Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

ot- sink disposer

Posts

ot- sink disposer

#1

ot- sink disposer

Jerry Gibbs

We have a double sink. One side has a garbage disposer. The disposer drain feeds across to the other sink drain. The disposer drain feeds into a diverter tee (1 1/2"). The disposer passes chunks of apple core which clog the narrow diverter channel. My wife thinks something is wrong if she cannot put apple cores in the disposer. Is there a different set up that is better? I hate to replace the disposer unless I know it is the problem. Do I need the diverter tee? Apparently putting the apple cores into the garbage under the sink is not an option. Thanks. Jerry

Re: ot- sink disposer

#2

Re: ot- sink disposer

Tony-Memphis

I just replaced ours. I bought one of the higher end InSinkerator's at Lowe's. It is very quiet and smooth running and I have already put several apple cores through it. I believe it has two or three stages of grinding. We like it much better than the old one (it was a cheapy). It was $169, so I think I'd just throw the cores in the garbage for that!

Tony

Re: ot- sink disposer

#3

Re: ot- sink disposer

Nat Robison

If getting a new wife is out of the question, see if you can get her to reconsider what goes down the sink. I'm sure you have a standard setup under the sink and right now, it's clogging based on what goes down the disposal. Other than replace what may be a perfectly functioning disposal with a bigger/more powerful one, you may not have many options.

My neighbor, a plumber, thinks disposals are the worst (from a plumbing standpoint) and that people send far too much down them. The guy doing a kitchen in my parents' house thinks the same.

I don't have your setup but I only try to send down whatever bits are in the sink.....no peels, cores, etc.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#4

Re: ot- sink disposer

Barry Irby

I have installed about a dozen disposers and several different brands. I have never really studied the interior layout of one but I can't figure how an apple core would survive the process. I would have to look but I thought what was going on was the waste was being pressed through a grater or screen.

Look at a new one and at yours. See if there is a hole big enough for an apple core. I am suspicious yours has rusted out or otherwise failed.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#5

Re: ot- sink disposer

William Duffield

If you think apple cores are a problem, you should try lobster shells. :(

I can't understand why apple cores should be a problem for any competent garbage disposal. That said, I also don't understand why you would waste the apple cores, the water and the energy to put them into the sewage system. Apple cores should be composted.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#6

Re: ot- sink disposer

Keith Newton

I can't imagine that an apple would really be a problem. I have to wonder how much water she uses to flush is out, I suspect too little. I would suggest that she have a glass of water on hand to dump in just as she turns it on, as well as having the water running.

As for the diverter tee (1 1/2") that you mention, if it does't maintain the full ID through both sides, I would try to find a different configuration.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#7

holes much smaller

Jerry Gibbs

Thanks all. I will try to look inside the disposer and also look at different plumbing configurations. The diverter tee looks like a regular tee divided by a slanting web. Chunks of the apple core are getting caught.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#8

Re: holes much smaller

David Yoho

During our kitchen upgrade earlier this year, the final thing I did was replace our original InSinkErator Badger 1 with a Badger 5. I noticed during reconfiguring the drain pipes from the old double sink to the new one that the diverter coming off the disposal side had a piece in it that reduced the 1 1/2" pipe in half. My guess is so that anything larger would not end up clogging things up beyond that but I'm not sure.

I replaced our original 1/3 horsepower unit with the 1/2 horse because it developed a leak at a point that couldn't be fixed. However, since going with the larger HP InSinkErator I have found it does a much better job of grinding things and no longer have the drain backups we would get once in a while.

If your wife must put apple cores down the disposal, my thinking is the unit is not doing its job properly for some reason. Perhaps the answer is as simple as a new unit. Certainly much cheaper than a new wife 8)

I wouldn't change the diverter pipe to a full open one because it must be there for a good reason. A plumber could certainly answer that question.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#9

Re: ot- sink disposer

John McGaw

I'd suggest that the disposer is not up to the task. If the old one is really 'old' I'd suggest a replacement with more power and multistage grinding. I just replaced my elderly unit with an "InSinkErator Evolution Essential 3/4 HP Household Garbage Disposer" (to quote their description). It is quieter and reduces everything to smaller sized bits than the old one. Even with the old one I ran virtually everything through it including lots of apple cores, peach pits, bones, banana peels, etc. with no problem as long as I didn't overfeed it and kept a good flow of water going before, during, and after the grind.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#10

Re: ot- sink disposer

Gary Smyth

Could the problem be the "T" configuration? What if it was a "Y" instead? Like others have suggested, I'd look into the size of the particles exiting the disposal. Add cold water before and ten seconds after the last crunch. I've not had problems with apple cores, but on the other hand, a large burned spaghetti and cheese casserole will make you cuss (a lot).

Re: ot- sink disposer

#11

Re: ot- sink disposer

Jerry Nicholson

About 50 years ago we tried grinding a bunch of corn shucks. I had to take out the disposer and the pipes to fix that one! My wife thinks anything food related can go down the disposer. A guy that came out a few years back to unclog the pipe where it exited the house said that in his opinion disposers were good for two things. (1) Gravy (2) Keeping him in business.

He also said that Thanksgiving was one of his most profitable days.

Jerry

Re: ot- sink disposer

#12

Re: getting down off my soapbox…

William Duffield

First, I should explain that I currently do not have a disposal because I have a septic system, not city sewage. In all the previous homes I've owned and rented, I did have disposals. Every one was an InSinkErator. I've replaced lots of them, too, usually because they developed a leak in the pot metal tank. There's nothing like acidic ground fruit and pork chop bones to destroy them in a hurry. I've always replaced them with more horsepower, more sound insulation and especially a stainless steel tank (no Harley-Davidson engine, however).

