Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

wood rot

Posts

wood rot

#1

wood rot

Jerry Roberts

I am attempting to replace an existing wooden fence in the back yard. My question is, how do I slow down the rot in buried pt 4x4s. depth is about 2 ft on Fla. sand. My first attempt,years ago, I used creosote which slowed down the rot but in a few years they fell over. Plus I got a severe face and arm burn from that stuff. Any ideas? I even thought bout using Reynolds wrap tin foil and sealing it well. Would concrete prevent it as well? If it wont,I I wont use concrete. Just thought someone out there might have experienced my problem. Thanks. Jerry

Re: wood rot

#2

Re: wood rot

Ralph Lipeles

In 1947 my parents had a picket fence built around their property. The posts were 4 by 4 cedar dipped in creosote and then set in concrete. The post rotted out and the concrete made repairs very difficult. I would just use pressure treated 4 by 4's set directly into the ground.

Re: wood rot

#3

Re: wood rot

Barry Irby

My Grandfather said "only a city slicker would set a post in concrete." He died when I was seven, almost sixty ears ago. The barns he built on the farm he bought during WWII are still there. The house that was no the farm when he bought it fell down.

I would check around and see if you can find a supplier that supply PT wood for docks. There are differing grades of PT and some of the lightly treated stuff is not meant for soil contact. Find stuff meant for marine use.

And I would dig the holes a few inches too deep, put some gravel in the bottom set the post in the hole and back fill with gravel. Not round pebbles, broken stone. The stone will drain quickly and help keep the posts dry. You will find the gravel locks up nicely with a minimum of tamping and makes for nice solid posts.

Concrete will give you nice solid posts, but will accelerate rot and make repairs difficult.

Some of the newer environmentally friendly treated wood is treated with ACQ and some with Borates. The borates are water soluble and not suitable for ground contact. The ACQ stuff is very corrosive to metal. Use rated fasteners.

If you cut the posts to length, don't bury the cut end. Or get some of the chemical and treat the cut ends. Also, select posts that do not enclude heart wood. Heart wood is somewhat naturally decay resistant, but can not be treated.

Re: wood rot

#4

Re: wood rot

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Buy treated posts for below ground use. You did not say what kind of posts you desire. If round go to a farm store to buy them. A well treated post will last decades. Cost no object, then get posts prepared for water immersion at your coastal dock supply store.

You may have a farm fencing store near-by. Buying there is a good bet. Or, if you want square post find a place that caters to pole barn builders.

There are many levels of treatment. Just because the stuff at Lowes is greenish yellow does not mean it is treated for burial.

Re: wood rot

#5

Re: wood rot

George Koch

Jerry, I would dig the holes about a foot deeper than the bottom of the posts, fill the hole up to the bottom of the post with #2 stones, set the pressure treated 4x4s in and then backfill to grade with more #2 stone. The stones create a drainage and leaching area to keep the damp sand away from the wood. Unless you are setting these posts below the water table, then, nothing will keep the dampness away from them!

Re: wood rot

#6

Re: wood rot

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I put a new deck on my place 20+ years ago. Instead of concrete and sonatubes for the posts, I used PT 4x4's that were double-coated with roofing tar and set on concrete footings (3' in-ground), then back-filled with 1" bluestone. Deck and posts are as solid as ever.

PS: I also used Cuprinol (the wood boat "green stuff") on the posts before applying the tar

Re: wood rot

#7

Re: wood rot

Basil

PVC....it's all the rage around here.

Re: wood rot

#8

installation enhancements

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I live on a farm and as a result I have a lot of post experience. At least in these parts my post failures are always at the earth- air interface. This is the place that the post stays wet and there is oxygen to support growth of post eating organisms. Hence, diddling with the details of the post 2' below ground would be a waste of time for my conditions.

Additionally, coating the post is a short term benefit. As soon as the coating biodegrades whatever lies beneath is subject to attack. For this reason below ground posts are treated to the core.

Re: wood rot

#9

Re: installation enhancements

Jerry Roberts

I just got thru unloading a half ton of recycled concrete pebbles from my pickup. Going to fill hole with it around 4x4. I sure thank everyone for the good advice. Couldn't have attempted this job without it. J.R.

Re: wood rot

#10

Re: Fixing

TomD

My parents had a fence that had rotted entirely off at about ground level. This meant it would be difficult to remove the old posts, possibly impossible to drive those metal spike post holders in, that they wanted to use. Angry talk went back and forth over the years. I wanted to start afresh, they wanted a very time consuming job done with bailing wire. As you have probably seen, there is a new product that consists of a U chanel stake in steel that one hammers into the ground and that bridges the brokes section, and splints top to bottom, then one nails the posts off. For a kludge, it was a solid one. It went very fast. No disassembly was requires. No clearing away of the neighbours bruch (the neighbour is 105 and his daughter has cancer) so they weren't in a position to help. Heartily recommend it for those situations where you can't do the right thing. Of course it only works for soil types where the rot occurs at groundish level.


Re: wood rot

#11

Re: Fixing

Barry Irby

Can you post a name and or model number and where to buy for these? I can imagine situations where they would allow you to get the remaining life out of the rest of the fence before replacing the whole thing.

Re: wood rot

#12

Re: wood rot

William Duffield

Can't do much about your climate >( I lived in Florida for 4 decades. In addition to the stone instead of concrete advise, you need to realize that the water gets in through the top of the post. Sealing the bottom only, or setting it in concrete, traps the water, and keeps it from getting out the bottom. You need to cap the top of the post with something waterproof. Copper or aluminum comes to mind, but you can also use epoxy, covered with a painted wooden cap with horizontal grain.

If you want wooden posts, seriously consider ipe, or purpleheart, or even black locust. A long time ago, the Miami parks department (before it was Miami-Dade) built all their picnic tables from purpleheart. If it weren't for the splinter problem, they would still be there, in spite of over 60" of rain a year, intense sun, high humidity and temperatures that reach the 90's 9 months of the year.

Re: wood rot

#13

Re: Fixing - E-Z Mender *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Barry,

I found this link for the company that makes them, the splicing device is called "E-Z Mender". Home Depot caries them around here.

I've never used them, but it looks like a handy quick fix to tide things over until better fence post replacing weather, though they cost near the same as a new fence post.

Bob in NJ


E-Z Mender

Re: wood rot

#14

Re: Fixing - E-Z Mender

Barry Irby

Thanks, Looks like something that might be useful once in a while. I have never see them at Home Depot, but I have not looked either. Might have helped to know such a thing existed. Now that I think of it I reinforced a rail post recently by driving two aluminum angles in beside it. One at each outside corner. Worked well.

Re: wood rot

#15

Re: Fixing - E-Z Mender

TomD

I got mine at home depot, not cheap (I wasn't paying), but 20 bucks for two. Still solved this long standing problem (of not standing). Really easy to use. We had done a bunch of other things, and discussed all kinds of alternatives. It feels as strong now as the day it was built, and I think it will last 20 years.

I'm in Canada, which is a bit like living in the 1920s, but up here I first started seeing them in 2013.

Re: wood rot

#16

Re: installation enhancements

Barry Irby

Bill is right about the earth air interface. they rot there because they get and stay just wet enough. I believe but have no proof that filling the holes with gravel allows them to dry quickly and not rot as rapidly. Deeper in a typical hole they stay too wet for the rot fungi to thrive. The gravel under the post serves as a sump to hold the excess water until it perks away.