Re: not good reasons
Lars Parrington
ebd, i'm sorry that you've had a bad experience with this technique. without knowing all the deatils of what you've tried, i can't comment on what might have gone wrong. in any case, i didn't make this up. it is commonly used, and it provides good adequate results for lost of woodworkers.
i personally don't have a ton of experience with it. i have only used it a few times. i have done it with boards longer than 12", although only up to about 36". i don't see why longer boards would be a problem, but i can imagine it getty hairy if your board is too short.
i haven't tried it with any tropical woods. it's been a while, but i think i used it on cherry and on walnut.
i didn't say the result was perfect, or that the two cuts would perfectly coplanar. it does require a bit of planing to clean up after the cut, just like a bandsaw cut does (at least for a standard 14" saw with a steel blade). in my experience, the amount of extra wood removed for this cleanup is less than for bandsaw cleanup.
i'm no safety expert, so i won't comment on the likelyhood of kickback. i would avoid trying it with severely case hardened wood.
if you're still in doubt, take a look at some youtube videos showing how it is done. you'll at least see that it can work well, and maybe you'll be able to learn what you were doing wrong.