Can you tell visually is Seal Coat has gone bad? I used some to seal the top of an old wood filing cabinet and it seemed to be a bit soft after a day. If I can't use it, what's the best way to dispose of or recycle it? I've got probably 3/4 full can. I'd prefer to keep it out of the landfill.
If it hasn't hardened in a day, it's over the hill and should be discarded. Unlike most other finishing products, shellac is environmentally friendly. Is should be O.K in your land fill. The solvent is alcohol which will quickly dissipate, and the shellac is a natural substance which is used in many food products. Even so, most land fill operators will still have some hesitation about allowing you do simply dump it. The textbook way to dispose of it is to pour it out in an wide, shallow container and let it cure (i.e., allow the solvent to gas off). Once it's cured, you can toss it into the trash. That process may be a little challenging with the quantity you have.
Check with your county waste management department. They may have hazardous waste recycling events every so often. If you live near Rockford, you can take it to the Rock River Water Reclamation District on Saturday mornings. They will take almost anything except ag chemicals for no charge.
I have a friend that had worked for a hazardous waste disposal company, that said lots of stuff, they would just mix into a box of shavings or saw dust until it was all absorbed. Then they let it set out for the volatiles to dry. After that, it could go in the land-fill.
Of course, anything that might subject to spontaneous combusting, ought to be set out away from anything that it could spread into.
Also, keep in mind that alcohol vapors are heavier than air, so don't leave it anywhere that those vapors might find their way in to the pilot light of your furnace, or water heater. Air compressor pressure switches also produce a spark, so out in the driveway, so long as it slopes away from your door.
If you want to test any shellac before committing to putting it on a project, pour a small blob on a sheet of glass; wait 24 hours, and try to ding it with a fingernail. If you can dent it at all, it's not useful as a finish.
IIRC, Seal Coat is not denatured with methanol, so, other than the flammability danger in an enclosed space that Keith warns you of, it probably won't cause much more than gastric distress and a very minor uptick in global warming. While I'm not advocating pouring it on your breakfast cereal, it's not really very hazardous. Leave the can open in a well ventilated area until it has hardened, and just throw it in the trash. Alternately, I would just spread it out onto my compost pile, and recycle the can. The VOCs that come off a quart of Seal Coat aren't as potent as what comes off a half acre of grass clippings.
With shellac, most finishers will just brush on a coat to a piece of scrap wood. Let it dry. If it is tack free in 12 to 24 hours, it's OK to use. The blob on glass will work too.
As far as disposal, I just put some sawdust/shavings or kitty litter in a cardboard box. Then I pour the shellac into the box and spread it around. When hardened, I put the box in the normal garbage.
As said, shellac is not harmful to the environment. For that matter, no finish sold in the US since the mid-1970's is harmful to the environment as long as it is fully dried.