Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

How due I determine value of an item?

Posts

How due I determine value of an item?

#1

Jim Orasky

How due I determine value of an item?

Jim Orasky

I need some help/advice. I made a spice chest as a wedding present for my son and his new wife. We happen to move shortly after I started the project in Dec 2011. I built our new home and shop myself so it took me a while to get back to the spice chest. I finally finished it in Aug 2014. I promptly mailed it to him (he lives in Japan) after packing it in what I thought was "bullet proof" packaging. You probably guessed by now it was damaged. It was dropped on the corner (from what had to be considerable height).The upper trim came off on one side (I had it tacked, not glued) and it may have separated the dovetailed carcase (I can't really tell from the pictures my son sent). I will visit him in Dec and hope to fix it for him. Since Sept I have been wrestling with the post office for the insurance. My problem is they want me to show proof of value. I made the thing and have no receipts to show it's value. The main carcase and door is cherry, the door is inlayed with their initials and wedding date, the drawers are fronted with book matched solid fiddleback ash. Any ideas an how I can document the value, it is in Japan so I can't take to anyone for a formal appraisal.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#2

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

Dick Coers

With no receipts, and I'm guessing no labor log book, I don't envy your task. Did they tell you what type of documentation they would accept? How much did you insure it for when you shipped it? I'm guessing the only way to establish value would be to get a auction house or antique appraiser(I know it's not old, but don't know where else to get a knowledgeable person) give you documentation to its value.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#3

Jim Orasky

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

Jim Orasky

They told me to consult their website for value. It is really for items that you buy, e.g. credit card statements, receipts etc. I insured it for 190.00 (that was the max for no additional cost).

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#4

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

Mark Nowicki

You insured it for $190, you did not want to pay more in insurance, probably because you did not think it was worth the extra cost.

Therefore, its value, according to you, is $190.

Am I missing something?

Mark

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#5

Jim Orasky

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

Jim Orasky

You are missing the basic issue, post office wants me to prove the value, be it 190 or 1.90. How can I do that?

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#6

Re: How do I determine value of an item?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Find someone selling them and use that price. There was a shop somewhere in or near Chester Co that sold them. Post over on Hand Tool forum and ask for an opinion of Warren who lives near that area and will know furniture makers in that region.

Try emailing Steve Latta who used to make them "Latta, Stephen" <Latta@stevenscollege.edu>

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#7

Jim Orasky

Re: How do I determine value of an item?

Jim Orasky

Bill -thanks for the info. I'll give it a try.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#8

Jim Orasky

Re: How do I determine value of an item?

Jim Orasky

My note to Steve Latta was rejected by his email host.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#9

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

mdclor

I had a similar, although not as significant, event. I used the receipt I got for the lumber I purchased as proof of value. You may or may not have any receipts for lumber from that date range. FWIW

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Tough one

Ellis Walentine

Value is subjective. Unless there is a contract showing the price of the deal, you may be stuck with just your cost of materials, if you still have your receipts for those. Nasty situation. Sorry you have to deal with this.

Ellis

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#11

Jim Orasky

Re: Tough one

Jim Orasky

I used wood that I had for years, waiting for the right project, so no receipts.

Guess I just have to chalk this one up.

Thanks to all for your input.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#12

Re: Tough one

paul in AZ

Picking up on the receipt thought, why don't you get a back dated work order for a little over amount of the insurance? Say $250. That could be enough to make them settle for the $190.

That won't cure the damage but may ease the pain.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#13

Re: How do I determine value of an item?

William Duffield

Curious. That's the email address I have for Steve.

You could try writing to him at

Steve Latta

Thaddeus Stevens College of Technology

750 East King Street

Lancaster, PA 17602

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#14

make up receipts

Jerry Gibbs

receipts for materials don't reflect the labor or fair market value. I had to register a 12' sailboat that I claimed I made myself. the clerk didn't bat an eye when I included drywall as a small boat material. this probably won't help. Jerry

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#15

Re: make up receipts

Dick Coers

I'm not sure suggesting back dated/fraudulent receipts is really the best advice. Just my opinion of course.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#16

i bet this will work

del schisler

here is what you can do , do a wood cost , of the amount of the wood you used, get list from a wood company , like a estimate , now go to a cabnet shop and ask if they could give you a estimate of labor cost to make the same or about the same chest, i had to do this a few time's , all you need is estimates from company's , they don't like people estimate's , i bet they will pay the bill , they need documents to back up their pay out at the post office, check back with a up date good luck

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#17

Agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is needed is a quote of something equivalent.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#18

Or......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

take pictures to some shop and get a quote to fix it.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#19

Re: Or......

