Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

Posts

How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#1

craigd

How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

craigd

This is a duplicate of my post over at WoodNet but the same topic was raised here so I thought it would merit a repost.

A while back there was a thread on PEC blems and how good were they? I have a double and just made the tooling to check for squareness so I gave them a whack, along with old Starrett, Lufkin and Union combos. I used two Mitutoyo grade B (<= 0.00130" @ 5") squares for reference. The PEC and Union matched the Mits and the combos were close enough (and are designed to be correctable if I cared).

The link is to a short youtube video where I do the testing.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FT5p17VMK0Q

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#2

"PEC,  Union ,  Mits "? what are we talking about?


Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#3

Brands

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of squares.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO

Ellis Walentine

That sure is a baffling video. Can't see much of anything. But, the comment section says that Mit Class Bs are off by a thousandth at 5". I can get my tablesaw fence closer than that. My question is, what is good enough for woodworking? I know you make precision planes and stuff, Craig, so maybe that level of precision is important. My Starrett combos get me where I need to be.

It wouldn't hurt to know which brands are reliably more accurate than others, but price may enter into it, too, and how consistent is that accuracy from one to the next within a particular brand?

Interesting topic.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#5

Clint Searl

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO

Clint Searl

I fail to appreciate the relevance of the absolute "squareness" of a tool that is used to mark a material that is inherently dimensionally unstable well beyond the variations exhibited by the squares in the video.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#6

Relevance

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not withstanding the material, there are those who take pride in working to such tolerances. Perhaps not you, certainly not me ;) , but their goal and effort nonetheless.

Then, too, there are those who buy such "tools" only to keep them wrapped in velvet and climate-controlled cabinets, not to be handled without white gloves. I seem to remember there is medication for that.

:D

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Relevance

Clint Searl

The very nature of wood renders it impossible to work to such tolerances. I'll continue using my '60s vintage Craftsman, though I shudder to think of how out of square all my projects have been. The edges on my Starrett are too sharp, anyway. Nyuk nyuk

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#8

I'm Impressed!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Mine's a no-name.

[Haven't gotten a call about anything falling apart, yet]

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#9

The point?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would seem that the point could be that if some assemblage of squares is essentially equivalent then one can shop by price and convenience. That is useful information, though I never heard of the brands mentioned.

The first 4" square I got from LV was unacceptable even by my building standards and I returned it. Apparently on round two they got it right and the replacement is good enough as far as I can determine it. This experience suggests that checking is important.

Wife goes nuts when I weigh recipe ingredients to 1 or 0.1 gram (depending on scale used). It may not be important but I have the capability, it doesn't take any more time and it keeps my lab skills honed. I can do it so I do do it. The same may be said for square checking.

Some more time spent making the post relevant to typical woodworking would have make the post more useful.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#10

Re: I'm waiting for

ChuckInND

a cabinet saw sales pitch.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#11

craigd

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO

craigd

>Can't see much of anything.

Sorry about that - I got in as tight as I could. If you have a large screen (mine is 23") it is better.

>comment section says that Mit Class Bs are off by a thousandth at 5".

Actually, it can be off by that amount to meet spec (the spec is 0.00080" + blade length/10,000). How do you know your tablesaw fence is that square? Over what distance? That is the idea, to be able to repeatedly verify an object in relation to a known standard, whatever that standard might be.

To beat the horse a bit more, how do you know that Starrett is good? Drop it a couple of times and maybe not. Or use it and the little bumpers in the stock that keep it square wear down and if the wear is uneven, the blade tilts (I've seen this). Starrett is a good brand because they publish the spec they meet and we can trust them to meet it.

I did this to test my new testing tool and I like numbers. I also do metal work where sub thousandths of an inch matter (the eye can see gaps of well under a thousands of an inch - light will actually start to turn blue as the longer wave lengths are filtered).

Do we care in wood working? Sometimes and we often do work to those tolerances without measuring. If you cut a tennon out of square, a couple of thou is very obvious during fit up - that gap sticks out like a sour thumb. Or you clamp it tight and that long rail doesn't run level; cut it 0.040" out (over 5", which is half a degree) and it will be almost a quarter inch at 2'.

Errors like these are obvious and easy to correct by eye; if it fits good enough, it is good enough.

On the other hand, Bill Tindall posted data on gaps, glue and strength. There, it can be hard to see or judge the gap so you gotta measure to ensure the glue is actually acting as an adhesive.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#12

craigd

Re: How square are PECs?

craigd

Wood is dimensionally stable for that short time we are working it. Once assembled, if we did a good job, it is one big piece of wood and can move all it wants and not fail.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#13

craigd

Re: Relevance

craigd

>The very nature of wood renders it impossible to work to such tolerances

Uhhh, do you do inlay? How about edge glue ups? Gaps of a few thousandth are visible. If you ever hold a joint up to the light to check it, you are working to much finer tolerances than those square are good for.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#14

craigd

Re: The point?

craigd

>Some more time spent making the post relevant to typical woodworking would have make the post more useful.

Ouch.

The work you have posted shows you work to these tolerances even if you don't need precision tools to do it. Different strokes for different folks.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#15

Re: The point?

Tony - Memphis

I'm an engineer. I used to design/make race car parts to extremely tight tolerances. So, that's just the type of measurements I am used to. I like my Starret stuff. It is very useful for tool setup and verification. And since I have it, I use it on my wood too. Why not?!? I also use dial indicators, calipers, etc. in my shop.

Funny, the hand tool folks are always talking in measurements that can ONLY be measured by these types of tools! Imagine that!

Tony

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#16

Clint Searl

Wood never sleeps


Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#17

clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Perhaps I was the only person clueless about what your post was about, but likely not. And a statement of the objective of making the measurements could have made it more clear why the typical woodworker could use the information. The brevity made the post too easy to overlook its relevance.

You are correct, that to get a case to come up square when it is assembled the pieces need to be square to withing a few thousandths of an inch on a case side of a foot.

That said I never use a square to determine if the assembly is square. Measuring diagonals is more reliable. Tiny out of flatness of any side gives the appearance of out of square to the square.

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#18

Re: How square are PECs?

Mark Nowicki

Wood is dimensionally stable for that short time we are working it.



Mine is measured with calendars.

I don't need too many, only those with zeros.

Mark

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO *LINK*

#19

Re: How square are PECs? *VIDEO

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As a retired Engineer that worked in an industry that manufactured small parts using a lot of automated assembly and test equipment, I often was responsible for measuring in .0001" tolerances. The last couple of years I was the QS-9000 and ISO Management Representative for our plant.

When measuring in tolerances that tight, your measurement tools must be 10X the acceptable tolerance (+/-.00001). In order to do those measurements both the product being measured and the measuring equipment must be in a controlled temperature for a length of time to stabilize.

I do have a Mitutoyo certified square used for reference only - it is kept in a box and used to verify my working Starrett and another machinist square. However these squares are used to set up and verify my machines. I have dial indicators both (.001 and .0001) with cast iron stands and magnetic holders as well as accurate Mitutoya and Starrett digital calipers.

Actually the only way I would attempt to measure a square accurately would be to use a cylinder square. When they are used on a granite surface plate it is quite easy to use a light source to determine if the square is accurate.

Personally I believe if my machines are set up properly (and I am anal about that) - saw blade perpendicular to the table, morticing jig and tenon cutter properly aligned, Joiner fence at proper angle, planer head parallel to the table, etc - I don't have to check my wooden part carefully. If it fits and the assembly is square by measuring diagonal, it is ok.