Waterlox vs other brands
Randy Stukenberg
Is there much difference between Waterlox tung oil finish and other brands of tung oil finishes? Waterlox is getting hard to find in my area.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Waterlox vs other brands
Randy Stukenberg
Is there much difference between Waterlox tung oil finish and other brands of tung oil finishes? Waterlox is getting hard to find in my area.
Re: Waterlox vs other brands
Ellis Walentine
The short answer is no, though the original Waterlox has distinctive handling and color properties that I like a lot, likely having to do with the proportions of solids and driers in it. Lately, I've been using General Finishes Seal-A-Cel finish, which is paler than Waterlox but has a lot of the same handling and finishing properties. It's also cheaper. If you want a wiping varnish, try thinning some regular varnish. It might take some getting used to, but you can get by with it.
My 2¢,
Ellis
Love the stuff
David Yoho
I'm a huge fan of the Waterlox original formula in medium sheen. Although it's been my favorite finish for a long time, a few years ago I tried General Finishes Arm-R-Seal on a project and liked it. The advantages I find with the Arm-R-Seal are that it's less expensive and the odor afterward disperses much sooner than with the Waterlox. I didn't have to change my application method at all and the results are almost as good, in my opinion.
There are things I will build that I will only use Waterlox on, while the rest get the Arm-R-Seal. Both look great.
Re: Waterlox vs other brands
Randy Stukenberg
Thanks Ellis! I used Waterlox on some counter tops so I want to stick with that type of finish to recoat them. Does the General Finishes get as hard and water resistant as Waterlox claims? Is it mostly the tung oil that privides toughness, or is it other additives? I really like the Waterlox and used it on my floors and cabinets, plus a few other projects, but it is hard to find in stores around here.
Re: Waterlox vs other brands
David Yoho
If anything, the tung oil makes the varnish softer than a pure polyurethane varnish. It's got more "give" than a hard curing one.
Re: Waterlox vs other brands
William Duffield
There is no polyurethane in the original WaterLox finish. WaterLox is not tung oil, per se. The alkyd resins that provide its advantages are modified from tung oil.
Another alkyd varnish you might find to have properties more to your liking than polyurinate is Pratt and Lambert 38.
Where is "around here?" Your approximate location might help us find you a source nearby.
Didn't say that
David Yoho
There is no polyurethane in the original WaterLox finish.
I didn't say there was. My point was the oil makes the varnish softer.
some chemistry and a question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Indeed the function of the "oil" component is to make the hard resin component more tough and flexible and maybe in this case brushable. Waterlox, according to the MSDS, is a phenolic resin (hard), some ester thing I never heard of , Tung oil and Mineral Spirits solvent ( and a sturdy dose of catalyst "drier". It may be that the Tung oil is more for marketing than function. No percentages are given.
Does anyone know where one can buy the Pratt and Lambert varnish? It keeps being recommended as a traditional varnish. I would like to try it but have never seen it for sale anywhere.
Re: Pratt & Lambert - Where to buy *LINK*
Pratt & Lambert Store Locator
phenolic not alkyd resin
Rum
Minor correction, Waterlox uses a phenolic not an alkyd resin (from their docs "tung oil coreacted with a phenolic resin"). Nominally it's claimed to be somewhat more flexible than the alkyd resin products, how much that's true I believe depends largely on the specific formulation. Before they changed the formula the old Behlens rock hard (which I ?think? was alkyd?) would take a higher shine and seemed harder, haven't tried the new stuff. Remember that the original waterlox was designed as a floor finish, so some flexibility in the film was desirable.
Whatever you choose test it carefully to make sure it will burn in and bond well with the waterlox, since some of the products don't.
"Around Here" is...
Randy Stukenberg
Rockford, IL area. None of the stores in town carry Waterlox. Our local True Value used to, but they are closing. There is a Rockler store in the Chicago area that carries it, but that is 1 1/2 hr drive if I can find the time to go. Trying to avoid shipping in the cold weather if I can,
Thanks for all the good advice!
Re: phenolic not alkyd resin
Howard Acheson
If you read the info on the Watelox site, you will see that their product is an oil based varnish. It's not an oil/varnish mixture like Minwax and other Tung Oil finishes. As they state, it's a true varnish made using tung oil.
Varnish consists of a resin and a drying oil. The two are mixed and heated until they combine into an new compound called varnish. A thinner is then added to make is easier to apply. Some manufacturers will add some other chemicals to speed up the curing or to accomplish other items. In the case of Waterlox, the resin is phenolic which is a hard resin. The drying oil is tung oil which improves the water vapor resistance of the resulting varnish. The ratio of resin to oil determines the hardness of the finish. More oil equals more flexible and softer finish. Tung oil is the most often used drying oil in marine finishes because of it slightly more water resistance and flexibility compared to linseed oil.
