Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Is this stupid?

Posts

Is this stupid?

#1

A.J. Hamler

Is this stupid?

A.J. Hamler

OK, this may be a dumb question, but I ask in all seriousness.

You know how exposure to sunlight darkens wood -- cherry, poplar, oak, etc. Would I be a total knucklehead if I thought you could speed this up by tossing a finished project into a tanning booth/bed for a half hour or so?

-- A.J.

Re: Is this stupid?

#2

Re: Is this stupid?

Brad

Yes, assuming infrared is the darkening agent.

Re: Is this stupid?

#3

Not Nessessiarily

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

While cherry will darken somewhat from just heat, the real culprit is UV. Keep in mind however, that UV will have the reverse effect on Walnut in which the heartwood will lighten and the sapwood will darken due to differences in the extractives.

The "suntan" treatment (in a box or on the porch) should be done after sanding and before finish is applied. Most finishes will inhibit UV somewhat; some will actually block it for a period of time. If you have to resand the piece, you'll have to "re-tan" it as well because the effected layer of the wood is very thin and can be sanded off easily.

All that said, what's the big rush?

Re: Is this stupid?

#4

Not Stupid

Yonak

I would say it's the ultraviolet spectrum that has more to do with the darkening of wood than infrared. That said, there have been discussions on the subject on some discussion boards.

Also, there's an article in fine Woodworking Magazine about tanning beds and darkening cherry wood and Rockler.com has a short article on it.

I'm not including any direct links as it's, likely, contrary to the CoC.

It's not a dumb question at all. It sounds intriquing. One article suggest darkening just some portions of the wood for, possibly, corrective or decorative reasons.

Re: Is this stupid?

#5

Ellis Walentine

Re: Is this stupid?

Ellis Walentine

I have heard of instrument makers darkening soundboard in a tanning booth as you describe. If I recall correctly you need a lot of wattage to get the effect.

Ellis

Re: Is this stupid?

#6

Re: Is this stupid?

Barry Irby

Like the others above, I think its the UV that tans the wood. I know almost nothing about tanning beds, but have heard that they have filtered out or somehow eliminated either the UV-A or UV-B, which ever one was supposed to cause cancer. I wonder if that is the part that would darken the wood? You could try it and see.

Re: Is this stupid?

#7

Re: Not Stupid

Brad

I'm stupid! Of course it's ultraviolet! Infrared is one of my cooking ovens so it's good for cooking the wood.

Brad

Re: Is this stupid?

#8

Re: Is this stupid?

Jesse Cloud

Just bring your cherry by the house. Up here in the New Mexico mountains the UV is intense. I can darken cherry in one afternoon by a sunny window.

Re: Is this stupid?

#9

Intensity of UV Rays

Yonak

This brings up a question in my mind. I have a cherry table sitting by a south facing window. The years have bleached the legs and one edge of the top of the table badly. The legs, on one side, are almost white.

..So I guess too much ultraviolet radiation will do just the opposite. I wonder if it's the intensity of the radiation or the repeated exposure over a long period of time that will turn a darkening process to a lightening one. I wonder if the more intense sunlight in your area, Jesse, would be productive or counter-productive.

Re: Is this stupid?

#10

Re: Intensity of UV Rays

john Veerkamp

Is it possible that the table is not cherry but cherry stained other wood? My experience is that cherry always darkens.

Re: Is this stupid?

#11

Sun Bleaching

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not to rule that out, but I would also suspect damage to the finish (as well/instead). I've had cherry getting direct sun for a good 10 years but with no lightening at all. Granted, having finished with oil-based dye under shellac under Target PSL waterborne, this stuff may be more UV resistant than otherwise.

Re: Is this stupid?

#12

Re: Is this stupid?

John in NM

You can get the same effect by wiping the wood with a weak base solution. Ammonia, lye, lime, etc.

Re: Is this stupid?

