is not always inversely proportional to tooliness, it doesn't really tell us anything about 440 series steels per se. Or any actual stainless.

A lot of high end cutlery is made with stainless, though this is generally regarded as a poor choice were performance other than stain resistance is the main parameter. Most high performance steels used in knives are not classic stainless steels like 440 or 154 cm, etc... But as with our game some of the attitude have to do with prejudices. Stainless steels are often very poor sharpeners and edge holder, and developed a reputation for poor performance, and difficulty in sharpening. This has let various myths persist about SS. And of course, like plywood which in certain applications is far superior to solid wood, Stainless has some workablilty and aesthetic limitations.

In general SSs are weak. But there are super stainless steel used in knives, and gun barrels, and bicycle frames, etc... that are very remarkable steels, though normally very expensive. 440 steels can offer pretty goof edge holding and sharpening. Performance comes down to objectives and QC at the factory.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#5

Chisel Steel Theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What I will report is based on studying edge failure/dulling of several chisel steels under high magnification with a metallurgical microscope. Some disagree and I invite them to provide data to support their theories.

Background: Steel has three main properties- hardness, abrasion resistance and toughness. Hardness as measured by Rockwell indentation predicts the steel's resistance to bending. Toughness predicts whether the steel will fracture when stressed (bent) or resist fracture and chipping, like when chopping dovetails. Abrasion resistance, often incorrectly confused with "hardness", is the steel's resistance to abrasion. Abrasion resistance is largely determined by the amount and type of carbides formed by the alloying constituents during heat treatment.

Chisels fail/dull in use either by microchipping or edge deformation (bending/folding). Unlike plane blades that plow through hundreds of linear feet of wood, chisels are rarely if ever are exposed to enough abrasion to get dull by metal loss. Hence, one wants a chisel steel that has both high hardness and high toughness. Abrasion resistance is largely irrelevant.

In general as steel is made harder it gets less tough. By picking an optimum steel composition the steel can be hardened to a high degree during heat treatment while preserving its toughness. Hence, a good chisel combines optimum steel composition and heat treatment.

PMV11 chisels are exceptionally hard (Rc over 60) and they resist edge deformation better than any I have used. Japanese chisels, legendary for their performance, are similarly hard. Yet they are also exceptionally tough and resist microchipping. One can conclude that the composition and heat treatment were optimally chosen. The PMV11 metal is expensive to fabricate into a chisel of conventional shape and the price reflects this fact.

PMV11 is closely related in composition to the 440 stainless steels and in fact it may(speculative "may") be considered part of this family of cutlery steel. However, note that the PMV11 chisels are hardness over 60 while the Perfect Pattern are in the range of Rc 56 to 59. While 56 might be dandy for a knife I predict that the edge of a chisel hardened to Rc56 will deform unacceptably when used for chopping dovetails. Disclaimer- I have not used this chisel. I nearly ordered one to test my assumption, but they only come as a set and my curiosity was not worth $75.

I don't know if 440 C, or one of the other variants used for knives, can be hardened enough without loosing toughness to make it a good chisel. If I was still making chisels it would be a test I would do.

From this discussion you can see that the name of the steel by itself does not predict performance. Manufacturing details and heat treatment play an important role.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#6

What makes stainless steel "stainless steel"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At least in the metallurgical world whether a steel can be categorized as "stainless" is determined by composition, not by whether it can be used in dive knives. For example the corrosion resistance of the 300 series of stainless steels is greater than the 400 series, and 316 more corrosion resistant than 304 (in some applications) yet their chromium content makes then all "stainless steel". If you have determined the composition of a steel you are them on a technically firm footing to refer to it by its technically correct name.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#7

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 is not a stainless steel

Rum

Stainless steel is definitionally steel with a minimum of 10.5% chromium content by mass. Obviously there are other factors that can reduce the corrosion resistance of steel so that hardly tells the whole story.

You would have to admit that the metallurgy of a powder deposition product like PMV11 separates it fairly far from a stock stainless like 440 (A/B/C) though and comparing the two isn't really a fair comparison. I have no idea what the composition of PMV11 actually is (since LV holds that fairly close as a trade secret) but it does seem like a bit of a wonder metal (a lot of the new metallurgy strikes me in a similar "wow magic" fashion though :D).

I do wish it was stated if they were 440A, 440B or 440C. If they're the latter its certainly steel that would work well enough. 440A/B would be "ok" but imho would be a bit on the soft side (C has more carbon than A/B). Any of the 440 steels will have more "hardness" than traditional 1000 series carbon but won't be as "tough". That is they should have more abrasion resistance but would be somewhat more apt to chip if abused (all other things being equal which they rarely are). The 440 series will also be a bit more "gummy" when sharpening than a high carbon steel (that is it would moderately clog up a stone slightly faster) and may be somewhat harder to sharpen on oil stones due to the higher abrasion resistance. I also wouldn't expect it to take quite as keen of an edge, whether it would be enough difference to matter is highly debatable (I might argue probably on 440A, no on 440C and maybe on 440B).

A somewhat reasonable overview of some of the more common steels can be found here: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/368828-Steel-FAQ

These are all marginal differences and a lot of other factors (like how the steel was treated, chisel is shape, etc..) are more apt to have a larger impact. You can certainly find chisels with any steel that are stinkers and buying a set from a good company like LV lowers your risk substantially.

Your risk in any case is relatively low because if you really really hate them LV will take returns. They have some of the best customer service in the industry and I can unequivocally say that my dealings with them have been 100% positive.

Finally those are really pretty chisels as well so there is at least the aesthetics side taken care of (whether you like the design or prefer other types aside .. they are pretty!).

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#8

Thanks To All


Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#9

Re: Your making my point, which I appreciate.