I just looked at the parts diagram for a cheap disposal at ereplacementparts.com. I now understand how one of these could easily fail and no longer be able to chew up apple cores. At issue is the interface between the stationary shredder and the rotating shredder assembly. (I am also aghast at the prices they are asking for these parts.) If the fins on the rotating part are abraded or broken, stuff just slips between them and the teeth of the fixed part. I'm not going to discuss this type any further, any more than I would discuss Fiat repair procedures.

The better design has two very sturdy steel blocks called slingers that freely rotate on sturdy steel axles and can easily move away from the fixed teeth if something large and hard gets involved. Centrifugal force throws them out, back into close proximity to the teeth, where they can take another bite. Also, the motor is reversible. If it gets hung up, when you stop it and restart it, it turns in the opposite direction. If it still doesn't turn when you flip the switch, there is an allen wrench that you can insert in the bottom of the shaft and turn it manually. This should be permanently stored in the tray attached to the inside of the sink cabinet door. Anyone who thinks they should put it anywhere else needs to be traded in. Teach your wife how to use it, and where to find the thermal overload reset button. If it's not chewing, you need to check to make sure the slingers swing freely. If your hands are as big as mine, you'll need a stick and a flashlight to do this. Otherwise, you can put your hand in and feel them, after you have unplugged the disposal or locked your helper in the pantry.

I'm confused about the discussion of "bypass." There are two plumbing connectors on the side of disposals. The important one is the large diameter pipe with the 90° bend that connects the outflow of the disposal to the waste pipe. I've never experienced any obstruction problems with this one (other than the lobster shell, corn husks or black walnut husks). The other connector is a hose connection for the outflow from the dishwasher, whose produce chewing capabilities are not as thorough as those of the disposal. It often has a knockout plug. The gorillas who install these things usually knock it out with the end of a screwdriver, which usually leaves some sharp obstructions, or even leaves the remains of the plug in the disposal chamber. If the plug is not threaded, you may need to smooth off the rough edges where it enters the disposal chamber.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#13

Re: getting down off my soapbox…

Tony-Memphis

The model we have will reverse itself if it gets stuck. Not sure if it has done that yet, but it seems lile a good idea. Funny you mention Thanksgiving....several years ago, we clogged the system with potato peels. I guess my wife fed it more than the water/flow/pipes could handle. Seems like we did that once with shrimp shells too. Believe it or not, our first one in the current abode was killed by a seed (orange or apple - can't recall). Got lodged in just the right place and locked the thign up and snapped the bolt that holds everything. The #2 just started making a real loud and scary noise. It was pretty rusted inside. The new model is all stainless.

Tony

Re: ot- sink disposer

#14

Re: fixed it *LINK*

William Duffield

:D


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UD1VCJvoDQ

Re: ot- sink disposer

#15

The only time...

David Yoho

The only times we had a backup problem while using the disposal was when we tried dumping leftover spaghetti down the drain. I think it gummed up the disposal's screen and the diverter pipe so much it wouldn't drain. We fixed it by not doing that anymore!!

Re: ot- sink disposer

#16

Disposer Story

Jerry Nicholson

Several decades ago I bought a Maytag disposer from the neighborhood hardware/everything store. It worked fine but one of the owners of the store told me about installing a new Maytag for his mother-in-law after bragging to her that you could shove a mop down a Maytag and that the Maytag would chomp it up without difficulty. After he installed the disposer his MIL said "OK - now prove it". He stuffed the mop down the disposer. Then he removed the disposer and spent a lot of time getting the mop out of it. He quit telling people that a Maytag would eat a mop but I doubt that his MIL ever let him forget that incident.

Jerry

Re: ot- sink disposer

#17

Also, have a discussion with your wife.

Keith Newton

In your original post, you said, "Apparently putting the apple cores into the garbage under the sink is not an option." This is a bit vague. It is one thing for the sink to clog on a single core, and quite another situation if your wife was processing a bushel of apples, where she could fill the disposal before turning on the faucet, then flipping the switch. The latter will coarsely grind the cores, but send them into the drain too viscous for gravity to take over and clear out everything.

My sister, who is a wonderful host for family gatherings seems to forget this every few years when she is preparing meals of about 20 ~ 30 people. She or her helpers would totally fill the disposal with broccoli stalks or something stringy before hitting the switch. Then of course by the time I'm called in, that side of the sink is now 3/4 full of water, and I seem to always be the one chosen to fix it. I had recently replace the old one with a new big powerful one.

Last time, it was so packed, that even after I had the pluming loose, the water couldn't even make it through the grinder. I told her to bump or jog it. This was not quite specific enough I guess, because she turned it on, and must have turn around or something, because after I yelled to turn it off, a lot of time elapsed. That crap comes out like Old Faithful at Yellowstone when the plumbing is off, with plenty of water above it. You would not believe what a mess that turned out to be. Make sure she understands that it can take it a little at a time, but not all at once, so don't wait to turn that switch on after it is full.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#18

Re: Disposer Story

Barry Irby

Many years ago we made about a hundred deviled eggs. (I can't remember why. Maybe the fleet was in or the Aliens had landed.) I boiled and pealed the eggs in the sink with cold water running on them. pushed all the shells into the disposer at once and turned it on. Enough egg shells make excellent aggregate. Locked the disposer solidly. Don't do that.

Re: ot- sink disposer

#19

thanks- appears I'm not alone