Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT- Car Maintenance

Posts

OT- Car Maintenance

#1

OT- Car Maintenance

Tom

My wife's car is presently at the dealer for a oil change, tire rotation and a factory notice repair. The service desk calls and suggest a transmission for $189. Mileage is 30,000.

So what are your thoughts??

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#2

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

john Veerkamp

In my opinion, transmission filter and fluid change at 30,000 is a bit sooner than necessary. I do this closer to 50,000. Other better versed in modern auto's may have a different idea.

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#3

Nope not needed on most cars

Dustmaker Mike

How old is the car is a bigger question. Most newer cars don't even have a dip stick anymore. I know my Toyota states in the manual the tranny fluid never needs to be changed. Now that I have 108,000 miles on it I am thinking about doing a complete fluid change with torque converter and all. Look in the owners man and see what it says about it.

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#4

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

David Yoho

You didn't say what year and model vehicle. Another consideration might be your driving conditions (a lot of dusty roads) or type of driving (mostly highway or city). One factor that could come into play regarding the life of transmission fluid is if there has been a problem with the cooling system where the car was driven a distance during an overheating situation, perhaps trying to get to the repair shop. Heat is the enemy of transmissions.

The service centers are good at suggesting add-on services to make more money for themselves. A look at the service manual for the correct service interval will tell you. A dealer should know this and not make the suggestion if it wasn't time for it. An independent shop will hope you don't know better and try to pry your money out of your pocket sooner than necessary.

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#5

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

Tom

my wife's car is a 2011 Ford Fusion with 30,000miles on it. No dusty road driving.

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#6

Looked it up

David Yoho

I looked up the scheduled service for your car under normal driving conditions at 30,000 miles. I didn't see anywhere where they mentioned transmission service. Here's what I found:

Recommended maintenance for your vehicle

Rotate and inspect tires; check wheel end play and turning noise

Inspect complete exhaust system and heat shields

Inspect and lubricate all non-sealed steering linkage,ball joints,suspension joints,half and drive-shafts and u-joints

Inspect cabin air filter, if equipped

Inspect brake pads/shoes/rotors/drums, brake lines and hoses, and parking brake system

Inspect cooling system and hoses

Perform multi-point inspection

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#7

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

Bill Howatt

By all means check your owner's manual and see what it says. I'm not as charitable about independents and not dealers wanting to do extra service.

My 2005 Dodge mini-van has 117,000 miles on it with no transmission servicing but that isn't your car.

Bill

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#8

Re: Looked it up

Bill Howatt

You might scan the manual and see if and when it is recommended so you are "prepared". The other thing they like to recommend is "injector service" which I have never found in my manual.

Bill

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#9

Change or transfusion of fluid?

Tom Dunlap

In years past the only way to 'change' fluid was to drop the pan, change the filter and replace the quart or so of fluid in the pan. There was LOTS still in the torque converter.

Now there is a system that works like a transfusion. A pump is connected via a T in the tranny coolant line near the radiator. Fresh fluid is then pumped through the system to flush out and really change the fluid. Its a much more thorough process.

30k does sound wayyyyyy to early. I'm guessing the 95% of the vehicles on the road today have never had their tranny fluid changed...even once!

Tom

PS...the tire shop I used to deal with would give me a great deal on seasonal air changes in my tires. You have to be careful about having summer air in tires during a Minnesota winter...hehehheheeh!

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#10

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

Chuck in Mtl.

my car with an automatic trans has 200k on it and no change of fluid ever. to me this is just a quick way for the dealer to pad his profit margin.

Re: OT- Car Maintenance

#11

Re: Change or transfusion of fluid?

Bill Howatt

You're right about a lot of oil being in the torque converter. When doing a transmission oil change, a place near me that had a good reputation for transmission work used to drill a hole in the "bottom" of the torque converter to drain the oil out of it. They then plugged the hole with a small threaded plug. That was many years ago.

Bill