Oil/varnish mixtures (Tung Oil Finish) are a different product. They are made by adding oil to an existing varnish. It's not nearly as water resistant or durable as a true varnish.
All that said, Waterlox Original is a very good varnish. Because it is made with phenolic resin, it is quite dark and amber. I would rarely use it on a light colored wood because of its dark color. But, it certainly looks good on dark colored woods.
The original comes in three different versions. One is a gloss (used to be called "Gym Floor Finish"), the second is a non-gloss version which is very flat and the most versatile version is called Sealer/Finish. The last is thinner than the gloss and non-gloss and can be used as a wiping varnish right out of the can. The intent is that the Sealer/Finish be used as an initial coat primer followed by either the gloss or the non-gloss but most use the Sealer/Finish as a stand-alone finish.
Re: phenolic not alkyd resin
Rum
Small side note on the water resistant character, I can vouch that it's quite good indeed. About three years ago I made some taster trays for a buddies brewpub and finished them with waterlox (three coats brushed on and buffed out after curing for a couple weeks). These are worked hard and put away wet all day, every day especially in the summer. Lots of beer spilled on them and then immersion washed in hot water and rinsed with a hot sterilant solution multiple times a day, left upside down to drip dry. I can't claim they look brand new anymore but darn close (and of you hadn't seen them when new you might be fooled). About the worse abuse you could subject a piece of wood to next to maybe a high traffic wet hall entry floor.
there is a thrid compenent
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
" In the case of Waterlox, the resin is phenolic which is a hard resin. The drying oil is tung oil "
Additionally the MSDS lists "Ester Gum" as the 3rd film forming constituent. I have no idea what ester gum actually is. It could just be heated linseed or soy oil. Tung, linseed and soy are all esters that can be made gummy, and some are a lot cheaper than Tung oil.
Why?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"Trying to avoid shipping in the cold weather if I can," ? I can understand trying to avoid shipping costs but it matters not when it is shipped.
Re: there is a thrid compenent
Rum
Google searching the CAS number gives it as a "Rosin glycerol ester" which is apparently used to help keep oils in suspension.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycerol_ester_of_wood_rosin
http://www.fao.org/ag/agn/jecfa-additives/specs/Monograph1/Additive-213.pdf
Without being able to determine the actual formulation, I'm going to hazard a guess that its a fairly low % component with a somewhat specific purpose of holding the components in suspension together.
Looking up the CAS number for the phenolic resin is also somewhat interesting:
"FORMALDEHYDE, POLYMER WITH 4-(1,1-DIMETHYLETHYL)PHENOL AND 4,4-(1-METHYLETHYLIDENE)BISPHENOL"
So it wouldn't be great for direct food contact because of the bisphenol (which mimics some female hormones and has been subject to a lot of negative press) and some of the complaints about the smell are probably at least partially from the formaldehyde while it cures/off gasses.
Its also a similar formulation to a lot of epoxies. As with them one of the bigger risks appears to be long term exposure can cause sensitization and contact dermatitis (possibly also from the fumes if sufficiently exposed).
Health canada's rating of it (the only useful one I could find) is as follows:
Component Name Value
Bioaccumulative No
Human Health Priorities Moderate
Inherently Toxic to Aquatic Organisms Yes
Meets CEPA Categorization Criteria Yes
Meets Environmental Criteria for Categorization Yes
Meets Human Health Criteria Yes
Persistent Yes
Substance category Polymers
Re: Why?
Randy Stukenberg
I don't have all the UPS drivers trained yet to deliver to my shop in back of my house, so packages sometimes end up sitting on the house porch most of the day before I know they are there. Not a problem for most things, but can be a problem for finishes, especially if they are water-based. Probably not much, but why take any chances when it is -20° outside?
Why some finishes don't like freerzing
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Finishes that are latexes, which includes probably all the water based finishes(and much glue), are a suspension of solvent swollen mushy polymer balls in water. A delicate balance of surfactants and the like keeps the balls suspended. Freezing temperatures freezes the water. Freezing breaks both emulsions and latexes and the balls come crashing out of suspension, usually irreversibly.
In solvent based finishes the film forming polymer is dissolved in the solvent. Even ND cold temperatures won't freeze the solvent, and hence, there is not separation of the film former and the liquid.