I'm am making 1.75" thick white oak sliding carriage house doors from my shop/garage. I have all the M&Ts completed on the frames (heavy) and the panels (flat) are ready to be sized. I typically work on smaller scale furniture in which I have 1/4" panel groves and leave 1/8" for expansion. These doors have 1/2" wide x 1/2" deep groves for the panels which will have faces that are 10.25" x 60". Can anyone offer advice on how much room I should leave for expansion? I was planning on 1/4" all around... Thanks
You did not ask, but have you thought about the weather exposure on these doors? Do they get any rain? Or are they protected by a wide over hang? Are they facing out of the prevailing wind? If the bottom of the panel will sit in a groove, it is subject to filling up with water. There are strategies for dealing with it, but it is the cause of many a failure.
I would finish the panels and the frames before they are assembled, at the least.
1. They will be under a ~2' soffit, facing south (most of our weather comes from the NW. I'd expect mostly splash water (there is a gutter but it has some drips) but some rain/snow is certainly going to hit them (in WV).
2. Finish I was planning to use is spar varnish and I was going to hit the panels prior to assembly
3. I plan on hitting the tops of the rails with a mild chamfer for water run off and planed on drilling 2 holes at the bottom of each grove on the inside face of the doors for drainage. Now that I think about it I wonder if I should put some varnish inside the grove... might present fit issues.
Rot won't be your main concern but lack of finish durability will be. Southern exposure will disintegrate the ordinary spar varnish is 2-3 years. Suggest finding a boat supply store, for example Jamestown Distributors, and get one of their marine finishes. It will be dark, and expensive, but it will last in the sun.
Two foot over hang should be good, at least better than less. If it is the eave fo the roof I strongly suggest a gutter, as much as I hate gutters, they still help with the splash.
I was thinking that I would chamfer the out side of the bottom groove to drain the water away from the groove and panel. I would set the panel on some sort of impervious small blocks in the groove and drill the drain holes you are planning. That would leave a little air space under the panels for drainage.
As an alternative, I might consider gluing the bottom edge only and sealing it thoroughly to keep water out and let the float occur at the top.
Besides pre finishing the parts ahead of assembly, I would even go a step further by using CPES on the end grain before switching to the varnish. It really soaks up into the wood and saturates the cells before setting up, whereas most finishing products are designed to set up on top. As much time and expense as I suspect your will have in these doors, I'm sure you don't want to ever have an ongoing headache.
Your estimate for movement is about right, 1/8" for QS going from 6 to 12% MC change, and twice that for plain sawn, which is a lot to have to deal with.
Besides the pre-finishing, I would suggest that you do a secondary step in the slot for a thick caulking bead. You just can't expect a thin bead to move as much as your panels will need. Using a rubber band analogy, you can stretch one down it's length, but when it comes to across the band, there isn't much, so in the real world of harsh conditions of your doors, caulking in a tight corner will tear apart pretty soon.
It has been a while since I have done any boat work, but I think the longest lasting finish was a fairly opaque finish call Cetol or something like that. And If you think you might like that option, this project might be a lot less hassle free if you used Extira for the panels, which you could do some faux-graining on. It could be cut without much expected movement.
While we tend to think that the Summer Sun is a lot harsher than in Winter, at your latitude, that Southern exposure is going to be hitting pretty high up, and unless you have some big evergreens shading them, it will add up over time.
What if you were to "fake" the bottom groove so that the panel is only trapped on the sides and top? Then you could cut a groove in the bottom edge of the panel and wedge in a piece of backing rod that would protrude slightly and compress against the rail it's sitting on. You could then use a clear elastomeric caulk along the outside. Ideally, the rail would also have a 15º or so outward slope to it.
As a painter, I get a lot of time to contemplate how exterior watershed details could be improved. That's if any are even used...