TomD

I agree. as far as I know we 1) don't know the composition of PM-V11, is it still a trade secret?; 2) but according to Rob it isn't stainless. So for this example it's edge holding is not a transferable data point to a question about stainless.

Here is Rob's quote from Canadianwoodworking:

"Now, this steel holds an edge like none other I've used, which is great...but the really cool (unexpected) part is that according to the laws of metalurgy, this steel should not be rust resistant at all.....but for some reason it is almost rust resistant as stainless....stuff like that."

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#10

Re:420

TomD

I don't know what the stainless is in those chisels. I have the belt axe, and it is 440c, OK edge holding, could have been designed to keep open file sharpening.

There was a year, around 2005, when a lot of the makers jumped ship on 440c to 420. There were rumours it had to do with availability, but that sounds a lot like an pretext. Whatever the reason, there was some heat over it, but it seemed to be the case that heat treating could make it indistinguishable from 440c for the most part.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#11

you are making an assumption

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are assuming I don't know the composition. You may think determining it would be difficult.

There are many ways to analyze steel for its constituents. By far the easiest, if one has this common capability, is X-ray Fluorescence (XRF for short). The sample is irradiated with high energy X-rays which blast inner shell electrons out of the atoms that are in the steel sample. When the electrons in this atom rearrange an x-ray photon is given off. The energy of this photon is characteristic of the element and the number of these photons is proportional to the concentration of this element in the steel. X-ray fluorescence spectrometers are built to provide the exciting X-ray beam, and then measure the energy and number of emitted photons. An on-board microprocessor does the calculations. It takes about a minute to do the analysis on a flat surface of the steel sample. The method does rely on calibration but one can presume calibration is sound if several sources come up with the same result.

Carbon analysis requires a different method. In this case the sample is burned and the amount of CO2 generated is measured. Again the analysis is trivial for a lab equipped to do steel analysis, but in this case the analysis is destructive.

The miniaturization of electronics and the computing power of microprocessors enables inexpensive instruments to be made that are even portable. These instruments are common for sorting and identifying steel, providing customer service in identifying competitive steel and a host of other applications. Any supplier of steel,large users of steel or a customer service lab of a steel manufacturer has this capability, as well as other sources.

It is not difficult for even a somewhat curious person or motivated company to determine composition when you know where to look and ask, and from composition other information.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#12

Re: discouraging review

Rum

One vaguely useful review I could find (that wasn't just "oooh so pretty" without any useful usage data) wasn't encouraging and basically echo's Bills response.

Disclaimer I don't know this person at all, was just curious if anyone anywhere had actually bought these things and USED them so did some web searching:

http://sswantee.wordpress.com/category/all-categories/chisels/

Which is to bad.. because oooh shiny!!

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#13

Thank you

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I appreciate obtaining data relevant to my chisel steel theories. The review supports the hypothesis that a good chisel for chopping dovetails needs to have high hardness, probably 60 or greater.

I suspect the PMV11 does so well because a steel was chosen that retains toughness to prevent chipping at high hardness. But to make them pretty required milling the shapes from thick bar stock, a process which is expensive.

Chisels are cheap and easy to make if you are not wedded to pretty. They can be sawed from flat bar stock, ground and filed to shape and sent off for heat treatment. It makes it practical to have many sizes without breaking the bank. Son-in-law and I recently completed a somewhat complex coffee table. We used most of the chisel sizes I made, about 5 sizes 1/4 to 1".

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#14

Re: discouraging review

William Duffield

The "Ooh, Purdy" perfect handle imitation is another three strikes against them. It's not as nice looking as a real perfect handle, but the real problem is that your wooden carving mallet strikes steel instead of wood, damaging the mallet. Also, wood against steel transfers more shock to your hand and wrist than wood against wood, leading to increased musculoskeletal injuries.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#15

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

John Lucas

I'm on my cell and can't type long messages. Can't answer all your questions pm11 isn't a secret. It's been around a while as we as pm 15. It has 11 percent vanadium which is what gives it the toughness. It is powdered metal that is pressed into shape and then goes through a sintering process to melt it into a solid tool or gear etc. the pwdered metal allows them to change the composition to better fit the needs of that too or gear. Etc.

You can only get 4 percent vanadium in melted steel. I would have to look it up but I don't think there is any chromium in it so by pure definition it is t stainless.

Can't answer your question a out making a chisel but I made 3 toe resembling a chisel. One high car on steel one high speed steel and one was v11. The test was to see if one could be sharpened better than another. All 3 sharpened at a 25 degree angle. Sharpened to 1500 grit sandpaper and then honed with green stick. I could not tell the deference in the edge. I e sent them off to a custom sharpening we I e to hopefully get a better edge. Then I will have them photographed to see if visually we can see any difference.

I'm a turner and intend to test them as a skew but can't really come up with a good test for edge holding. All would be too subjective.

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#16

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

John Lucas

I meant to add that we have been using V11 turning tools for over 10 years now. They take a lot of abuse. Probably more than a hand held chisel. I don't know of any turning tools made from stainless steel. A lot of knives are made of stainless. Not sure exactly why. Knives are hardened differ enh because ideally you can be d them without breaking. And possibly a carry over from skinning knives which must take the abuse the liquids in skinning

Re: How Is Stainless Steel For An Edge Tool

#17

You are confused.  Lee Valley PMV11 is not V11

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Lee Valley steel is not what is know in the trade as V11, a highly abrason resistant alloy due to a high vanadium content. If the Lee Valley steel had even 3% vandadium many would not be able to sharpen it. It is a high chrome steel that may have a bit of vanadium but not enough to make much vanadium carbide, one of, if the the most, abrasion resistant of the alloying carbides.