#13

Re: Is this stupid?

don stephan

Baking soda darkened cherry and red oak, to my great surprise, when I was trying to neutralize oxalic acid.

Re: Is this stupid?

#15

Re: Intensity of UV Rays

David Yoho

What you are reporting sounds totally opposite from my experience. I have two customers who have cherry pieces I built for them. One is a small table with a figured cherry top and the other is a fireplace surround and mantle where all the moldings are cherry. The table sits just under a south-facing picture window and the fireplace is just across from a bank of windows facing south. In both instances the cherry darkened quickly and has stayed that way for many years now.

I have to wonder why you are seeing the opposite behavior. That's interesting!

Re: Is this stupid?

#16

A.J. Hamler

Re: Is this stupid?

A.J. Hamler

Thanks, guys! I thought this might work, but it's good to be sure be fore I try it. If I had time I'd just set this out in the real sunshine and wait, but it's for some photography that I need to do now. I've Photoshopped stuff before to simulate it, but have never been pleased with the results.

And, no, I don't have a tanning bed. -- the sun and I are not on the best of terms -- but they have one where I get my hair cut, which I was planning to do this week anyway, hence the timing of the question. "Just take a little off the top and, oh, would you toss this in the tanning bed while you're cutting."

Re: Is this stupid?

#17

Might Surprise You

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

how L-o-n-g it will take to tan your cherry this way. Best take a book along.

Re: Is this stupid?

#18

Re: Is this stupid?

John in NM

Another base, though weaker than the others, IIRC. I only tried the lime since I had a barrel of lime plaster outside when I was messing with this :D

Re: Is this stupid?

#19

Similarly....

John in NM

The shop I worked for did a rare cabinet job - owner didn't like doing them but this was a big one. Cherry throughout the house and painted alder in the laundry room.

The cherry we were getting was very pale, and as one might predict, an alder door stile got mixed in with the cherry ones :O No one noticed until all the cabinets had been installed and we were finishing up details. Lucky for us the cabinet it was on got lots of Phoenix sun, so it only took a few weeks to start showing - cherry got dark, alder stayed light. Good thing it was a door and not a face frame! -- Easy fix.

Re: Is this stupid?

#20

A.J. Hamler

Re: Might Surprise You

A.J. Hamler

Actually, it's a particularly yellow batch of poplar. Sun will turn that to a golden brown. All I really need is a bit of tanning to take that yellow edge off and I'm, well, golden.

Re: Is this stupid?

#21

Re: Intensity of UV Rays

Doug Wolf

I've got a house full of Cherry cabinets and assorted turned pieces of Cherry and every one exposed to a south facing window has quickly darkened and then bleached out to almost white on the side toward the window. Maybe the high elevation of Colorado and the higher UV has something to do with it. I'll guarantee it's Cherry.

Re: Is this stupid?

#22

A.J. Hamler

Hey, it worked

A.J. Hamler

Got a haircut yesterday, tossed the project into the tan-o-matic thing they had there. Didn't really time it, just put it in right when I got there and while I waited my turn in the chair, through the haircut, and took it back out after I was done and paid for the haircut. Maybe 40 minutes or a little less.

The change wasn't drastic, but it was just enough to get out some of the yellow and replace it with a subtle brownish hue, which was the goal.

I forgot to put the goggles on it, though, so I suspect the project will have vision issues in the future.

A.J.

Re: Is this stupid?

#23

Bet it looks good in a Bikini, though! (nm)


Re: Is this stupid?

#24

Oh Yeah . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A real carpenter's dream :D

Re: Is this stupid?

#25

Re: Leather also tans..

TomD

just like wood. at least veg tan leather does, and it is tanned with high tanic acid materials, like wood bark, or more likely chemical today. So is it the tanin; can you accelerate it by adding tanin directly as is done with ebonizing; can you use the lye treatment to accelerate the leather tan, though it would presumably be harmful to a finished leather. Speaking of which you can accelerate the wood darkening process with lye also. I am sure there are many threads, hereabouts.