Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Did I learn incorrectly?

Posts

Did I learn incorrectly?

#1

Did I learn incorrectly?

Gary Smyth

This week I bought two pillow blocks and two shaft bearings for a 5/8" shaft. The shaft is .625. The pillow blocks however are .621 and .616 respectively. The shaft bearings are .623 and .621. I thought that shaft bearings were typically oversize by a couple of thousands in order that the shaft fit snuggly into them. Did I learn incorrectly? I don't have a metal lathe to turn down the shaft (15" long), but I can chuck it into a drill press and let a file remove a bit so that it fits into the pillow blocks , but is there a better way?

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#2

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

Ron in Sterling, CT

Gary,

You did not learn wrong. What brand of bearings are theses? Normally a pillow block bearing meant for a 5/8 shaft will be a slip fit, and then is locked to the shaft with either a set screw, or a cam locking collar. All of the bearings you have are meant for a press fit (a bit heavy I might add) on a 5/8 shaft.

Ron

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#3

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

Dick Coers

The first search I used said the id should be +.0000 to -.001 depending on the class of bearing. So even to tolerace, your shaft could be a light press. Depending on the rpm, filing it to size on a drill press might be trouble. I would either take it to a machine shop with a center less grinder, or shop for a new shaft. If the shaft has a keyway, it would have me shopping for better bearings.

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#4

Ream the pillow blocks and get new bearings.

Ray - Middletown, IN

Ream them to .626 (oversize reamer) and get some shaft bearings the right size. Don't know your application but if you make a shaft of an odd size nothing else will fit right either, best to make the bearings correct.

Ray

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#5

That could be a tough job Ray

Dick Coers

Pretty sure all bearing races are hardened, but I don't know how deep or how hard. I do know they are hard enough to shatter if you hit them with a hammer. If it's harder than the reamer, it's a no go. And then it would be the challenge of gripping the inner race well enough to even try to ream or grind it bigger.

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#6

Re: That could be a tough job Ray

Ray - Middletown, IN

Bearing races are hard but the pillow blocks are probably soft. Replace the bearings and ream the blocks. Hit them with a file to find out.

Ray

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#7

Also

Ray - Middletown, IN

In the pic the pillow blocks have set screws which means they are probably soft. That also means they are sticking out far enough to lock them down.

Ray

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#8

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

TomD

Yeah, it should be a very tight fit, not even 1 thou over, but under, not the spread you have either. A 1 thou loose fit is what you might want at that size to have clearance for free motion, like for a pin.

The correct way would be to fit an interference fit and then press them in a press. Of course that assumes you want zero play, or need it for the accuracy of what you are making. I wouldn't attempt a reamer, between the fixture I imagine, and the fact the 1 thou over reamers are sometimes extremely expensive would deter me. I think you can get them at a reasonable price at victornet though.

http://www.victornet.com/subdepartments/Chucking-Reamers-.376-to-1-1/2/1782.html

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#9

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

TomD

I took on a number of metal projects when I started, thinking I could just fire the parts together. The one inch tube would sleeve inside the 1.5 inch tube with the 1/4" walls, no problem. And I was angry when I found it wouldn't work. On due reflection, if they made the stuff like that, it would be very awkward for the general population of users that is able to machine to fits. They need the tolerances to fit their parts.

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#10

I see what you are saying now.

Dick Coers

You're talking about reaming the locking sleeve. I was assuming you were talking about the inner bearing race, sorry.

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#11

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

Keith Newton

I thought those were "Flange mount" rather than pillow block, which bolt down on a surface parallel to the shaft.

I don't think you will get very good results using a file and drill press, but if you have one that will chuck 5/8" yours is probably sturdier than mine.

It would be nice to know what you are trying to make with these parts.

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

#12

Re: Did I learn incorrectly?

Gary Smyth

Just a shortshaft that forms an axle. Flange mount is correct. I did solve the problem by buying a 5/8" drill blank. Serves my purpose just as well and it fit with minor tweaking. I suspect I may have tilted the calipers when measuring earlier.