Barry Irby

The Post Office is trying to avoid being scammed by someone over insuring something and then filing a big claim. They are always skeptical of "home Made" stuff. Too easy for somebody to put inflated values on it. So they try to limit the claim to the cost fo the materials. obviously this completely ignrs the value of your creativity and labor.

I think Bill has a good idea. Find some well established shops to give you estimates of the repairs based on the photos.

Reminds me of the situation my son got into. He totaled his car. We bought it back and had it repaired and inspected and put it back on the road. About three years alter he totaled it again. Insurance company did not want to pay off because it had already been totaled. We argued that they had been defrauding him by selling him insurance that they knew they had no intention of paying off on. They paid.

You could argue that you accepted the post office's $190 coverage and now they want to argue that its less.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#20

I am in same situation

dIZD

but only 1000 miles away. Is the insurance for the lessor of cost of repairs or total value, or do they want both? I have a friend who has a refinishing shop (and also builds furniture) and I will get a written quote for repair and also for building a similar piece. You should be able to find someone like that locally.

BTW, my piece is a mahogany tripod tilt top table and one leg was taken off. The sliding dovetail leg joint held fine, which I was glad to see - but the column was split off at the base of the joint.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#21

Jim Orasky

Re: i bet this will work

Jim Orasky

That's a great idea. Thanks

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#22

Good Opinion 


Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#23

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

TomD

If it was me, I probably would have insured it, since the insurance tends to be cheap, but I probably wouldn't claim on it. For 190, some part there of, it isn't worth the trouble to me, and there isn't any way of knowing who should get nailed for carelessness or something, stuff happens. Of course if you can get money, all the better.

Insurance isn't "coverage", it is a contract that we normally don't read, and the industry rarely pays out on, unless it is an area with defined, usually government mandated terms.

It is too bad the post office doesn't save everyone some time and just pre-approve value. This thing could be worth a lot of money in some cases, you are only insuring it at a fraction of the value, yet you have to later spend time proving it was worth even the fraction.

No mater what anyone offers as the value, I don't see how you can prove that someone else's estimate applies to your object. And a quote for repairs is not all that meaningful if there isn't any intention that the person who gives it will actually do it. The quote is normally relevant in establishing who gets the job, the work then goes ahead and is covered.

One thing that is expensive, and that will be required if the object needs anything more than cursory repair, is that the object will need refinishing. If done in a reasonably good shop, that alone will cost a lot more than 190. So depending on how they roll, you could perhaps justify that cost alone. But then even if the repair bill for whatever is say 9000 dollars, if the object is worth 20 bucks, you probably will find they are not required to pay for repairs in excess of the value of the object. It becomes a write off, and you are back to trying to prove what it is worth.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#24

I always hated those calls.......

Dick Coers

when I was in the woodworking business. Someone wants free estimate help, with no hope of making any money. All the time you loose time and money. They want to talk for 20 minutes on the phone explaining every detail, then tell you the same story when they show up at the shop. I even had an out of state shop call me to go talk to an unhappy commercial customer in my city. I did it, but the entire time I was only thinking that if the customer would have bought local, it would have been better for both of us. So if you do make that call for help, go out of your way to make it convienient for them. Suggest the end of the day so he doesn't have to stop production to talk. Maybe even leave the information so he can get back with you latter. That way he can work it in when doing other paper work. It's definitely a good will effort for the shop owner, so work nicely with them.

Re: How due I determine value of an item?

#25

USPS "Insurance"

Joe Pack

USPS insurance is a joke. It took over 3 months to settle a simple $50 claim, with repeated back and forth with a USPS claims office...and I had receipts!! After 3 months my local post master finally just settled it out of her local office.

Insuring with the USPS is a waste of money, and a pure profit center for the USPS.

Good luck, though.