Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OK don't call me STUPID

Posts

OK don't call me STUPID

#1

OK don't call me STUPID

Marty Rose

I have been watching and participating in W/C a long time. I have looked with distain at all the post's RE: Dust Masks. Well at this time of my life I've got to say I need one. What is a good one that will not make me look like I've just stepped out of a Star-Wars movie. I was cutting some Santos Mahogany,and a day later I thought I had the Flu. Dr. visit after Dr. visit confermed No Flu just respertory problems. Still hacking and other problems. I did this again on Monday and the same symptoms came back. So what is a good mask to wear,I wear glasses don't need any fog'ng up. Thanks, Marty (NOT STUPID)

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#2

Dear NOT STUPID

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Definition of mental illness: Doing something again you know to have bad results after the first time but while expecting different results. :D (paraphrasing A. Einstein)

A. Simplest remedy: Find a different wood to which you're not allergic knowing that your reactions to the same stuff will get worse with each exposure.

B. If you insist on courting anaphylactic shock, spring for a 3M Airstream (about $800). You can get even more rec's over on the turning board from the guys who insist on playing with toxic materials because they're so pretty.

PS: Do it again and all bets are off on the "NOT STUPID" deal. ;)

PPS: Keep in mind that whatever mask/filter, etc. you choose, it will be rendered worthless as soon as you take it off and expose yourself to the dust the will be on your clothes, in your hair, and will be floating in your shop's air for hours after you stop working.

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OK don't call me STUPID *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Link below. You may have to try several different brands/styles to find one that works well for YOU, but in general, you'll want one with a valve. I also don't see the point in a N95 mask, so I'd go with a N100.

Jason


N100 mask with valve

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#5

Re: Dear NOT STUPID

Barry Irby

I agree with Mark. Some woods are allergens and some are sensitizers. If you get a mild reaction, consider it a warning. Each exposure is likely to get a bigger reaction. I'm not an expert on this, but this could be serious and expensive. If your lungs reacted this time, next time it may be your eyes, sinus, arm pits and any other moist spots.

I am pretty sure you will not develop any "resistance", more likely to go the other way and get MUCH worse.

Plenty of other woods out there.

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#6

Re: OK don't call me STUPID *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

This is the one I use. I wear glasses and don't have a problem with fogging even under a face shield.


3M Half Facepiece Respirator

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#7

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

John in NM

I use 3M disposable masks with the valve, just buy them at Home Depot or where ever, two pack is $7 I think. The valve makes all the difference in the world, I would hardly ever wear one before trying those.

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#8

I kinda like these,

Keith Newton

I find I can make them fit my face better, plus when I want to come up for air, or answer the phone, I can just pull the loop off one ear, leaving it hanging on the other, so it doesn't get lost.

The ones in the link are thicker than some others that I've used, and like better, but still are the accordion fold type. The thinner ones allow easier breathing, but still catch the size particles from sanding.

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#9

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

Rum

+1 to the 3M half face mask. Its more comfortable and fits better on me than the disposables and the price is competitive in the long run with the cartridge swaps.

I tried both the 6000 and the 7500 and imho the 7500 wins hands down

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B008MCUT86

It has a silicon ring so its less irritating and fits tighter than the 6000, worth the extra $10 imho.

The other nice thing is you can swap the filters if you're doing vox - P100 for particulates and then easy to swap for a gas/vapor cartridge (I tend to use lower vox finishes but it was nice to use when re-painting the house :D)

It fits nicely under the uvex faceshield, doesn't interfere with my glasses and I have no problems breathing with it. The bottom drain is nice as well when its hot & sweaty out since it clears moisture without any hassle.

I tried the Trend supplied air but it made my neck hurt after a 6-9 hour day of turning and I didn't end up plugging it in all the time when I was done so personally didn't like it as much. Others say they have no problems with it so ymmv.

Also make sure to hang the mask inside or otherwise out of the dust area when you're done or you'll be cleaning it out later .. don't ask me how I know this :\

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

#10

Re: OK don't call me STUPID

Hank Knight

Marty,

A dust mask may give you some relief, but it's probably not along term solution for you. I had increasingly severe sinus and respiratory problems for several years that were clearly caused by my woodworking machines. My problem was with the fine dust that was getting into my respiratory system. I finally bit the bullet and installed a good dust collection system that captures most of the fine dust and chips at the source. My problem went away. I still use a dust mask if I'm working on I something that I can't hook up to my DC, like some routing and sanding operations; but my DC handles 90% or more of the work in my shop.

If you're having real allergy problems, they will likely get worse. Your body will likely develop an increasingly severe response to whatever it is you're allergic to, and even the smallest contact will trigger a reaction. The more you can eliminate contact with or inhalation of the offending dust, the better off you'll be. Think about a serious DC system. It gets at the root of the problem and is much more effective than a dust mask in most situations. Unlike a dust mask, a DC system gets rid of the dust in the air, so it's not still floating around when you take off your dust mask.