I am planning to make a hope chest for one of my co-workers. There will be a lot of gluing involved due to material available, OLD air dried cherry that averages around six inches in width.
The lumber is such that I will probably end up with a thickness somewhere between five-eighths and one-half inch. I was thinking of using biscuits for reinforcing the joints but I seem to remember Norm Abrams saying that after a period of time they tend to show through to the surface.
Is this a problem with all woods? Some woods? Is (gasp!) Norm wrong?
Since it is my intention to make this look like something out of the 19th century, should I just go ahead and forsake modern techniques as a matter of principle?
Work responsibilities (I can’t run any machines that will keep me from hearing a phone or hand-held radio) will keep me from doing much beyond planning for another week or so.
The problem with biscuits is that they swell. I think they are compressed when they are installed and swell when wetted by the glue which forces them to fill the slot very tightly and may bulge the surface a bit. Then you have two possibilities. If you quickly level and sand the panels and they swell afterward, you could end up with bulges. If you level and sand the panels after they have swelled, and then they dry out and shrink back a bit you end up with very shallow depressions. Either way the effect may be so slight you can only see it in raking light after you apply the finish. Thinner stock aggravates the effect.
In a long grain to long grain glue up you are discussing the biscuits add little or nothing to the strength. And alternative is to use the biscuits but do not glue them. Just insert them into dry slots and let them help align the boards. Be sure to glue around them so as not to have a skip in the glue line. I have done this many times on big glue ups working by myself. No ill effects noted.
I used to put one near the middle and one at each end, but I learned that the glue responds better to pressure than impact and now I skip the ones at the ends. I was trying to pound the pieces into perfect alignment and they does not work well at all after the glue has become even a little viscous. At the ends In can install a batten on each side and use c-clamps to press the pieces flat. Its surprising how little pressure it takes to make them slide, even after the clamps are fairly tight across the panel. (be sure to wax you battens or apply packing tape or plastic to the edges to keep from gluing them to the panel.)
I think the curved cauls across the paneLs might be useful and I am sure there are those that love them, but I have never had a glue up get far enough away from me to bother making any.
None of this is a good substitute for excellent stock prep and good stock. But, sometimes the best laid plans go a little astray.
Also, be SURE to put the biscuits in locations you KNOW you will not be cutting through later, exposing them. DAMHIKT
i think that is kind of thin for biscuts? use a good glue and just glue the panels togother, i have done this before and it works for me , and i have used biscuts also, for me it just take more time and i din't know if it is worth it , a good glue works for me also, i use tite-bond 2 and also weld-bond which i like better , their shouldn't be any stress on the panel's . or not much i think you should be ok eather way you go
If you are contemplating using biscuits for edge gluing- don't. If you edge glue one board at a time, with care you can get near perfect alignment.
If the biscuits are intended for some other joinery it needs to be described. Personally, I never found much use for biscuits except in joining plywood.
If a biscuit is too tight, I put them on the floor, and tap hit them with a hammer on the face of the biscuit to thin them. You can shrink them in a toaster oven, or sand them a little. Any problem from swelling comes from working the wood too quickly after the glue up. Barry gave you good advice. Just let it sit a while after glue up and it will be fine. For the record, I never use them for edge glue up, and I've used thousands of biscuits. I bought into the system when all you could buy were a Lamello or Elu. I bought the Elu. When they discontinued them, I bought another one. Still new, unopened in the box. Collector item?
They will not generally re-enforce a joint. They can't make bad joints good, and good joints are strong enough. However, they can be useful in edge joints at times. I agree that when you are getting a good tight fit with them, you shouldn't glue them, particularly in the thickness wood you are considering using them in. I would probably not use them in the 1/2" they displace too much glue area and could even allow a light pattern to show.
Why use them? well there can be defects, and they are useful in certain alignment situations, where the clamps can't keep the wood in line. Yeah that is a kludge, but sometime those are the cards.
The are good for lots of stuff, imagination being the main limit.
Just the other day I was contemplating putting the stringers in this motor boat I am building. I will have to glass them in and figured that some kind of registration would be good. I could blow the large biscuits right through the 1/4" bulkheads to hold the stringers on either side. Then I remembered I had glassed the bulkheads already, and I won't cut into glass for health reasons.
Another situation I used them in I was doing a wedged scarf in some light wood, and I needed a registration key. I just glued one side in and the other was demountable. It was for a musician who needed a very portable stand for a large Koto (?). I had to put one of the biscuits in that case into a mortise cut with a chisel. Worked great.
Obviously the common uses are fixed shelves, and face frames and any 90 degree joints like raise panel doors, or saw horse, etc... The biscuits are much better than dowels at times. Super fast to put in and strong enough so long as one understands the limitations.
Franz Klauzs has a video on using them to make funiture. I always feel a little dirty when using them conventionally, and they are obsolete with Dominos out there, except I won't be buying one of those till the clones come in, which I may not live to see.